The Bernie Sanders speech
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
The Bernie Sanders speech
I won't call this a filibuster, because it didn't delay the Senate, but did anyone watch this? He spoke for 8-1/2 hours at length about the wrongness of the Republican demand that all tax cuts be extended or they would block the extension of the tax cuts for the lowest 98% of earners in the U.S. The goal was to draw attention to the deal struck between the White House and the Republicans to support a total extension so they can get an extension in unemployment benefits. He didn't limit himself strictly to the tax plan. He talked about income inequity, the past policy of the Congress to extend unemployment benefits despite who controls what branch of government, the new estate tax changes, the hypocrisy of demanding deficit reduction while adding so much to the deficit with tax cuts, and a number of other issues that concern the poorest 98% of Americans. It's nice to have one socialist in Congress.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
And taxes = deficit reduction how?
That is the most illogical thing I've ever heard. You know that money gotten from taxes doesn't equal money going towards reducing the deficit, usually it ends up as waste. The idea of tax cuts increasing the profits of the government is that it makes it easier for businesses to hire (small business is affected by the tax rates that are set to expire) therefore there are more wage earners and therefore there are more taxes going to the government.
The idea of unemployment lasting for three years is disgusting to me it teaches dependency something I'm 100% against. I agree with having a safety net for maybe a year but 3 years? Come on, that's insane. I'm just thankful that the spending bill didn't go through.
There is proof people find jobs more often around the time their benefits expire...."stroke me, for i wish to orgasm" I wonder why.
That is the most illogical thing I've ever heard. You know that money gotten from taxes doesn't equal money going towards reducing the deficit, usually it ends up as waste. The idea of tax cuts increasing the profits of the government is that it makes it easier for businesses to hire (small business is affected by the tax rates that are set to expire) therefore there are more wage earners and therefore there are more taxes going to the government.
The idea of unemployment lasting for three years is disgusting to me it teaches dependency something I'm 100% against. I agree with having a safety net for maybe a year but 3 years? Come on, that's insane. I'm just thankful that the spending bill didn't go through.
There is proof people find jobs more often around the time their benefits expire...."stroke me, for i wish to orgasm" I wonder why.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
If you allow tax rates to come up, the gap between spending and revenue will shrink. It is a fact. It's not like that additional money is going to be put elsewhere immediately. It just means the treasury doesn't have to sell as many bonds to cover the revenue shortfall. Taxes = revenue.
To the issue of unemployment, there are about five job seekers for every opening. The unemployment problem is structural. Corporate America is sitting on over $1 trillion in cash, but there is no need to add capacity. Demand isn't there, domestically or abroad. Ending unemployment benefits would not only put a lot of people at risk, it would depress the economy further. Unemployment benefits have a high impact, because they are always spent, and never saved. Tax cuts are often saved and rarely spent, especially in the higher brackets. That's why tax cuts are poor stimulus.
This is basic, non-crackpot, economic theory.
To the issue of unemployment, there are about five job seekers for every opening. The unemployment problem is structural. Corporate America is sitting on over $1 trillion in cash, but there is no need to add capacity. Demand isn't there, domestically or abroad. Ending unemployment benefits would not only put a lot of people at risk, it would depress the economy further. Unemployment benefits have a high impact, because they are always spent, and never saved. Tax cuts are often saved and rarely spent, especially in the higher brackets. That's why tax cuts are poor stimulus.
This is basic, non-crackpot, economic theory.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="The Fu Monster"] economic theory.[/quote]
Theory =/= fact, theory is an idea that sounds good but often put into practice doesn't work out. I have not said anything that hasn't been shown to be true.
Economics is based on what's worked, NOT theories. The FACT is people seem to not get employed until about 2 months BEFORE their unemployment benefits expire, that tells me there's a high level of abuse in the unemployment benefits. I know people who use them properly and definitely need them so I'm not stupid or heartless. However, extending unemployment to 3 years puts more of a damper on business the reason they aren't hiring is they don't know what's coming to get them, they don't know if they're going to have to pay more unemployment per worker, plus higher tax rates. This cuts their ability to grow and to hire. This has been shown. what helped our economy in the past? Tax cuts, rather you want to admit it or not. Common sense says raising taxes would cut the revenues of businesses therefore cut hiring and therefore cut the profits of the government and people. Also, the top earners are always going to find a way around super high tax rates we all know this. So guess who the tax hikes really affect? The middle class and small businesses.
Wanna know how to reduce the deficit? Simple, BUDGET PROPERLY, cut spending, cut public pensions (this applies to my state), you know live within our means and use common sense. The problem is nobody wants to lose anything, we all want something for "free".
Theory =/= fact, theory is an idea that sounds good but often put into practice doesn't work out. I have not said anything that hasn't been shown to be true.
Economics is based on what's worked, NOT theories. The FACT is people seem to not get employed until about 2 months BEFORE their unemployment benefits expire, that tells me there's a high level of abuse in the unemployment benefits. I know people who use them properly and definitely need them so I'm not stupid or heartless. However, extending unemployment to 3 years puts more of a damper on business the reason they aren't hiring is they don't know what's coming to get them, they don't know if they're going to have to pay more unemployment per worker, plus higher tax rates. This cuts their ability to grow and to hire. This has been shown. what helped our economy in the past? Tax cuts, rather you want to admit it or not. Common sense says raising taxes would cut the revenues of businesses therefore cut hiring and therefore cut the profits of the government and people. Also, the top earners are always going to find a way around super high tax rates we all know this. So guess who the tax hikes really affect? The middle class and small businesses.
