Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Shoot the shit with other metal folk. Free discussion on any topic that doesn't suit the other forums. Avoid mentioning carpet.
Post Reply
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Meat Engine »

...pedophiles remain in good standing with the Catholic church.


Last November, a 27-year-old woman was admitted to St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix. She was 11 weeks pregnant with her fifth child, and she was gravely ill. According to a hospital document, she had "right heart failure," and her doctors told her that if she continued with the pregnancy, her risk of mortality was "close to 100 percent."



The patient, who was too ill to be moved to the operating room much less another hospital, agreed to an abortion. But there was a complication: She was at a Catholic hospital.



"They were in quite a dilemma," says Lisa Sowle Cahill, who teaches Catholic theology at Boston College. "There was no good way out of it. The official church position would mandate that the correct solution would be to let both the mother and the child die. I think in the practical situation that would be a very hard choice to make."



But the hospital felt it could proceed because of an exception — called Directive 47 in the U.S. Catholic Church's ethical guidelines for health care providers — that allows, in some circumstance, procedures that could kill the fetus to save the mother. Sister Margaret McBride, who was an administrator at the hospital as well as its liaison to the diocese, gave her approval.



The woman survived. When Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted heard about the abortion, he declared that McBride was automatically excommunicated — the most serious penalty the church can levy.



"She consented in the murder of an unborn child," says the Rev. John Ehrich, the medical ethics director for the Diocese of Phoenix. "There are some situations where the mother may in fact die along with her child. But — and this is the Catholic perspective — you can't do evil to bring about good. The end does not justify the means."



Ehrich adds that under canon or church law, the nun should be expelled from her order, the Sisters of Mercy, unless the order can find an alternative penalty. Ehrich concedes that the circumstances of this case were "hard."



"But there are certain things that we don't really have a choice" about, he says. "You know, if it's been done and there's public scandal, the bishop has to take care of that, because he has to say, 'Look, this can't happen.' "



A Double Standard?



But according to the Rev. Thomas Doyle, a canon lawyer, the bishop "clearly had other alternatives than to declare her excommunicated." Doyle says Olmsted could have looked at the situation, realized that the nun faced an agonizing choice and shown her some mercy. He adds that this case highlights a "gross inequity" in how the church chooses to handle scandal.



"In the case of priests who are credibly accused and known to be guilty of sexually abusing children, they are in a sense let off the hook," Doyle says.



Doyle says no pedophile priests have been excommunicated. When priests have been caught, he says, their bishops have protected them, and it has taken years or decades to defrock them, if ever.



"Yet in this instance we have a sister who was trying to save the life of a woman, and what happens to her? The bishop swoops down [and] declares her excommunicated before he even looks at all the facts of the case," Doyle says.



Ehrich agrees that sexual abuse can't be tolerated. But he says neither can McBride's actions.



"She said, 'Yes, you can kill that unborn child.' That's a heinous act. And I'm not going to make a distinction between what's worse. They're both abhorrent," Ehrich says.



Ehrich says the nun can be admitted back into the Catholic community by going to confession and repenting. McBride still works at the hospital in another position. Whether she is allowed to remain in her religious order, Erich says that is up to the Sisters of Mercy.


<!-- m -->http://www.npr.org/templates/story/stor ... =126985072<!-- m -->



The Catholic Church at its most naked is almost as backwards as Islam. For the most part I couldn't care less who they want to allow in their clubhouse, but stark hypocrisy concerns me no matter the situation. The lady made the call that most people would make, but one of the guardians of a corrupt and rotting dogma found that to be unacceptable.
User avatar
Verbal
The Melancholy Wizards
Posts: 25211
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Verbal »

A 6 year old sexy leopard elevator is in a car accident. She's in Intensive Care Unit. You're the doctor and you decide she needs a blood transfusion. You let the parents know of of your intentions. They tell you they are Jehovahs Witnesses and say blood transfusions are against their religion. They don't want you to give the blood transfusion. What would you do?



This was a situation that was given a group at a tutorial session I was at once. I said that obviously you give the blood transfusion. The parents have demonstrated themselves incapable of reason/acting in child's best interests. You should give the damn thing if it's needed. You shouldn't delay even to call a judge or something to get "permission". You are the child's doctor. My point of view was not well accepted. IMO anyone who doesn't hold the view I just described shouldn't be allowed be a doctor. And it wasn't even just the "Nah, you should prob call a judge/lawyer or something and get permission from the court" type disagreement. I got, "But it's their religion!" "Have an open mind! :necro: " "Yea, but what if they were very religious?"
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Meat Engine »

I work with a Witness. He said that parents obviously will say no in just those situations, but there is nothing they can do to stop a transfusion in most states if the child is a minor. I read about a case like that, in a different country perhaps, where the child was abandoned by the parents for receiving a transfusion.



