The red in the sky is ours vs soul of a new machine

[Ryeknow]

1992 match up

[Ryeknow]

[slugbait]

Too much filler on Soul. AtG wins this one.

[jawn galliano]

red by a thousand miles

[Methuselah Honeysuckle]

red by a thousand miles

You think it's that close?

[User]

ATTTTAA THE GATESSAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[jawn galliano]

red by a thousand miles

You think it's that close?

i was trying to be nice

[droidspawn]

Red. Not even close.

[Mesarthim]

Too much filler on Soul. AtG wins this one.

I love soul but yeah this.

[agony bagony]

the sky is a soul machine

[Corpsepyre]

Fear Factory for me. The high points are really up there.

[User]

soul of a new machine is a good album but it is too all over the place to compete with atg

[shadowalk]

Soul because I was never really a big At The Gates fan whereas there was a point in time that I was obsessed with the old FF records.

[Mesarthim]

[slugbait]

Burton's clean volcals always sound live

[zim]

that's always such a shame isn't it. some people just can't match their studio performance and it's always sad

[Ryeknow]

Who are other singers in death metal that can't cut it live?

Besides Barnes

[slugbait]

Not death metal but Chino usually sounds like butt live.

[droidspawn]

Rob Zombie is god awful

[jawn galliano]

my extremely fuzzy memory was "doesn't really sound the same without all the fancy studio production, but performed fine"

but that was also on the astrocreep tour so probably he hadn't yet destroyed his voice

i remember dani filth being horrendous when i saw them on uhh, i guess it must've been the cruelty tour?

[deckard]

not a good comparision imo

[Ryeknow]

Both are debuts from 1992

[Methuselah Honeysuckle]

not a good comparision imo

Because you prefer necroticism?

[agony bagony]

our sky is a new red soul

[Mesarthim]