Wanna know how to reduce the deficit? Simple, BUDGET PROPERLY, cut spending, cut public pensions (this applies to my state), you know live within our means and use common sense. The problem is nobody wants to lose anything, we all want something for "free".
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Economic theory provides a framework to analyze certain situations. That doesn't make it irrelevant. You try to adopt a model that fits the circumstance. If you insist on talking facts, it is a fact that there are far more job seekers than jobs. Abuse is not the issue, lack of jobs is. We don't have a situation where people don't want to take less than they were making previously, so they stay on unemployment insurance. That ended a long time ago. We have a situation of high, structural unemployment. Tax cuts won't fix this. As I said, corporate America has over $1 trillion in cash, but feels no urgency to create jobs. And super rich Americans don't create jobs. The most prosperous time in this country happened despite a high end marginal tax rate of over 90%. The reason was that U.S. manufacturing was still competitive, and unemployment was low. We made things people wanted to buy. Now we are a consumption-driven economy. The economy is depressed because demand is low. Demand is low because unemployment is high. Unemployment will remain high because U.S. exports are not doing well. Tax cuts simply won't fix that.
And I challenge you to balance a state or federal budget by spending cuts alone. It is impossible. Most federal spending goes toward the military, social security, Medicare and interest payments. Most state spending will go to education and Medicaid. I don't expect schools and libraries to operate for no cost - I expect to pay. The problem is the mentality that everyone needs to stand on his or her own feet and pay their way totally. If the poor needed to pay tuition to send their children to a public school, or everyone needed to pay a toll to use a public road, the country would be an awful place.
And I challenge you to balance a state or federal budget by spending cuts alone. It is impossible. Most federal spending goes toward the military, social security, Medicare and interest payments. Most state spending will go to education and Medicaid. I don't expect schools and libraries to operate for no cost - I expect to pay. The problem is the mentality that everyone needs to stand on his or her own feet and pay their way totally. If the poor needed to pay tuition to send their children to a public school, or everyone needed to pay a toll to use a public road, the country would be an awful place.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Spending cuts should be part of the solution though, I know that alone can't be the solution but they certainly couldn't hurt.
That tax rate of 90% is deceiving, we had tax deductions for everything nobody paid that.
Reforms on spending and cutting them have always helped stimulate our economy often accompanied with tax cuts like with Clinton, and Bush.
Government taking taxes doesn't create jobs either. Security and knowing what's coming tax wise/economy wise does help. Don't forget the tax rates affect existing businesses, if we raise costs on business there is no way for them to grow or to HIRE from growing, this is simply common sense. Business and the rich are not the enemy, out of control spending and asinine regulatory bills are a huge part of the problem.
I don't think any one group/person has all the answers but some things are obviously not working so we should try something that has in the past.
I thought we were on federal issues not state....education used to be strictly a state issue and actually worked better then but those were different times.
I never said no taxes, I just don't think we need super high taxes during a recession especially I think this would cause business to fire not hire based on past situations.
That tax rate of 90% is deceiving, we had tax deductions for everything nobody paid that.
Reforms on spending and cutting them have always helped stimulate our economy often accompanied with tax cuts like with Clinton, and Bush.
Government taking taxes doesn't create jobs either. Security and knowing what's coming tax wise/economy wise does help. Don't forget the tax rates affect existing businesses, if we raise costs on business there is no way for them to grow or to HIRE from growing, this is simply common sense. Business and the rich are not the enemy, out of control spending and asinine regulatory bills are a huge part of the problem.
I don't think any one group/person has all the answers but some things are obviously not working so we should try something that has in the past.
I thought we were on federal issues not state....education used to be strictly a state issue and actually worked better then but those were different times.
I never said no taxes, I just don't think we need super high taxes during a recession especially I think this would cause business to fire not hire based on past situations.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
I agree that any balanced budget will see tax increases and spending cuts. It would be onerous to put the burden solely on one or the other. Keep in mind, though, that we didn't need tax cuts during two wars - it had never been done before - but we got them. it turned out to be a horrible idea. Right now I would continue to run deficits, because there are no other options. I would also let the tax cuts for the top 2% expire, and scuttle the estate tax deal. Neither one of those things remaining is going to help the economy, especially the estate tax giveaway. The only thing that is going to get businesses of any size hiring again is demand.
We should have had an infrastructure stimulus passed in 2009, one that would have fixed the country's ailing components, and created enough temporary demand to hopefully offset the inevitable hangover from construction projects ending. Consider that if you rebuild a broken road, Caterpillar is going to sell earth movers, Ingersoll-Rand is going to sell compressors and generators, other small tools and equipment will be sold, restaurants will be patronized, and construction wages will be spent. Plus, you have a frigging road. The same goes for any civil and electrical engineering project - in the end they have utility. It's not like paying a person to dig a hole and then fill it. We were going to run staggering deficits regardless - it would have been smarter to just borrow $3 trillion and put the nation to work fixing itself. All we've done is run big deficits for little effect, and put off the pain of paying to update the infrastructure in the future when it could have helped now.