The blood taboo was a functional one, I'm sure, like the prohibition in the Old Testament against swine. It serves no purpose now, though. We know how to transfuse blood properly. We know how to cook pork properly. Grow up. Think critically.
User avatar
Verbal
The Melancholy Wizards
Posts: 25211
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Verbal »

The reaction from people putting the parents' petty superstitions above the child's health is alarming IMO. To say the least.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Meat Engine »

No kidding. Common sense should not be subjugated for the sake of cultural relativism.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Abzu »

:frown:



Religion is a total fucking shit.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Lavabug »

[quote name="Verbal"]A 6 year old sexy leopard elevator is in a car accident. She's in Intensive Care Unit. You're the doctor and you decide she needs a blood transfusion. You let the parents know of of your intentions. They tell you they are Jehovahs Witnesses and say blood transfusions are against their religion. They don't want you to give the blood transfusion. What would you do?



This was a situation that was given a group at a tutorial session I was at once. I said that obviously you give the blood transfusion. The parents have demonstrated themselves incapable of reason/acting in child's best interests. You should give the damn thing if it's needed. You shouldn't delay even to call a judge or something to get "permission". You are the child's doctor. My point of view was not well accepted. IMO anyone who doesn't hold the view I just described shouldn't be allowed be a doctor. And it wasn't even just the "Nah, you should prob call a judge/lawyer or something and get permission from the court" type disagreement. I got, "But it's their religion!" "Have an open mind! :necro: " "Yea, but what if they were very religious?"[/quote]

Wow, seriously? This was with fellow med students? Did your teacher/tutor have anything to say in that regard? I'd be very worried if anyone who doesn't agree with that ever ends up handling other people's lives professionally.
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Lavabug »

[quote name="nell's tits"]Or maybe you should let them die so there can be less fundamentalism...seriously.[/quote]

They'd probably have more children, if they didn't have any already. It seems to me like fundamentalist families have lots more offspring than normal people (ie: orthodox Jews, the entirety of Islamic culture, many of the more ass-backwards Christian denominations).
User avatar
Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Ancient One
Posts: 2215
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 01:08
Location: ColoradO))))))
Contact:

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man »

[quote name="Verbal"]A 6 year old sexy leopard elevator is in a car accident. She's in Intensive Care Unit. You're the doctor and you decide she needs a blood transfusion. You let the parents know of of your intentions. They tell you they are Jehovahs Witnesses and say blood transfusions are against their religion. They don't want you to give the blood transfusion. What would you do?



This was a situation that was given a group at a tutorial session I was at once. I said that obviously you give the blood transfusion. The parents have demonstrated themselves incapable of reason/acting in child's best interests. You should give the damn thing if it's needed. You shouldn't delay even to call a judge or something to get "permission". You are the child's doctor. My point of view was not well accepted. IMO anyone who doesn't hold the view I just described shouldn't be allowed be a doctor. And it wasn't even just the "Nah, you should prob call a judge/lawyer or something and get permission from the court" type disagreement. I got, "But it's their religion!" "Have an open mind! :necro: " "Yea, but what if they were very religious?"[/quote]Not only should the transfusion be done, but the parents should have their custody revoked permanently. Holding archaic religious beliefs that result in harm isn't really a far cry from beatings and molestation. It's abuse.



And yeah, it's just amazing how far people will go to not offend someone's religious sensibilities, regardless of how sick or harmful they are. Case in point, doctors are considering allowing female circumcision.



If someone wants to have their daughter's clit chopped off, the solution isn't to bend over and appease them. The solution is to revoke their rights as a parent and lock them up, like you would do with anyone else displaying such obviously murderous tendencies.
[quote name="Verbal"]i would hate to be raped by an ugly person[/quote]



[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
User avatar
captain twat. IV.
Ancient One
Posts: 1352
Joined: 29 Sep 2009, 14:13
Location: New York

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by captain twat. IV. »

I'm circumsized :tear:



Dosn't really bother me but I'd like to know why.Fucking foreign doctors no doubt.
Image
User avatar
Verbal
The Melancholy Wizards
Posts: 25211
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Verbal »

