Page 1 of 1

Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 05:57
by Noyka
I think derailing the neurosis thread is impolite but I always find this interesting

Can you separate music from ideology?
Music from the musician?

Should we do this?

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 06:00
by Noyka
Personally I am very black and white with the musician if you groom teens, abuse children, are a pedo, or any of that i can no longer listen to your art.

Ideology there is a lot of gray i listen to songs that support politics i disagree with but then there are ideas like nsbm i just can’t get behind or listen to.

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 06:47
by zim
it's a funny topic. some people don't seem to care at all, some people pick and choose. like chris brown beat the hell out of rihanna his fans just looked on. faust and burzum are literally murderers and they still have lots of fans.

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 07:12
by Ryeknow
It really depends, but for the most part, I can seperate the art from the artist. I've always like to learn about the members in bands I'm into. The more popular the band, and the more footage (Pantera for example) I feel like I would be more invested in what they had to say (back then), than a band I only knew little of


On the topic of neurosis, I've been a fan for years, and they've always been a pretty private band, so this really won't make me think otherwise about their music

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 09:44
by Noyka
Its so weird to me peopke can enjoy music and not think about the horrible people behind it. I had a fellating lover who still listened to Lost Prophets after the whole sexually assaulting babies thing with Ian their lead singer.

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 10:08
by jawn galliano
i am definitely a pick and choose type. the cases where i do separate them are wildly inconsistent, i just don't seem to have a system.

as an example, i really don't listen to burzum much anymore, but i wouldn't categorically say i won't. arghoslent or GBK though, i just can't do it. burzum wins out here i guess probably just because of historical significance, those pre-prison releases were just good!

but then there's the case of all the cryptofascist acts in the neofolk scene like death in june, who are quite significant but for whatever reason i just can't get past the political trappings.

so i don't generally give people a hard time for listening to what they do. or give them flack for choosing not to listen to certain things, etc.

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 14:51
by Ryeknow
Always been a big fan of nachtmystium, when he turned into a shitbag and robbed his fans of thousands of dollars, it did make me angry at Blake, i still continued to listen to his music, but I no longer bought any cd's or merch. Now that he apparently straightened up, and paid back a lot if people before he ended nachtmystium, it really doesn't bother me now



Dude is a brilliant song writer, wonder if he will ever make music again in some shape or form

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 19:11
by jawn galliano
i never really got into the music so it made it a lot easier to continue avoiding them when he was outed as a massive shitbag :redneck:

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 31 Aug 2022, 01:11
by Ninny
I don't seem to mind. Though I don't like homophobia in hiphop. Nor any form of antisemitism

Re: Music and the Musician

Posted: 31 Aug 2022, 01:12
by Ninny
I do mind :necro: