So everyone has listened to Sepultura at one time or another.
Certainly one of my alltime favorite bands.
The band kinda ended for me when Max left though. I did buy Against and, for some reason, Roorback, but since then I’ve only jammed a handful of tracks from the newer albums, without ever being impressed.
Anyway, I saw a ranking of all Sepultura albums in a facebook post recently, by a fellating lover of mine who’s a musician and a huge Sepultura fan, old-school fan at that. We used to share thoughts on their albums back in the mid/late gloryhole era , and often fought about whether to take sides with Soulfly or the “new” Sepultura I chose the former
What amazed me about that ranking was that he put Roots at the bottom of the pile, even below the Derrick-era albums
Furthermore, a shitload of his friends also commented, most of them being musicians, and almost everyone rates Roots very poorly
Is this the general concensus about Roots ?
I love Roots. It did take me a while to accept it back then, but in the end I got what they were trying to do, and jammed it relentlessly for years. Actually, my ranking of the albums would be.
- Beneath
- Arise
- Roots
- Chaos
- Schizo
- Bestial
- Morbid
So, how did/do you like it, the Roots experiment ?
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 18:38
by vO)))id
I don't know what and don't care about what the general consensus is about Roots. I think it's an awesome album.
Beneath and Arise are my number 1 and 2 as well.
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 18:51
by rhino
Oh the ever so decisive roots album. I love it and always have, ranking it below the post max stuff is crazy to me, though I rank it lower than the greats
Arise
Chaos ad
Btr
Roots
And I just listed those albums because it's the only ones I listen to
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 19:11
by droidspawn
Roots has always been hot trash to me. Never liked it. It’s just always rubbed me the wrong way. The new record Quadra is awesome. Best record with Derrick imo by far. And I’m not a big Derrick fan. For me it’s
btr
arise
chaos ad
schizo
morbid visions
quadra
roots
the rest
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 19:26
by shadowalk
Schizo, Beneath and Arise are all classics to me. There are times I like one over the other two but all three are special to me.
Roots is okay but in my mind, it's kinda like that's a different band altogether.
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 19:28
by agony bagony
roots is sepultura’s load
i think it’s ok but also too long. just like the first soulfly album
can’t hold a candle to the btr-chaos era
also not as good as against, which fucking rules and will never get the respect it deserves
chaos ad
arise
against
btr
roots
whichever album has troops of doom on it
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 19:37
by Ninny
Arise
Beneath the Remains
Chaos A.D.
Roots
Morbid Visions
Schizophrenia
No Max no Sepultura :grimshake: Roots has a nice tribal vibe
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 19:43
by shadowalk
arborist shrub tarkington wrote:just like the first soulfly album
dusty do you still jumpdafuckup
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 20:31
by agony bagony
i never really got down with soulfly
though the last few days i have a weird nostalgia for late gloryhole era metal. i might even jam the soulfly debut later today
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 21:05
by Methuselah Honeysuckle
I get down with roots but I can see how that album doesn't sit right with people because of those classical as a cunt sepultura albums
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 21:06
by Aðalsteinn
The first Soulfly is a solid ass jam. I agree that it’s a little bit too long, but there are some of Max’s greatest tracks on there.
To this day my friends still speak of the Soulfly ‘98 Roskilde festival performance as among the greatest shows they ever saw.
And I was stuck in Iceland working Had a ticket and everything but couldn’t get time off from work
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 21:09
by droidspawn
POOPS BLOODY POOPS
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 21:34
by shadowalk
BENEF DA
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 21:53
by rhino
WAR FOR TERRY TORY
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 May 2020, 22:07
by droidspawn
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 18:33
by Aðalsteinn
Ninny wrote: :grimshake:
Someone go ahead and make this happen please :!:
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 18:49
by agony bagony
:grimaod:
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 19:39
by Mesarthim
I like the newer sepultura albums I just wish they'd bring a second guitarist on board.
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 25 Aug 2022, 22:37
by Ryeknow
Chaos ad today
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 26 Aug 2022, 00:46
by shadowalk
Schizo is the one that I listen to a lot nowadays.
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 26 Aug 2022, 02:12
by Verbal
beneef da remain
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 28 Aug 2022, 21:01
by Ryeknow
Re: Sepultura question
Posted: 30 Aug 2022, 04:25
by agony bagony
roots is fine but it's too long, they were trying out a bunch of new shit and so it works in that sense but even at my most sepultura-crazed i thought "this album could be three tracks shorter"