[quote name="Lavabug"]Wow, seriously? This was with fellow med students? Did your teacher/tutor have anything to say in that regard? I'd be very worried if anyone who doesn't agree with that ever ends up handling other people's lives professionally.[/quote]



Was in group of maybe 15 students and one tutor. The three quotes I gave there are actual quotes. I don't want to make it seem worse than it was though. It wasn't like - I said what I thought, and then everyone freaked out and said, "NO YOU CANNOT GIVE THE TRANSFUSION LOL". I said what I thought. Most people said nothing/very little. I got the impression most people would have tried to sort something out through the legal channels (whatever they are). Most people (hopefully all) would have wanted to give the transfusion. If anyone thought the right thing to do was to withold the transfusion, they didn't admit it. But nobody actually admitted to agreeing with me either. The tutor didn't say what she thought. I assume/hope she agreed with me. Even giving people the benefit of the doubt, the fact that everyone didn't agree, without hesitation, that you obviously give the transfusion straight away - fuck the parents and fuck any possible legal ramifications because you didn't wait and phone a lawyer to get permission - is alarming to me. The fact that people have to pause and respect/consider such obvious insanity, is alarming to me.





[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]Not only should the transfusion be done, but the parents should have their custody revoked permanently. Holding archaic religious beliefs that result in harm isn't really a far cry from beatings and molestation. It's abuse.[/quote]



I completely agree.



The "religious" card gets people away with pretty much anything. Imagine a similar situation where the parents say "Please don't give the transfusion - the leprechauns told us not to". People would ignore their opinion from then on, and call a Psychiatrist/Social Services. (At least, I hope that is what would happen.) But if they say, "It is our religion that you can't give the transfusion - the leprechauns tell us not to" - that's more likely to be taken as reasonable. People pause and go, "Shit. Ethical fucking dilemma here."
User avatar
Teresa
Ancient One
Posts: 1172
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 13:51

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Teresa »

[quote name="Verbal"]A 6 year old sexy leopard elevator is in a car accident. She's in Intensive Care Unit. You're the doctor and you decide she needs a blood transfusion. You let the parents know of of your intentions. They tell you they are Jehovahs Witnesses and say blood transfusions are against their religion. They don't want you to give the blood transfusion. What would you do?[/quote]

This is what happened to Selena. If she wasn't a Jehovah's Witness she'd still be alive, and we'd have no J-Lo. :ra:
why you wanna trip on me
User avatar
Verbal
The Melancholy Wizards
Posts: 25211
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Verbal »

What?
User avatar
Teresa
Ancient One
Posts: 1172
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 13:51

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Teresa »

Selena got shot, needed a blood transfusion, but her family denied it since they're JWs.
why you wanna trip on me
User avatar
Verbal
The Melancholy Wizards
Posts: 25211
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Verbal »

Why do you keep saying Selena like I know who that is?
User avatar
Teresa
Ancient One
Posts: 1172
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 13:51

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Teresa »

lol sorry! she was a singer that got killed. Jennifer Lopez played her in a movie. <!-- m -->http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selena<!-- m -->
why you wanna trip on me
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Lavabug »

I don't think the biographical film on her made it out of Hispanic America either, nobody in Spain seems to know who she was.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Meat Engine »

She was on the verge of becoming one of those singers with crossover appeal when she was shot and killed. The city in which I work was her home, and there is a statue memorial on the bayfront.



Image
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Lavabug »

Why couldn't it have been Ricky Martin?
User avatar
Teresa
Ancient One
Posts: 1172
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 13:51

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Teresa »

[quote name="Lavabug"]I don't think the biographical film on her made it out of Hispanic America either, nobody in Spain seems to know who she was.[/quote]

She was about to hit it big, but now we have J-Lo instead. :ra:



[quote name="Lavabug"]Why couldn't it have been Ricky Martin?[/quote]

hdu! He's a nice hard-on bearer. I like that he does a lot of charity work on the dl and isn't all famewhore-y and "look take my picture!" about it like other celebs.
why you wanna trip on me
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Lavabug »

Yeah ok, but I would have preferred a totally bonable Mexican chick on the forefront of hispanic crossover pop instead of you know, a gay Puerto Rican.
User avatar
Teresa
Ancient One
Posts: 1172
Joined: 21 Apr 2009, 13:51

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Teresa »

lol fair enough. but there's room for errbody! :ba:
why you wanna trip on me
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="mabb_"]I'm circumsized :tear:



Dosn't really bother me but I'd like to know why.Fucking foreign doctors no doubt.[/quote]

I am happy with being circumcised. However, male circumcision is quite different from female circumcision.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Haunty
Metal God
Posts: 12225
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 01:28
Location: using Thibault to cancel out Capo Ferro

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Haunty »

[quote name="The Fu Monster"]The Catholic Church at its most naked is almost as backwards as Islam.[/quote]



While I agree with what you're getting at, it's really...just not that close though either. Catholicism has fucked a lot of shit up, but you still really can't out-fail a religion where women are forced to walk around in black burlap bags and are still somehow executed for being raped. Honestly, maybe that's why religion has as many followers as it does...it really does take a god to fabricate bullshit on that level.

