Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
http://news.yahoo.com/s/bloomberg/20100 ... acvuseeas4
Feb. 3 (Bloomberg) -- Costs incurred in sex-change operations and procedures are tax-deductible, the U.S. Tax Court ruled.
The Washington-based court decided yesterday that hormone therapies and sex reassignment surgeries are necessary to treat gender identity disorder, a disease, in the case of a Boston- area man who became a woman named Rhiannon O’Donnabhain.
“The Court is persuaded that petitioner’s sex reassignment surgery was medically necessary,” Judge Joseph Gale wrote in a 69-page decision for the majority.
The decision is the first to rule that sex-change operations qualify as medical care and overturns a 2005 Internal Revenue Service policy denying medical expense deductions in such operations on the grounds they are ‘cosmetic.’’
The case involves a $5,679 tax bill assessed by the IRS, which denied medical deductions claimed by O’Donnabhain after she underwent sex reassignment-surgery in 2000. O’Donnabhain, a civil engineer who joined the U.S. Coast Guard during the Vietnam War, was diagnosed with gender identity disorder in 1997.
O’Donnabhain sued the IRS after it denied her deduction of $25,000 in out-of-pocket medical costs associated with the surgeries and other care such as hormone treatments and counseling, according to Boston-based Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, which represented her in court.
Deduction Rules
Medical expenses are deductible after they exceed 7.5 percent of adjusted gross income. Cosmetic surgery generally doesn’t qualify.
O’Donnabhain, who became a woman after 20 years of marriage that produced three children while simultaneously struggling with her gender identity, argued her medical costs were no different than heart surgery.
Yesterday, a majority of the court sided with her, ruling the IRS was wrong to deny her deductions.
The contention that O’Donnabhain “undertook the surgery and hormone treatments to improve appearance is at best a superficial characterization of the circumstances that is thoroughly rebutted by the medical evidence,” Gale wrote.
The decision “recognizes that expenses related to medical care for transgender people should be treated no differently than expenses related to an appendectomy or chemotherapy,” said Karen Loewy, a lawyer with Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders in Boston who represented O’Donnabhain. “The dismissal of these medical expenses as illegitimate and not deductible was discrimination, pure and simple.”
Differing Opinion
In an opinion that dissented in part, Judge David Gustafson said that O’Donnabhain may have suffered a “serious mental condition.” Still, he said her condition met a strict definition of non-deductible “cosmetic surgery.”
“Congress did not provide that an appearance-improving procedure will nonetheless be deductible if it merely ‘mitigates a disease,’” Gustafson wrote.
The decision was first reported by the TaxProf Blog, run by University of Cincinnati law professor Paul Caron.
The case is O’Donnabhain v. Commissioner, 134 T.C. No. 4 (Feb. 2, 2010).
To contact the reporter on this story: Ryan J. Donmoyer in Washington at <!-- e --><a href="mailto:rdonmoyer@bloomberg.net">rdonmoyer@bloomberg.net</a><!-- e -->
Feb. 3 (Bloomberg) -- Costs incurred in sex-change operations and procedures are tax-deductible, the U.S. Tax Court ruled.
The Washington-based court decided yesterday that hormone therapies and sex reassignment surgeries are necessary to treat gender identity disorder, a disease, in the case of a Boston- area man who became a woman named Rhiannon O’Donnabhain.
“The Court is persuaded that petitioner’s sex reassignment surgery was medically necessary,” Judge Joseph Gale wrote in a 69-page decision for the majority.
The decision is the first to rule that sex-change operations qualify as medical care and overturns a 2005 Internal Revenue Service policy denying medical expense deductions in such operations on the grounds they are ‘cosmetic.’’
The case involves a $5,679 tax bill assessed by the IRS, which denied medical deductions claimed by O’Donnabhain after she underwent sex reassignment-surgery in 2000. O’Donnabhain, a civil engineer who joined the U.S. Coast Guard during the Vietnam War, was diagnosed with gender identity disorder in 1997.
O’Donnabhain sued the IRS after it denied her deduction of $25,000 in out-of-pocket medical costs associated with the surgeries and other care such as hormone treatments and counseling, according to Boston-based Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, which represented her in court.
