Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Shoot the shit with other metal folk. Free discussion on any topic that doesn't suit the other forums. Avoid mentioning carpet.
Post Reply
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

A ten gallon hat of Texan fail.



http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/13/educa ... ves&st=cse



Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

By JAMES C. McKINLEY Jr.

Published: March 12, 2010




AUSTIN, Tex. — After three days of turbulent meetings, the Texas Board of Education on Friday approved a social studies curriculum that will put a conservative stamp on history and economics textbooks, stressing the superiority of American capitalism, questioning the Founding Fathers’ commitment to a purely secular government and presenting Republican political philosophies in a more positive light.



The vote was 10 to 5 along party lines, with all the Republicans on the board voting for it.



The board, whose members are elected, has influence beyond Texas because the state is one of the largest buyers of textbooks. In the digital age, however, that influence has diminished as technological advances have made it possible for publishers to tailor books to individual states.



In recent years, board members have been locked in an ideological battle between a bloc of conservatives who question Darwin’s theory of evolution and believe the Founding Fathers were guided by Christian principles, and a handful of Democrats and moderate Republicans who have fought to preserve the teaching of Darwinism and the separation of church and state.



Since January, Republicans on the board have passed more than 100 amendments to the 120-page curriculum standards affecting history, sociology and economics courses from elementary to high school. The standards were proposed by a panel of teachers.



“We are adding balance,” said Dr. Don McLeroy, the leader of the conservative faction on the board, after the vote. “History has already been skewed. Academia is skewed too far to the left.”



Battles over what to put in science and history books have taken place for years in the 20 states where state boards must adopt textbooks, most notably in California and Texas. But rarely in recent history has a group of conservative board members left such a mark on a social studies curriculum.



Efforts by Hispanic board members to include more Latino figures as role models for the state’s large Hispanic population were consistently defeated, prompting one member, Mary Helen Berlanga, to storm out of a meeting late Thursday night, saying, “They can just pretend this is a white America and Hispanics don’t exist.”



“They are going overboard, they are not experts, they are not historians,” she said. “They are rewriting history, not only of Texas but of the United States and the world.”



The curriculum standards will now be published in a state register, opening them up for 30 days of public comment. A final vote will be taken in May, but given the Republican dominance of the board, it is unlikely that many changes will be made.



The standards, reviewed every decade, serve as a template for textbook publishers, who must come before the board next year with drafts of their books. The board’s makeup will have changed by then because Dr. McLeroy lost in a primary this month to a more moderate Republican, and two others — one Democrat and one conservative Republican — announced they were not seeking re-election.



There are seven members of the conservative bloc on the board, but they are often joined by one of the other three Republicans on crucial votes. There were no historians, sociologists or economists consulted at the meetings, though some members of the conservative bloc held themselves out as experts on certain topics.



The conservative members maintain that they are trying to correct what they see as a liberal bias among the teachers who proposed the curriculum. To that end, they made dozens of minor changes aimed at calling into question, among other things, concepts like the separation of church and state and the secular nature of the American Revolution.



“I reject the notion by the left of a constitutional separation of church and state,” said David Bradley, a conservative from Beaumont who works in real estate. “I have $1,000 for the charity of your choice if you can find it in the Constitution.”



They also included a plank to ensure that students learn about “the conservative resurgence of the 1980s and 1990s, including Phyllis Schlafly, the Contract With America, the Heritage Foundation, the Moral Majority and the National Rifle Association.”



Dr. McLeroy, a dentist by training, pushed through a change to the teaching of the civil rights movement to ensure that students study the violent philosophy of the Black Panthers in addition to the nonviolent approach of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. He also made sure that textbooks would mention the votes in Congress on civil rights legislation, which Republicans supported.



“Republicans need a little credit for that,” he said. “I think it’s going to surprise some students.”



Mr. Bradley won approval for an amendment saying students should study “the unintended consequences” of the Great Society legislation, affirmative action and Title IX legislation. He also won approval for an amendment stressing that Germans and Italians as well as Japanese were interned in the United States during World War II, to counter the idea that the internment of Japanese was motivated by racism.



Other changes seem aimed at tamping down criticism of the right. Conservatives passed one amendment, for instance, requiring that the history of McCarthyism include “how the later release of the Venona papers confirmed suspicions of communist infiltration in U.S. government.” The Venona papers were transcripts of some 3,000 communications between the Soviet Union and its agents in the United States.



Mavis B. Knight, a Democrat from Dallas, introduced an amendment requiring that students study the reasons “the founding fathers protected religious freedom in America by barring the government from promoting or disfavoring any particular religion above all others.”



It was defeated on a party-line vote.



After the vote, Ms. Knight said, “The social conservatives have perverted accurate history to fulfill their own agenda.”