We should have had an infrastructure stimulus passed in 2009, one that would have fixed the country's ailing components, and created enough temporary demand to hopefully offset the inevitable hangover from construction projects ending. Consider that if you rebuild a broken road, Caterpillar is going to sell earth movers, Ingersoll-Rand is going to sell compressors and generators, other small tools and equipment will be sold, restaurants will be patronized, and construction wages will be spent. Plus, you have a frigging road. The same goes for any civil and electrical engineering project - in the end they have utility. It's not like paying a person to dig a hole and then fill it. We were going to run staggering deficits regardless - it would have been smarter to just borrow $3 trillion and put the nation to work fixing itself. All we've done is run big deficits for little effect, and put off the pain of paying to update the infrastructure in the future when it could have helped now.
- Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
- Ancient One
- Posts: 2215
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 01:08
- Location: ColoradO))))))
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Taxing the rich makes no sense - what about simply tearing apart the mechanisms that allowed them to get so rich in the first place. Taxation is a large part of what allows people to get rich. The super-rich are not beneficiaries of natural market mechanisms, they're the beneficiaries of coercion and artificial privilege. Taxation is a form of coercion that places the tax-collector into a position of artificial privilege.
And shit, most capitalists are getting fat off subsidies that were stolen right out of your paycheck. Not to mention zoning laws, intellectual "property", regulations (which are generally used to stifle small businesses, not big ones), etc. Capitalists are beneficiaries of state power, therefore the solution is not MORE fucking state power.
And shit, most capitalists are getting fat off subsidies that were stolen right out of your paycheck. Not to mention zoning laws, intellectual "property", regulations (which are generally used to stifle small businesses, not big ones), etc. Capitalists are beneficiaries of state power, therefore the solution is not MORE fucking state power.
[quote name="Verbal"]i would hate to be raped by an ugly person[/quote]
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Taxing the rich in the short term makes perfectly good sense to me. They have lots of money that simply doesn't get used. It's just there. Some of them have the right idea. Buffet and Gates spent many years between the two of them earning money, and now they're going to give away 99% of it. Good for them - they can't take it with them, and their descendants don't need that much money.
On to the issue of taxation as coercion: I don't like the idea of taxing labor. In the abstract, it does feel like theft. What else would you propose? People simply are not enlightened enough to live without a government and the things it can provide. Let us operate with the premise that the government isn't going to change much, structurally speaking. We need a balanced budget, and the income tax is the funding method of last resort. Where do we go? I say start with a transaction tax on financial services. The financial industry is one big casino anyway. A small tax would encourage useful investment by penalizing speculation. What else, though? Taxing consumption is highly regressive.
To spending cuts, I'm all for ending subsidies across the board. Big agribusiness has done well for itself, as has the petroleum industry, off of the public teat. Chip in. I enjoy this thought exercise. Try to keep it reasonable. Reducing the military budget is reasonable. Eliminating the military is not. Getting rid of the DEA is totally reasonable. Getting rid of every federal law enforcement officer is not.
On to the issue of taxation as coercion: I don't like the idea of taxing labor. In the abstract, it does feel like theft. What else would you propose? People simply are not enlightened enough to live without a government and the things it can provide. Let us operate with the premise that the government isn't going to change much, structurally speaking. We need a balanced budget, and the income tax is the funding method of last resort. Where do we go? I say start with a transaction tax on financial services. The financial industry is one big casino anyway. A small tax would encourage useful investment by penalizing speculation. What else, though? Taxing consumption is highly regressive.
To spending cuts, I'm all for ending subsidies across the board. Big agribusiness has done well for itself, as has the petroleum industry, off of the public teat. Chip in. I enjoy this thought exercise. Try to keep it reasonable. Reducing the military budget is reasonable. Eliminating the military is not. Getting rid of the DEA is totally reasonable. Getting rid of every federal law enforcement officer is not.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Explain just why the richest 2% should get the tax cuts. Justify their fucking need. Go ahead and tell me of their fucking suffering.
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
The estate tax deal is the worst part to me. It is a tax cut for the children of billionaires. It exists so the heirs to the Mars fortune get to live in extreme opulence, instead of just the regular kind.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Fucking crazy.
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
The estate tax affects farmers as well of course your anger towards the rich would cause you not to think about that. It's based on assets, if assets like land cost over a million and you have to pay 50% of that to the government the farmer's heirs would have to sell the land to pay it thus ending family run operations. But it's easier to vent and villainize all "rich heirs" into being more Paris Hiltons, isn't it?
Also the tax cuts affect those making 250k or above, not just the top 2%. Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways? Why should we encourage dependency and discourage improving ourselves and working our way up? That's what extremely high tax rates do. If we make the tax rates so high (with few deductions) we discourage talent and business from taking part in our country and we will lose in the global market, this is common sense to me.
Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.
Also the tax cuts affect those making 250k or above, not just the top 2%. Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways? Why should we encourage dependency and discourage improving ourselves and working our way up? That's what extremely high tax rates do. If we make the tax rates so high (with few deductions) we discourage talent and business from taking part in our country and we will lose in the global market, this is common sense to me.
Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Noyka"]The estate tax affects farmers as well of course your anger towards the rich would cause you not to think about that. It's based on assets, if assets like land cost over a million and you have to pay 50% of that to the government the farmer's heirs would have to sell the land to pay it thus ending family run operations. But it's easier to vent and villainize all "rich heirs" into being more Paris Hiltons, isn't it?
Also the tax cuts affect those making 250k or above, not just the top 2%. Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways? Why should we encourage dependency and discourage improving ourselves and working our way up? That's what extremely high tax rates do. If we make the tax rates so high (with few deductions) we discourage talent and business from taking part in our country and we will lose in the global market, this is common sense to me.
Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.[/quote]
No family farm has ever been lost due to the estate tax. That is a right wing smear. In the past, Democrats have offered to exempt estates well into the millions, but Republicans always say no. It isn't about protecting farmers - it's about protecting the super rich. The fact is that an estate tax makes good sense. It discourages the large-scale hoarding of wealth, which can be economically destructive.
Also the tax cuts affect those making 250k or above, not just the top 2%. Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways? Why should we encourage dependency and discourage improving ourselves and working our way up? That's what extremely high tax rates do. If we make the tax rates so high (with few deductions) we discourage talent and business from taking part in our country and we will lose in the global market, this is common sense to me.
Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.[/quote]
No family farm has ever been lost due to the estate tax. That is a right wing smear. In the past, Democrats have offered to exempt estates well into the millions, but Republicans always say no. It isn't about protecting farmers - it's about protecting the super rich. The fact is that an estate tax makes good sense. It discourages the large-scale hoarding of wealth, which can be economically destructive.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]No family farm has ever been lost due to the estate tax.[/quote]
This is a truth.
[quote name="Noyka"]Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.[/quote]
This is where your ignorance of the matter shows itself. These were Bush-era tax cuts off the standard taxation. It's a tax cut because it has always been a tax cut.
Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.
This is a truth.
[quote name="Noyka"]Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.[/quote]
This is where your ignorance of the matter shows itself. These were Bush-era tax cuts off the standard taxation. It's a tax cut because it has always been a tax cut.
Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- Grudge
- Metal God
- Posts: 10548
- Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 10:23
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
After reading some of the posts in this thread, I want to smash my keyboard.
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
smash out some truth, imran
tell it like it is
tell it like it is
- jawn galliano
- Yahtzee Genius
- Posts: 24065
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Noyka"]Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways?[/quote]
show me one place where banking a quarter-mil a year is not exceptionally well-off (hint: you cannot)
if the government doesn't have the right to tax people, i guess corporations and individuals in turn shouldn't have the right to benefit from things like public education, the highway system, the internet, modern medicine, etc.
show me one place where banking a quarter-mil a year is not exceptionally well-off (hint: you cannot)
if the government doesn't have the right to tax people, i guess corporations and individuals in turn shouldn't have the right to benefit from things like public education, the highway system, the internet, modern medicine, etc.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="hard-on bearer Incognito"]
[quote name="Noyka"]Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways?[/quote]
show me one place where banking a quarter-mil a year is not exceptionally well-off (hint: you cannot)
if the government doesn't have the right to tax people, i guess corporations and individuals in turn shouldn't have the right to benefit from things like public education, the highway system, the internet, modern medicine, etc.[/quote]
You fucking said it, sir.
[quote name="Noyka"]Depending on where you are 250k is not rich in the slightest sense of the word. What right does the government have to take what people have earned anyways?[/quote]
show me one place where banking a quarter-mil a year is not exceptionally well-off (hint: you cannot)
if the government doesn't have the right to tax people, i guess corporations and individuals in turn shouldn't have the right to benefit from things like public education, the highway system, the internet, modern medicine, etc.[/quote]
You fucking said it, sir.
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]No family farm has ever been lost due to the estate tax.[/quote]
This is a truth.
[quote name="Noyka"]Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.[/quote]
This is where your ignorance of the matter shows itself. These were Bush-era tax cuts off the standard taxation. It's a tax cut because it has always been a tax cut.
Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
Estate tax has never been at 50% that's what a proposed increase was so I was using it as an example and with land rates in some areas people would be forced to sell to pay off the debt,, which would have to be paid off in three months (Or is it 2 I can't reember).
250k is very much middle class (albeit upper middle class) and also includes small businesses, businesses who are having trouble as it is, I want to reach through the conmputer and shake some people for not understanding that. Try moving to areas in New York and northern California, 250k is comfotable but not rich. Rich is multi milliionaires, billionaires, ect.
It was a ta break that helped our economy. Now it would be raising taxes in a RECESSION and putting pressure on business that has enough pressure on them as it is, Estate tax is double taxing, just because someone makes what you consider obscene amounts of profit does not give you the right to take it from them, Profit is not obscene, it's what some do with it that is obscene and I firmy believe we do not have the right to regulate what people do with their individual money as long as it does not harm others
The government has a right to tax however there are limits. I personally believe in a flat tax because then everyone is equally vested in the tax rates and the top 5% wouldn't be paying 60% of the taxes like they do now which, as much as you may disagree with me, I find to be unfair. But this is because my thought process is a lot differen than most people's here, probably because I view the government totally different than most here but oh well.