Deduction Rules
Medical expenses are deductible after they exceed 7.5 percent of adjusted gross income. Cosmetic surgery generally doesn’t qualify.
O’Donnabhain, who became a woman after 20 years of marriage that produced three children while simultaneously struggling with her gender identity, argued her medical costs were no different than heart surgery.
Yesterday, a majority of the court sided with her, ruling the IRS was wrong to deny her deductions.
The contention that O’Donnabhain “undertook the surgery and hormone treatments to improve appearance is at best a superficial characterization of the circumstances that is thoroughly rebutted by the medical evidence,” Gale wrote.
The decision “recognizes that expenses related to medical care for transgender people should be treated no differently than expenses related to an appendectomy or chemotherapy,” said Karen Loewy, a lawyer with Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders in Boston who represented O’Donnabhain. “The dismissal of these medical expenses as illegitimate and not deductible was discrimination, pure and simple.”
Differing Opinion
In an opinion that dissented in part, Judge David Gustafson said that O’Donnabhain may have suffered a “serious mental condition.” Still, he said her condition met a strict definition of non-deductible “cosmetic surgery.”
“Congress did not provide that an appearance-improving procedure will nonetheless be deductible if it merely ‘mitigates a disease,’” Gustafson wrote.
The decision was first reported by the TaxProf Blog, run by University of Cincinnati law professor Paul Caron.
The case is O’Donnabhain v. Commissioner, 134 T.C. No. 4 (Feb. 2, 2010).
To contact the reporter on this story: Ryan J. Donmoyer in Washington at <!-- e --><a href="mailto:rdonmoyer@bloomberg.net">rdonmoyer@bloomberg.net</a><!-- e -->
- ANGEL OF DESEASE
- Metal God
- Posts: 11514
- Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 17:43
- Location: banned from the disco
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
hey Noyka, have u ever thought about becoming a man?

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="rocknrolla">prostitutes....they are magical beings. Almost like unicorns. But instead of unicorns, prostitutes do exist. They cost real money. But..........It may just be worth the while. They do unbelievable things with their mouths.</blockquote><blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Extreme Noise Tara">Ryan is black.</blockquote>
- Grudge
- Metal God
- Posts: 10548
- Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 10:23
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]hey Noyka, have u ever thought about becoming a man?[/quote]
- zim
- Zim(a)
- Posts: 26933
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 02:36
- Location: couch
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]hey Noyka, have u ever thought about becoming a man?[/quote]
this might be the funniest thing i've ever read
this might be the funniest thing i've ever read
the dead vote well wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 04:22moving from a garbage disposal back to the dumpster but it’s an improvement nonetheless
- Haunty
- Metal God
- Posts: 12225
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 01:28
- Location: using Thibault to cancel out Capo Ferro
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
What about you, Zimberley? Have you ever thought about becoming a man?

Need a new signature? Why not Zoidberg? (V) (;,,;) (V)
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
Medical Science has only progressed so far.
A sexy leopard elevator can still dream, I suppose.
A sexy leopard elevator can still dream, I suppose.
- ANGEL OF DESEASE
- Metal God
- Posts: 11514
- Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 17:43
- Location: banned from the disco
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
a dead dick from a dead man gets ressurection on a new woman body

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="rocknrolla">prostitutes....they are magical beings. Almost like unicorns. But instead of unicorns, prostitutes do exist. They cost real money. But..........It may just be worth the while. They do unbelievable things with their mouths.</blockquote><blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Extreme Noise Tara">Ryan is black.</blockquote>
- zim
- Zim(a)
- Posts: 26933
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 02:36
- Location: couch
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="HbW"]What about you, Zimberley? Have you ever thought about becoming a man?[/quote]
should have seen that coming
should have seen that coming
the dead vote well wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 04:22moving from a garbage disposal back to the dumpster but it’s an improvement nonetheless
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="zim"]
[quote name="HbW"]What about you, Zimberley? Have you ever thought about becoming a man?[/quote]
should have seen that coming[/quote]
...and how many times have you said that about 30 seconds before Guapo delToritto throws you a towel and leaves?
[quote name="HbW"]What about you, Zimberley? Have you ever thought about becoming a man?[/quote]
should have seen that coming[/quote]
...and how many times have you said that about 30 seconds before Guapo delToritto throws you a towel and leaves?