In economics, the revisions add Milton Friedman and Friedrich von Hayek, two champions of free-market economic theory, among the usual list of economists to be studied, like Adam Smith, Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes. They also replaced the word “capitalism” throughout their texts with the “free-enterprise system.”



“Let’s face it, capitalism does have a negative connotation,” said one conservative member, Terri Leo. “You know, ‘capitalist pig!’ ”



In the field of sociology, another conservative member, Barbara Cargill, won passage of an amendment requiring the teaching of “the importance of personal responsibility for life choices” in a section on teenage suicide, dating violence, sexuality, drug use and eating disorders.



“The topic of sociology tends to blame society for everything,” Ms. Cargill said.



Even the course on world history did not escape the board’s scalpel.



Cynthia Dunbar, a lawyer from Richmond who is a strict constitutionalist and thinks the nation was founded on Christian beliefs, managed to cut Thomas Jefferson from a list of figures whose writings inspired revolutions in the late 18th century and 19th century, replacing him with St. Thomas Aquinas, John Calvin and William Blackstone. (Jefferson is not well liked among conservatives on the board because he coined the term “separation between church and state.”)



“The Enlightenment was not the only philosophy on which these revolutions were based,” Ms. Dunbar said.





:mmno: :frown: :shakefist: :shake:
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

Ohnoes its teh NYTimes. Must be media hype.
Noyka
Ancient One
Posts: 4935
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
Location: California

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Noyka »

This was already talked about in another thread



It's a moot point propaganda has always been in history books
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="Noyka"]This was already talked about in another thread



It's a moot point propaganda has always been in history books[/quote]

Adding to it is not a moot point.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
Noyka
Ancient One
Posts: 4935
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
Location: California

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Noyka »

[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]This was already talked about in another thread



It's a moot point propaganda has always been in history books[/quote]

Adding to it is not a moot point.[/quote]



It's not adding to it though it's shifting it around I don't think people realize that. It's pretty scary like people not understanding that unis like Berkley are propaganda machines and why people like me say that. They're not in the areas yet they're quick to demean those of us that live in the areas and deal with the direct affects.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]This was already talked about in another thread



It's a moot point propaganda has always been in history books[/quote]

Adding to it is not a moot point.[/quote]



It's not adding to it though it's shifting it around I don't think people realize that. It's pretty scary like people not understanding that unis like Berkley are propaganda machines and why people like me say that. They're not in the areas yet they're quick to demean those of us that live in the areas and deal with the direct affects.[/quote]

How's the weather in Karmabladia?





"It's not adding to it though it's shifting it around" is one of the most ludicrous things I've ever heard you say. Just... wow.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

[youtube]UQx_2j5nXuc[/youtube]

Disgusting.
User avatar
Haunty
Metal God
Posts: 12225
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 01:28
Location: using Thibault to cancel out Capo Ferro

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Haunty »

God damn, someone needs to give the hard-on bearer with the beard a gold fucking medal for MOST MAGNIFICENTLY GETS THE POINT. :thingy:
Image



Need a new signature? Why not Zoidberg? (V) (;,,;) (V)
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

[quote name="hbw"]God damn, someone needs to give the hard-on bearer with the beard a gold fucking medal for MOST MAGNIFICENTLY GETS THE POINT. :thingy:[/quote]

<!-- m -->http://www.youtube.com/user/AronRa<!-- m -->



He's great, he's a geologist I think. He makes educational videos lashing out against creationist attempts to stupify American children.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

Part of the revamp of No Child Left Behind would prevent this idiocy, and force states to comply with uniform standards.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Part of the revamp of No Child Left Behind would prevent this idiocy, and force states to comply with uniform standards.[/quote]

intelligent Uniform Standards :xx: :xx: :xx: :xx: :xx: :xx: :xx: :xx:
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Ancient One
Posts: 2215
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 01:08
Location: ColoradO))))))
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man »

The problem with schooling all across the board is that any compulsory, tax-funded organization is naturally going to attract brutish personality types that relish having control over others. The solution isn't to wrestle for control over the indoctrination camps, but to rescue the poor kids from them.
[quote name="Verbal"]i would hate to be raped by an ugly person[/quote]



[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]The problem with schooling all across the board is that any compulsory, tax-funded organization is naturally going to attract brutish personality types that relish having control over others. The solution isn't to wrestle for control over the indoctrination camps, but to rescue the poor kids from them.[/quote]



You've mentioned unschooling and such in the past, but the fact remains that compulsory schooling is seemingly validated by its widespread use and relative success in literally every fully industrialized nation. Let's say we made school attendance non-mandatory. How do you prevent abuse of this new "freedom" by lazy, negligent or willfully deceptive parents? It would be easier to attract more effective educators that it would be to uproot the whole system.