Just because I disagree with you does not mean I'm ignorant on the subject, it means I think differently, Debate is part of a healthy system, don't like my opinion? Great, I still have a right to express it and vice versa. Believe me I come here and want to smash my face into the keyboard because of a lot of things a lot of you say, most of the time I keep from debating because it isn't worth it most here think way differently than I do which is fine but this is an issue that isworth it and I do have a clue about. Sorry my beliefs don't match yours, I guess that's what makes someone stupid or ignorant.
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]No family farm has ever been lost due to the estate tax.[/quote]
This is a truth.
[quote name="Noyka"]Also since when has keeping tax rates the SAME been a tax cut? That spin on it really confuses me.[/quote]
This is where your ignorance of the matter shows itself. These were Bush-era tax cuts off the standard taxation. It's a tax cut because it has always been a tax cut.
Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
Estate tax has never been at 50% that's what a proposed increase was so I was using it as an example and with land rates in some areas people would be forced to sell to pay off the debt,, which would have to be paid off in three months (Or is it 2 I can't reember).
250k is very much middle class (albeit upper middle class) and also includes small businesses, businesses who are having trouble as it is, I want to reach through the conmputer and shake some people for not understanding that. Try moving to areas in New York and northern California, 250k is comfotable but not rich. Rich is multi milliionaires, billionaires, ect.
It was a ta break that helped our economy. Now it would be raising taxes in a RECESSION and putting pressure on business that has enough pressure on them as it is, Estate tax is double taxing, just because someone makes what you consider obscene amounts of profit does not give you the right to take it from them, Profit is not obscene, it's what some do with it that is obscene and I firmy believe we do not have the right to regulate what people do with their individual money as long as it does not harm others
The government has a right to tax however there are limits. I personally believe in a flat tax because then everyone is equally vested in the tax rates and the top 5% wouldn't be paying 60% of the taxes like they do now which, as much as you may disagree with me, I find to be unfair. But this is because my thought process is a lot differen than most people's here, probably because I view the government totally different than most here but oh well.
Just because I disagree with you does not mean I'm ignorant on the subject, it means I think differently, Debate is part of a healthy system, don't like my opinion? Great, I still have a right to express it and vice versa. Believe me I come here and want to smash my face into the keyboard because of a lot of things a lot of you say, most of the time I keep from debating because it isn't worth it most here think way differently than I do which is fine but this is an issue that isworth it and I do have a clue about. Sorry my beliefs don't match yours, I guess that's what makes someone stupid or ignorant.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Flat taxes are regressive. They impact unequally those at the bottom. Taking 25% of a $30,000 income is a lot more painful than 25% of a $250,000 income. If you are going to tax labor, you need to do it in the fairest way possible. From each according to ability.
I need to point out that your position on tax cuts is just wrong given historical context. The Bush tax cuts did not help the economy. They were too expensive at the time. Any economic gains were given back in the recession. And because of the outrageous deficits, we are now hearing early calls for austerity, which absolutely won't help an economy that is stagnant. Letting tax cuts expire for the top 2% of earners isn't going to put any undue pressure on the economy - that income bracket is not responsible for a lot of job creation. Most small businesses are simply not that large I can make the same argument for the estate tax. It does nothing to help the economy. It is a giveaway to the children of millionaires and billionaires. It encourages the generational hoarding of wealth, rather than the constructive use of it. That is destructive.
Help me with my thought exercise, though. If you don't necessarily want to tax labor, what would you tax to raise money for the government? Ignore, for a second, spending cuts. Some will be needed, but that's not the topic here. Also keep in mind that you want taxes that aren't regressive. Sales tax and VAT are regressive, because low earners spend a larger percentage of their income on taxable items. I have put forth what seems to make sense to a good number of people, a tax on financial transactions like stock, derivatives, and commodities trading. It would be very small, perhaps 0.1%, but it would encourage investment, rather than speculation. The financial services industry is casino capitalism. That tax is good for hundreds of billions, given the volume of those transactions. There is carbon taxation to consider. I think it's better than a cap-and-trade system. A revised corporate tax code would be nice. The rates, on paper, appear high. The fact is that there are so many legal accounting loopholes that corporations often pay very little in tax. If you set it at something like 12.5% with no giveaways, you could claim publicly we have competitive rates when compared to the rest of the international community. So yeah, your turn.
I need to point out that your position on tax cuts is just wrong given historical context. The Bush tax cuts did not help the economy. They were too expensive at the time. Any economic gains were given back in the recession. And because of the outrageous deficits, we are now hearing early calls for austerity, which absolutely won't help an economy that is stagnant. Letting tax cuts expire for the top 2% of earners isn't going to put any undue pressure on the economy - that income bracket is not responsible for a lot of job creation. Most small businesses are simply not that large I can make the same argument for the estate tax. It does nothing to help the economy. It is a giveaway to the children of millionaires and billionaires. It encourages the generational hoarding of wealth, rather than the constructive use of it. That is destructive.
Help me with my thought exercise, though. If you don't necessarily want to tax labor, what would you tax to raise money for the government? Ignore, for a second, spending cuts. Some will be needed, but that's not the topic here. Also keep in mind that you want taxes that aren't regressive. Sales tax and VAT are regressive, because low earners spend a larger percentage of their income on taxable items. I have put forth what seems to make sense to a good number of people, a tax on financial transactions like stock, derivatives, and commodities trading. It would be very small, perhaps 0.1%, but it would encourage investment, rather than speculation. The financial services industry is casino capitalism. That tax is good for hundreds of billions, given the volume of those transactions. There is carbon taxation to consider. I think it's better than a cap-and-trade system. A revised corporate tax code would be nice. The rates, on paper, appear high. The fact is that there are so many legal accounting loopholes that corporations often pay very little in tax. If you set it at something like 12.5% with no giveaways, you could claim publicly we have competitive rates when compared to the rest of the international community. So yeah, your turn.
- Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
- Ancient One
- Posts: 2215
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 01:08
- Location: ColoradO))))))
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
I'll maybe come back with a more substantial reply, although I'm not sure it's worth it. I just want to clear up one misconception: I don't believe "duh free market" is magical (and I'm so god damned sick of libertarians and conservatives who willingly feed that misconception that I'm contemplating calling myself a socialist), it requires constant vigilance and rebellion, just like with governments. I advocate replacing both corporations and government bodies with democratic customer/taxpayer/worker-owned cooperatives. Mutualization, not privatization.
The market needs to be equalized before it can be privatized, since it currently rests on hundreds of years of theft and enslavement. But trusting the government to do take care of that is kind of like calling the SS and warning them there's a Hitler on the loose.
The market needs to be equalized before it can be privatized, since it currently rests on hundreds of years of theft and enslavement. But trusting the government to do take care of that is kind of like calling the SS and warning them there's a Hitler on the loose.
[quote name="Verbal"]i would hate to be raped by an ugly person[/quote]
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
- jawn galliano
- Yahtzee Genius
- Posts: 24065
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
250k is very much middle class (albeit upper middle class) and also includes small businesses, businesses who are having trouble as it is, I want to reach through the conmputer and shake some people for not understanding that.
The feeling is mutual. US median household income is ~45k/year. Saying that someone earning 5x the median is anywhere even remotely close to the middle is complete and utter nonsense. people making 250k/year lease S-classes which they park in three-car garages. how many of those do you see bombing around a basic middle-class suburb?
it's what some do with it that is obscene and I firmy believe we do not have the right to regulate what people do with their individual money as long as it does not harm others
so, i guess multimillionaires and billionaires and so-forth, using their vast wealth to distort and subvert the political process to further enlarge their fortunes, at the expense of the overwhelming majority of the population's well-being, isn't harmful. okay.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
I have no sympathy for a person making $250,000 a year and crying poverty because he or she is unwilling to scale back his or her standard of living to more reasonable expectations. They'll still be better off than most of the country. Plenty of people seem to get by in New York and New Jersey on much less.
- captain twat. IV.
- Ancient One
- Posts: 1352
- Joined: 29 Sep 2009, 14:13
- Location: New York
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
LOL@250k middle class.Glad you have had a great upbringing though Noyka.

- bills bro
- Ancient One
- Posts: 1914
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 00:39
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="Noyka"]250k is very much middle class (albeit upper middle class) and also includes small businesses, businesses who are having trouble as it is, I want to reach through the conmputer and shake some people for not understanding that. Try moving to areas in New York and northern California, 250k is comfotable but not rich. Rich is multi milliionaires, billionaires, ect.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="Noyka"]250k is very much middle class (albeit upper middle class) and also includes small businesses, businesses who are having trouble as it is, I want to reach through the conmputer and shake some people for not understanding that. Try moving to areas in New York and northern California, 250k is comfotable but not rich. Rich is multi milliionaires, billionaires, ect.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
i havent read this thread, but nokya is probably wrong
i may read it to see if it disagree with anyone else, but i probably wont
carry on
i may read it to see if it disagree with anyone else, but i probably wont
carry on
- jawn galliano
- Yahtzee Genius
- Posts: 24065
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
gleeso, you might be kind of a cunt
but you're my kind of cunt
never change, buddy
but you're my kind of cunt
never change, buddy
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Tax rates and tax breaks are two different things people don't understand that.
250k is upper middle class rather you people want to admit it or not, especially in areas of California and New York. They're able to make it now but upping the tax rates will force people to downsize more. mabb_ if you have to know my upbringing has been very much middle class I just see things differently than most on this board assumption is never a good thing.
The political process has been corrupted for a long time, I see that point and do agree we have regulation in that area for a reason. What I'm talking about is if someone wants to buy a yacht and can afford it we have no right to stop them, those people can afford a tax increase people at the 250k line in most cases can't.
Flat tax doesn't harm those at the bottom anymore than people at the top, flat 15% for all plus upping the sales tax on items that are non-essential like amusement parks, luxury items, ect would make everyone accountable. If we have too many people with their hands out and not enough paying into the system we have a problem. You are aware about 47% of Americans are getting hand outs and essentially not paying in? That is obscene, we all should pay in rather you make 20k or 20 billion we should all pay in. It's my firm belief and nothing you say will change my mind because I've heard your opinions before and seen what it's done in other countries which is where we are heading and it's not good.
Guess what groups help people a lot in America? Non-profits funded by GASP! charitable donations they're who help those who can't afford certain necessary medical procedures and help them to help themselves. Guess who gives to them? Not the government, individuals.
250k is upper middle class rather you people want to admit it or not, especially in areas of California and New York. They're able to make it now but upping the tax rates will force people to downsize more. mabb_ if you have to know my upbringing has been very much middle class I just see things differently than most on this board assumption is never a good thing.