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- zim
- Zim(a)
- Posts: 26933
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 02:36
- Location: couch
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
i think i've been getting an average of around 3-5 gay jokes thrown at me a day now
the dead vote well wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 04:22moving from a garbage disposal back to the dumpster but it’s an improvement nonetheless
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
My God, newbie, it's been two furiously frustrating years. How is it possible that you still don't get me? I would never compare you to the gays. I like the gays. I like their music. I like their sense of style. I especially like what they've done with Halloween, but our thing is that you are a little sexy leopard elevator. That's who you are. But maybe that's not fair...
- zim
- Zim(a)
- Posts: 26933
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 02:36
- Location: couch
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
the dead vote well wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 04:22moving from a garbage disposal back to the dumpster but it’s an improvement nonetheless
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]hey Noyka, have u ever thought about becoming a man?[/quote]
Nope, never thought about, never will.
I've honestly never met a tranny before
Nope, never thought about, never will.
I've honestly never met a tranny before
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="Johnny"]My God, newbie, it's been two furiously frustrating years. How is it possible that you still don't get me? I would never compare you to the gays. I like the gays. I like their music. I like their sense of style. I especially like what they've done with Halloween, but our thing is that you are a little sexy leopard elevator. That's who you are. But maybe that's not fair...[/quote]
That was the perfect Dr. Cox quote for Zimberly's post. Good job, Gleeso.
That was the perfect Dr. Cox quote for Zimberly's post. Good job, Gleeso.
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- zim
- Zim(a)
- Posts: 26933
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 02:36
- Location: couch
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
it was the perfect reply but he most likely copied and pasted it so he only gets half credit. however, i am a woman, therefore i am duty-bound to award johnny 'motherfucking' gleeso full credit.
the dead vote well wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 04:22moving from a garbage disposal back to the dumpster but it’s an improvement nonetheless
- jawn galliano
- Yahtzee Genius
- Posts: 24065
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
that was a very noble and honorable thing you did just there
- deathgrow
- Neophyte
- Posts: 24
- Joined: 06 Feb 2010, 03:41
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
- jawn galliano
- Yahtzee Genius
- Posts: 24065
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
GID is incredibly rare. i am doubtful that everyone who falls under that banner actually goes through the process of getting diagnosed, going through the extensive counseling and all the required hoops, to qualify for reassignment surgery. the number of those who actually go through with the surgery, and then go on to file the deduction i'm sure is even smaller still.
if you're concerned about deduction abuses, this crowd is pretty much the absolute least of your concerns. a hair of a fraction of a drop in the bucket, and all.
(i mean this in a general sense, not directed toward you (deathgrow) specifically)
if you're concerned about deduction abuses, this crowd is pretty much the absolute least of your concerns. a hair of a fraction of a drop in the bucket, and all.
(i mean this in a general sense, not directed toward you (deathgrow) specifically)
- deathgrow
- Neophyte
- Posts: 24
- Joined: 06 Feb 2010, 03:41
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
Concern about the abuse and manipulation of money?...
Whatever...My tax money pays for civilian casualties of war everyday!!!
There is undoubtedly even heavier rule bending that isn't addressed because it's the norm...and is more socially transparent than this one.
There is undoubtedly even heavier rule bending that isn't addressed because it's the norm...and is more socially transparent than this one.
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="zim"]it was the perfect reply but he most likely copied and pasted it so he only gets half credit. however, i am a woman, therefore i am duty-bound to award johnny 'motherfucking' gleeso full credit.[/quote]
I had typed in something based on the quote from memory. But decided the proper quote may be better. I'm actually regretting my decision.
I had typed in something based on the quote from memory. But decided the proper quote may be better. I'm actually regretting my decision.
- zim
- Zim(a)
- Posts: 26933
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 02:36
- Location: couch
Re: Sex Change Operations Are Now Tax-Deductible
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]that was a very noble and honorable thing you did just there[/quote]
why you no good dirty post modifying meanie!
why you no good dirty post modifying meanie!
the dead vote well wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 04:22moving from a garbage disposal back to the dumpster but it’s an improvement nonetheless