One change I would like to see, though, is to have what we know as high school end after the 10th grade. By that time most kids have an idea of whether or not they would prefer to go to college or learn a trade. Let the ones inclined to continue school do so. The final two years of high school are inevitably repeated in the core curriculum of most universities as it is. Let the others not so inclined to continue in academics find something otherwise interesting. Two extra years to learn and apprentice as a tradesman could be quite beneficial. I think shaving off those last two years could be a positive thing.
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

[quote name="The Fu Monster"] I think shaving off those last two years could be a positive thing.[/quote]

I agree, but only if the academic level/requisites in all the preceding years is brought up a LOT.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

With a uniform standard, that could be okay; but, how it stands now, most high school graduates are retarded cuntards.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

Agreed. In those only two years of high school, even the dumbest kid can learn algebra, geometry, biology, chemistry, geography and whatever else. The more academically inclined kids can learn geometry and advanced algebra. Algebra and geometry are sufficient for most trades and careers that don't involve a university education.
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

In my country(Spain), Calculus is a mandatory course in 10th grade, and our educational system sucks compared to most of Europe. In America I had calculus as an "advanced" optional course in 12th grade. Food for thought.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

I took calculus in the manner that you described, and the class abruptly stopped teaching in with nearly two months left in school. I don't believe the teacher was required to go beyond teaching integration by substitution.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

One other change I would like to see is year-round school. It's a rarity here, but it seems fantastic.
Redd
Ancient One
Posts: 4821
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 05:52
Location: USA

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Redd »

I honestly would not mind year-round school if I could take the classes I want. Oh, and the teachers better be good. I'm sick of this "arrange terms in their proper order and define them" shit some teachers give out. And textbooks need to improve. I'm going to stop here before I go off on a rant.
User avatar
Haunty
Metal God
Posts: 12225
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 01:28
Location: using Thibault to cancel out Capo Ferro

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Haunty »

[quote name="Redd"]I honestly would not mind year-round school if I could take the classes I want. Oh, and the teachers better be good. I'm sick of this "arrange terms in their proper order and define them" shit some teachers give out. And textbooks need to improve. I'm going to stop here before I go off on a rant.[/quote]



Please continue...
Image



Need a new signature? Why not Zoidberg? (V) (;,,;) (V)
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

That rant could become a good discourse, Redd. I agree that you should continue.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

I would contest to one statement: although teachers do have the responsibility of doing their job right and at least trying to spark some interest in students, the success of the student lies within himself/herself. I've never run into particularly horrible lecturers and IME I've found a lot of people who complain about teachers were simply lazy and expected teachers to chew everything for them, not throwing you into the same bag though.
User avatar
djonni greazo
Ancient One
Posts: 2752
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 00:18
Location: NWO
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by djonni greazo »

[quote name="Lavabug"]I would contest to one statement: although teachers do have the responsibility of doing their job right and at least trying to spark some interest in students, the success of the student lies within himself/herself. I've never run into particularly horrible lecturers and IME I've found a lot of people who complain about teachers were simply lazy and expected teachers to chew everything for them, not throwing you into the same bag though.[/quote]



you should come over here :santa:
:xx: Image :xx:
Redd
Ancient One
Posts: 4821
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 05:52
Location: USA

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Redd »

Lavabug, I didn't quite mean that I wanted teachers to regurgitate information back to the students. I meant that teachers need to actually present thought-provoking information and in a way that engages the students. My history teacher last year would give us terms, tell us to write a sentence or two about each term, then arrange the terms in chronological order. That's an absolutely shitty way to teach. The tests were that way too, and I nearly failed the class all because I cannot memorize which of x number of events go in order. And to top it all off: we rarely related the events we were learning to past events or to the modern day. History does not occur in a vacuum.



And the textbooks are pretty bad too. I'm going to use the example of history since that's my one class that really relies on the textbook and good god.. there are a lot of lies and misinformation, and just plain repetition in them. For example, the World War I chapter it said that men all over the front celebrated. This site disagrees. Now, putting that fact in could spark some interesting classroom discussion. Also my textbook covers the westward expansion TWICE. Is that really necessary? Is it really necessary to say that in the '20s athletes became heroes, then repeat it AGAIN in the '30s chapter? My textbook also glazes right over Wilson's racism and racist policies. I'm taking U.S. History II right now, which is Civil War to modern day. I don't think we're even going to get to the Vietnam War at the rate we're going. We're not even on WWII yet and it's halfway through the third marking period (we have one marking period left, by the way). Textbooks are overstuffed. Textbooks present history in a way that glorifies people/events and thus makes them un-interesting.