The political process has been corrupted for a long time, I see that point and do agree we have regulation in that area for a reason. What I'm talking about is if someone wants to buy a yacht and can afford it we have no right to stop them, those people can afford a tax increase people at the 250k line in most cases can't.
Flat tax doesn't harm those at the bottom anymore than people at the top, flat 15% for all plus upping the sales tax on items that are non-essential like amusement parks, luxury items, ect would make everyone accountable. If we have too many people with their hands out and not enough paying into the system we have a problem. You are aware about 47% of Americans are getting hand outs and essentially not paying in? That is obscene, we all should pay in rather you make 20k or 20 billion we should all pay in. It's my firm belief and nothing you say will change my mind because I've heard your opinions before and seen what it's done in other countries which is where we are heading and it's not good.
Guess what groups help people a lot in America? Non-profits funded by GASP! charitable donations they're who help those who can't afford certain necessary medical procedures and help them to help themselves. Guess who gives to them? Not the government, individuals.
- Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
- Ancient One
- Posts: 2215
- Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 01:08
- Location: ColoradO))))))
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
It's a really fucked up kind of libertarianism that looks at all the downright evil and sadistic things our government does, and says, "you know what really sucks? that welfare!" Compared to the money spent on slaughtering millions of human beings, welfare is hardly a drop in the bucket. Simply shutting down the war efforts, bringing all the troops home, closing down foreign bases, and slashing the military budget would free up enough resources to allow the free market some breathing room, while simultaneously maintaining a large welfare state. The patient needs to heal before you yank out its IV drip.
[quote name="Verbal"]i would hate to be raped by an ugly person[/quote]
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
[quote name="ANGEL OF DESEASE"]This kinds of stuff are very gay cause is involved the brain, not the penis[/quote]
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Noyka"]250k is upper middle class rather you people want to admit it or not,[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]It's a really fucked up kind of libertarianism that looks at all the downright evil and sadistic things our government does, and says, "you know what really throws shit on the fire? that welfare!" Compared to the money spent on slaughtering millions of human beings, welfare is hardly a drop in the bucket. Simply shutting down the war efforts, bringing all the troops home, closing down foreign bases, and slashing the military budget would free up enough resources to allow the free market some breathing room, while simultaneously maintaining a large welfare state. The patient needs to heal before you yank out its IV drip.[/quote]
Not if Glen Beck says otherwise!

Not if Glen Beck says otherwise!
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]It's a really fucked up kind of libertarianism that looks at all the downright evil and sadistic things our government does, and says, "you know what really throws shit on the fire? that welfare!" Compared to the money spent on slaughtering millions of human beings, welfare is hardly a drop in the bucket. Simply shutting down the war efforts, bringing all the troops home, closing down foreign bases, and slashing the military budget would free up enough resources to allow the free market some breathing room, while simultaneously maintaining a large welfare state. The patient needs to heal before you yank out its IV drip.[/quote]
It is not fucked up, it is the belief that we can create climates where people can and will move up. A welfare state is not a good idea at all, creating dependency is never a good idea it creates a new kind of slavery something I think that's morally reprehensible.
Don't get me started on our foreign policy, especially with Latin America.
__________________
People/families making 250k live middle class life styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.
Maybe I'm having a moment here but what the hell does Glenn fucking Beck have to do with anything?
It is not fucked up, it is the belief that we can create climates where people can and will move up. A welfare state is not a good idea at all, creating dependency is never a good idea it creates a new kind of slavery something I think that's morally reprehensible.
Don't get me started on our foreign policy, especially with Latin America.
__________________
People/families making 250k live middle class life styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.
Maybe I'm having a moment here but what the hell does Glenn fucking Beck have to do with anything?
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Don't get butthurt, Liz. 
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
glenn beck is always relevant
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Noyka"]People/families making 250k live middle class manwhore styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.[/quote]
The Bush era tax was not the standard tax but A TAX CUT. The debate was who to keep the cut for and who to let it expire on. That said,
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
The Bush era tax was not the standard tax but A TAX CUT. The debate was who to keep the cut for and who to let it expire on. That said,
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]People/families making 250k live middle class manwhore styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.[/quote]
The Bush era tax was not the standard tax but A TAX CUT. The debate was who to keep the cut for and who to let it expire on. That said,
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote][/quote]
I answered this, they have to cut back MORE than they already have. They are not super rich families. They are middle class, home owners (in some areas) and struggling as it is.
It WAS a tax cut, now it is a tax rate that should be made permanent. Raising taxes in a recession is the LAST thing we need to do.
When rates were super high there were lots of breaks/deductions people could get. With all the slashes to that raising taxes would be unfair to those who pay them.
I've heard somewhere that 47% of Americans don't pay in, by receiving more than they put in, that is obscene if it's true.
[quote name="Noyka"]People/families making 250k live middle class manwhore styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.[/quote]
The Bush era tax was not the standard tax but A TAX CUT. The debate was who to keep the cut for and who to let it expire on. That said,
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote][/quote]
I answered this, they have to cut back MORE than they already have. They are not super rich families. They are middle class, home owners (in some areas) and struggling as it is.
It WAS a tax cut, now it is a tax rate that should be made permanent. Raising taxes in a recession is the LAST thing we need to do.