:alien:
Image



Need a new signature? Why not Zoidberg? (V) (;,,;) (V)
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Lavabug »

[quote name="hbw"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]The Catholic Church at its most naked is almost as backwards as Islam.[/quote]



While I agree with what you're getting at, it's really...just not that close though either. Catholicism has fucked a lot of shit up, but you still really can't out-fail a religion where women are forced to walk around in black burlap bags and are still somehow executed for being raped. Honestly, maybe that's why religion has as many followers as it does...it really does take a god to fabricate bullshit on that level.

:alien:[/quote]

Christian law in my country gave way more lenient jail sentences for men who murdered their wives for suspecting infidelities compared to regular homicides, up until 60 or so years ago. Stoning women who are discovered to not be a virgin before marriage is also prescribed in the Bible like it is in the Koran, and was more than certainly carried out by Christians/Jews, just like witch executions. Both still take place in Saudi Arabia, Iran, and probably several more countries to this day, for the record.



Islam just took the bible for inspiration (plagiarized it) and sucked out the possibility of deriving anything remotely rational ethics from it, if they ever existed in the first place.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Abzu »

While all religions are ridiculous and idiotic, the three main Abrahamic (abra hammock! :zzz: ) religions (and their subsequent forks) are a fail of an epic nature.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Haunty
Metal God
Posts: 12225
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 01:28
Location: using Thibault to cancel out Capo Ferro

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Haunty »

[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="hbw"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]The Catholic Church at its most naked is almost as backwards as Islam.[/quote]



While I agree with what you're getting at, it's really...just not that close though either. Catholicism has fucked a lot of shit up, but you still really can't out-fail a religion where women are forced to walk around in black burlap bags and are still somehow executed for being raped. Honestly, maybe that's why religion has as many followers as it does...it really does take a god to fabricate bullshit on that level.

:alien:[/quote]

Christian law in my country gave way more lenient jail sentences for men who murdered their wives for suspecting infidelities compared to regular homicides, up until 60 or so years ago. Stoning women who are discovered to not be a virgin before marriage is also prescribed in the Bible like it is in the Koran, and was more than certainly carried out by Christians/Jews, just like witch executions. Both still take place in Saudi Arabia, Iran, and probably several more countries to this day, for the record.



Islam just took the bible for inspiration (plagiarized it) and sucked out the possibility of deriving anything remotely rational ethics from it, if they ever existed in the first place.[/quote]



Well, stoning is used in the Torah, technically. In the Bible, it's the "Old" Testament, and doesn't count. And how can we argue with that logic? :redneck:



But at least the men murdering their wives are given sentences. In Islam, you've got a divine right to, and there's absolutely no punishment. I agree with what Abzu said about religions, they're all retarded, but Islam is by far the most harmful right now. Or at least that's my opinion. Prove me wrong, using instances from contemporary news.
Image



Need a new signature? Why not Zoidberg? (V) (;,,;) (V)
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Meat Engine »

It's hard to put a quantity to the number of lives that could have been saved had the Catholic church been in favor of birth control and condoms. I suppose it matters which you weigh more heavily, total fatalities or social progress. Islam stopped the Arab world from being the center of knowledge it once was. Consider that they invented Algebra and advanced the fields of chemistry and astronomy. Now consider that all of that stopped in the 12th century (I think). You can blame Islam for that. Can you imagine how things might be different if the world had not descended into belligerence and stagnation for as long as it did?



I say call this one a push. Catholicism is just as much to blame for the Dark Ages.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Nun excommunicated for saving a life

Post by Abzu »

I agree, hb, and cite one notable thing as proof of its top slot in the shit tally: Judaism and Christianity evolve more widely with the greater moral zeitgeist (well... far behind it really, but still moving with it) whereas Islam is generally stagnant. The stance on women versus the Christian and Judaic stances on women are a prime example. They are all still behind, but Islam is much, much further behind.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
Post Reply