I mentioned classroom discussion earlier in this post, and I really feel it's something that needs to be emphasized more. If there was more discussion about history, the students would learn off of each other and get to know one another's perspectives on historical events. Teachers don't need to teach constantly. There are gaps in their knowledge that I'm sure students could fill in. But discussion doesn't happen often because class is too regimented. It has to be or you'll never get to the important events, like Vietnam.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Abzu »

Write a paper on this and send it to newspapers and media outlets.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

Pre-university level schooling in America is largely designed to fill up children with facts rather than encourage critical thinking and abstract reasoning. Redd's complaints about history education are certainly valid; there is simply so much to cover that it becomes easy to look at major events from one point of view. The university level ameliorates this to some degree, but I had an experience in my second U.S. history course, (Civil War reconstruction to the present day), that showed me some professors simply don't try. I passed with a C because the essay portions of my tests were always graded poorly. The only reason given was that I did not follow the format, which was to specifically regurgitate two things you heard in the lecture and two things you read from the book to support your thesis. I'm sorry, but that is fucking stupid. It takes an elementary school pupil to say, "In class I heard this, and in the book they said this." That is not university-level work. I also had to do a paper using a small narrative of the Japanese internment in America. My specific thesis ceased to have supporting examples two-thirds through the book or so, but I was punished for not forcing examples to fit my thesis.



That's enough from me. TLDR, pre-university education in America needs to be changed, university level education is pretty good.
User avatar
Lavabug
Metal God
Posts: 7817
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 16:15
Location: An ocean of filth.

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Lavabug »

I don't know, maybe this is just very common in humanities courses because of the non-empirical nature of exams/essay assignments. I haven't taken a pure humanities course in a long time, so my assessment was really aimed at people who complain about math/science courses. :redneck: But I do recall the following:



When I did my last year of high school in the US, I had to take "American history II" along with 11th graders(because I didn't have enough history credits to graduate by their curriculum standards, but I practically knew everything in that class). I agree, it was pretty pathetic. What was taught in said course was pretty much plain dishonest, thinking critically was frowned upon by the teacher.



I don't recall the exact details but I remember the teacher force-feeding the students something plainly untrue about the reason/justification for the Spanish-American war, she also frequently slipped in her personal opinions with a false sense of humility. Generally speaking, it was a constant regurgitation of the "we're good, they're bad" false dichotomy in practically every armed conflict America had been in over the past century. To say nothing of how she presented one of Israel's "encounters" with Lebanon one day we were discussing current issues. Brainwashing kids who don't know better. :frown:
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Meat Engine »

Remember the (accidental explosion of the) Maine!
Redd
Ancient One
Posts: 4821
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 05:52
Location: USA

Re: Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change

Post by Redd »

[quote name="Lavabug"]I don't know, maybe this is just very common in humanities courses because of the non-empirical nature of exams/essay assignments. I haven't taken a pure humanities course in a long time, so my assessment was really aimed at people who complain about math/science courses. :redneck: But I do recall the following:



When I did my last year of high school in the US, I had to take "American history II" along with 11th graders(because I didn't have enough history credits to graduate by their curriculum standards, but I practically knew everything in that class). I agree, it was pretty pathetic. What was taught in said course was pretty much plain dishonest, thinking critically was frowned upon by the teacher.



I don't recall the exact details but I remember the teacher force-feeding the students something plainly untrue about the reason/justification for the Spanish-American war, she also frequently slipped in her personal opinions with a false sense of humility. Generally speaking, it was a constant regurgitation of the "we're good, they're bad" false dichotomy in practically every armed conflict America had been in over the past century. To say nothing of how she presented one of Israel's "encounters" with Lebanon one day we were discussing current issues. Brainwashing kids who don't know better. :frown:[/quote]



My history teacher last year could not tell me the causes of the Civil War. He told me to go watch Ken Burn's Civil War. Did I mention that he has a PhD? I swear, history is the only class where people become more stupid the longer they study it. And I think it might be some requirement to not have students think critically; of all the history teachers I've had, only one had us think critically.



Something history courses, at least from my experience, require is different perspectives. Why do we have to look at the arrival of Columbus from Spanish eyes? Why can't we see how the natives felt about what he was doing? Why can't we look at the Civil War through the eyes of an African American soldier? Why do we only look at the war through the eyes of the Lincoln administration? etc etc.



Sometimes I feel that high school history is designed to indoctrinate kids into blind nationalism. Everything is whitewashed, America is presented as the best country ever that never did anything wrong. I really do not understand why it's like this. Is it really that much easier to say "Spain blew up the Maine" than say, "America fucked up; we blamed Spain for the explosion of the Maine even though it was really an accident"? I don't know about anyone else, but it's a lot more satisfying to me to hear the real reasons for events, instead of the same "they attacked us and we defended ourselves" shit that is spewed out constantly. IT IS BORING.
Post Reply