Nirvana vs melvins

Talk about the classic Dionysian passion. Post the genres, eras, albums and bands that whammy your bar. Try not to post gloryhole era threads.
Post Reply
User avatar
rhino
PAWG Hunter
Posts: 51143
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 04:59

Nirvana vs melvins

Post by rhino »

:santa:
User avatar
vO)))id
Metal God
Posts: 12253
Joined: 13 Apr 2009, 14:44

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by vO)))id »

Melvins no doubt
droidspawn
I'd Rank That For $1
Posts: 49521
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 06:40
Location: to the depths, in degradation

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by droidspawn »

Melvins easily

Nirvana was garbage
User avatar
Methuselah Honeysuckle
Postwhore
Posts: 59385
Joined: 26 Jul 2009, 22:32
Location: the bottle dump

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by Methuselah Honeysuckle »

I never got into the melvins
vega wrote:But when I am meeting she is a round circle like egg. :oldryan: . She is eating 88% of foods and I am paying 100% bill.
Ninny wrote: ↑
10 Oct 2021, 21:53
but now I want to suck her soft parts.
User avatar
Aðalsteinn
Metal God
Posts: 7838
Joined: 29 Jun 2009, 08:00

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by Aðalsteinn »

Of course everyone will choose the Melvins :gaylol:
Kvlt :xx: :necro:

Nirvana of course. The Melvins suck.
User avatar
rhino
PAWG Hunter
Posts: 51143
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 04:59

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by rhino »

Awww shiiiiit
User avatar
rhino
PAWG Hunter
Posts: 51143
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 04:59

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by rhino »

The melvins have so much music and so many different styles/sounds it's a bit overwhelming :o
User avatar
agony bagony
Postwhore
Posts: 77363
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 07:36

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by agony bagony »

i mean...the melvins?

this is like lemonade versus a sip of lemonade?
Skinfection wrote: ↑
21 Oct 2020, 20:08
super Jesus people
User avatar
rhino
PAWG Hunter
Posts: 51143
Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 04:59

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by rhino »

Lemonade more like HATERADE
User avatar
Grudge
Metal God
Posts: 10548
Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 10:23

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by Grudge »

I think when it comes to the Melvins I should have the final say on the subject.

Comparing the two, this is what it boils down to. Nirvana gets off to a strong start with Bleach and that album alone wins enough points to nullify a big chunk of the Melvin's shitty catalog. But like a patient tortoise, the Melvins creep up when the hare is asleep (or in Nirvana's case, dead and disbanded) and exceeds Nirvana by some margin, with solid outputs like Lysol, Houdini, some of the early stuff like Bullhead and what came before it. Lysol really never gets old for me - I still get goosebumps when I go back to it for a listen.

Then starting with Stoner Witch, the Melvins start to go on a decline, then find a temporary moment of inspiration with a fantastic album - The Maggot - extending their lead on Nirvana further. Then that's that. It's off to an old people's home for the Melvins, with one shitty album after another. They have never since The Maggot managed to put out an album that contains more than one half-way decent song.
User avatar
agony bagony
Postwhore
Posts: 77363
Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 07:36

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by agony bagony »

:gaylol:
Skinfection wrote: ↑
21 Oct 2020, 20:08
super Jesus people
User avatar
Ninny
Metal God
Posts: 16125
Joined: 13 Apr 2009, 15:24
Location: Groaningagain

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by Ninny »

Lysol is interesting :santa:
User avatar
Dr. Gonzo
Metal God
Posts: 5465
Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 09:44
Location: between shite and pee

Re: Nirvana vs melvins

Post by Dr. Gonzo »

Nirvana of course but did get the chance to se the Melvin open for tool back on 95 and the acid inside of my brain really enjoyed their set. Most people around me were simple and couldn't get into them but I love their music n live stage presence.
Post Reply