Page 1 of 1
Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 06:38
by neckred
no, it's not one of rhino's other accounts
even though I really don't listen to Load and Reload, on reflection I realize they're really not that bad, and one can appreciate how they were just doing what the hell they wanted to do. I really find them less predictable and mainstream than the Black Album.
again I must stress, I don't listen to these often, in fact I haven't heard a song from those albums in a few years, but despite the stereotypes associated with tokers anonymous, the memory is strong with this one!
anyway, on to the point of this thread. I personally think I might actually like and listen to Metallica now if they never drifted from that sort of style of those two albums. They'd have been able to perfect it and find their own identity within those confines. Instead of simply trying to cater to fans by making supposed "thrash".
would you listen to Metallica's newer stuff a lot more now, if they'd have kept that road?
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 06:43
by rhino
i've said it before, they would be alot better now if they would stop trying to be the thrashers they once were and rock out some stoner/bluesy riffs instead
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 07:43
by droidspawn
sard and fucking sard
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 10:59
by neckred
[quote name="Skinoperable"]they haven't been metallica for over 20 years[/quote]
exactly why I always chuckle when people say they prefer old Metallica, they've been not Metallica longer than they were Metallica the thrash band
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 11:42
by shadowalk
Both are nice to listen to. It's not Master Of Puppets by any means but a joy to listen to nonetheless. I never did compare it their old stuff which is why I was all like "whaaaaaat?" when all I got into this whole internet thing and discovered that people scoff at Metallica after the black album.
Besides when you listen to a band like Metallica, a band that most of us probably grew up listening to, you don't really look for anything new or spectacular in them nowadays. They can write a simple, catchy song that's miles and miles from Animals As Leaders or Jeff Loomis or whatever yet you'd be surprised how long that song will last in your head.
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 12:45
by Holocaust
They made their money, retained a fan base and gained new ones (who are generally into soft shit), are still playing shows, I'd say they played their cards the way they should have, despite all the bitching about not being tr00 to the style of metal from which they originated. I'm glad they're not living in a 2-bedroom house slightly larger than mine and scheduling tours around a job
That being said, I still don't like these albums.

Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 18:56
by agony bagony
load is a really good album. reload is less good but still has moments of delicious win. death magnetic is eh with a few neat moments but it sounds more than anything else like a band trying to recapture a sound (and, to be fair, having fun also) than it does a band trying more than anything else to see what sound emerges. all this "we were trying to recapture the hunger of master of puppets," and "what we're writing sounds more like the black album" for the new one, none of that stuff does anything for me. why not just "we're jamming and whatever happens will happen"?
anyway i think it would have been neat if they had wandered down the load roads a bit farther
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 18:59
by agony bagony
[quote name="neckred"]
[quote name="Skinoperable"]they haven't been metallica for over 20 years[/quote]
exactly why I always chuckle when people say they prefer old Metallica, they've been not Metallica longer than they were Metallica the thrash band[/quote]
they havent been the amazing & heavy duty band of the 80s and early gloryhole era for twenty years. i maintain that there is a vibe to a metallica song that lets you know it's metallica even without vocals. (this obviously isn't unique to them.) i think all the post-80s stuff feels like metallica even if it doesnt "sound" like metallica. for me, the first album of theirs that both sounds and feels like something wrong ("broken" might be a better word) is st. anger. and death magnetic...eh
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 26 May 2012, 19:37
by Paste Human
Load and Reload are good, but not Metallica good. The reception of these albums would have been overwhelmingly positive had any other group put them out.
That said, Load is probably the greatest hard rock album I've ever heard. Reload is fairly average, but nothing to scoff at.
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 27 May 2012, 02:13
by Sarcofago
[quote name="Skinoperable"]they haven't been metallica for over 20 years[/quote]
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 27 May 2012, 02:15
by deckard
maybe they were only pretending to be a thrash band

Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 27 May 2012, 02:26
by agony bagony
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 27 May 2012, 02:31
by deckard
i really like metallica, pretty much all the releases, who gives a fuck like
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 27 May 2012, 11:59
by shadowalk
[quote name="it the dusto"]for me, the first album of theirs that both sounds and feels like something wrong ("broken" might be a better word) is st. anger. and death magnetic...eh[/quote]
I have somewhat similar views even though I will say that St. Anger is one hell of a noisy ugly album that's just damn fun to listen to. My take on the culprit would be James fiddling around with his guitar tone. Garage Inc. was their last record where James still had that ideal Metallica guitar tone for the I.
Re: Metallica - Load and Reload
Posted: 09 Oct 2021, 10:29
by Bill Clinton
rhino wrote: ↑26 May 2012, 06:43
i've said it before, they would be alot better now if they would stop trying to be the thrashers they once were and rock out some stoner/bluesy riffs instead