When rates were super high there were lots of breaks/deductions people could get. With all the slashes to that raising taxes would be unfair to those who pay them.
I've heard somewhere that 47% of Americans don't pay in, by receiving more than they put in, that is obscene if it's true.
- jawn galliano
- Yahtzee Genius
- Posts: 24065
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
if you make 250k or more and you are not already a millionaire or on track to become one in a short time, you need to drop the terrible cocaine addiction. seriously. being in, literally, the very top percentiles of earners in the country does not place you anywhere remotely close to the middle.
give a concrete example of an area where the average cost of living for an average household is $250,000/year. back it up with some data.
give a concrete example of an area where the average cost of living for an average household is $250,000/year. back it up with some data.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]People/families making 250k live middle class manwhore styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.[/quote]
The Bush era tax was not the standard tax but A TAX CUT. The debate was who to keep the cut for and who to let it expire on. That said,
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote][/quote]
I answered this, they have to cut back MORE than they already have. They are not super rich families. They are middle class, home owners (in some areas) and struggling as it is.
It WAS a tax cut, now it is a tax rate that should be made permanent. Raising taxes in a recession is the LAST thing we need to do.
When rates were super high there were lots of breaks/deductions people could get. With all the slashes to that raising taxes would be unfair to those who pay them.
I've heard somewhere that 47% of Americans don't pay in, by receiving more than they put in, that is obscene if it's true.[/quote]
Most U.S. multinational corporations pay no tax. I paid more tax last year than GE, Bank of America and ExxonMobil combined. That is more obscene than the figure you mentioned.
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]People/families making 250k live middle class manwhore styles, raising taxes is not a tax cut it is a tax increase and this will cause them to cut spending hurting the economy more.[/quote]
The Bush era tax was not the standard tax but A TAX CUT. The debate was who to keep the cut for and who to let it expire on. That said,
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote]
[quote name="desolation"]Please explain how someone making over 250k/year is suffering and needs a tax cut.[/quote][/quote]
I answered this, they have to cut back MORE than they already have. They are not super rich families. They are middle class, home owners (in some areas) and struggling as it is.
It WAS a tax cut, now it is a tax rate that should be made permanent. Raising taxes in a recession is the LAST thing we need to do.
When rates were super high there were lots of breaks/deductions people could get. With all the slashes to that raising taxes would be unfair to those who pay them.
I've heard somewhere that 47% of Americans don't pay in, by receiving more than they put in, that is obscene if it's true.[/quote]
Most U.S. multinational corporations pay no tax. I paid more tax last year than GE, Bank of America and ExxonMobil combined. That is more obscene than the figure you mentioned.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="hard-on bearer Incognito"]if you make 250k or more and you are not already a millionaire or on track to become one in a short time, you need to drop the terrible cocaine addiction. seriously. being in, literally, the very top percentiles of earners in the country does not place you anywhere remotely close to the middle.
give a concrete example of an area where the average cost of living for an average household is $250,000/year. back it up with some data.[/quote]
You want proof? Okay, I'll flat out tell you my family makes 250,000 a year now (my dad didn't always) and we had to move to the bay area due to my dad's job transfer. When we moved here we knew because of my brother we couldn't rent, it wouldn't work with him. So we decided we'd cut back in order to afford buying a home. We had to buy a home well outside of our price range because this was right before the housing bubble burst. A small home was at least a million dollars, the house my parents eventually picked was around 950,000. Combine high state tax levels, high federal tax levels, no cost of living, I can assure you we are not fucking rich and it is insulting to be told because my dad has worked his ass off, 100 hour weeks often that he needs to pay more when he's already paid. He worked his way up and it comes across to me that people claiming 250,000 is the same as 5,000,000 are insulting people like him.
Percentiles don't mean a damn thing to me, I see how people are actually living and go by that. We don't take fancy trips, buy expensive things. We're good at budgeting (we live on coupons) and we occasionally splurge, yes but that is not criminal I think all families save up and splurge a little if they want to take a trip or whatever. I'm sorry if I come across offensive or whatever I'm just tired of being told my family is evil because we make 250,000 now we didn't always and I don't see a reason why my parents should be punished for being normal hard working people.
______________________________________________________________________
Fu: Do you directly provide jobs? Do you have to pay benefits/ect for employees? Sorry, I don't think business should be made a villain. If there are loopholes and taxes are high of course companies are going to take advantage of them, why? IT'S EXPENSIVE TO DO BUSINESS IN THE US NOW common sense!
I think both are obscene, 47% not paying in if true (I don't remember where I heard it or if it is true) is unsustainable, you know it, I know it, we all know it.
give a concrete example of an area where the average cost of living for an average household is $250,000/year. back it up with some data.[/quote]
You want proof? Okay, I'll flat out tell you my family makes 250,000 a year now (my dad didn't always) and we had to move to the bay area due to my dad's job transfer. When we moved here we knew because of my brother we couldn't rent, it wouldn't work with him. So we decided we'd cut back in order to afford buying a home. We had to buy a home well outside of our price range because this was right before the housing bubble burst. A small home was at least a million dollars, the house my parents eventually picked was around 950,000. Combine high state tax levels, high federal tax levels, no cost of living, I can assure you we are not fucking rich and it is insulting to be told because my dad has worked his ass off, 100 hour weeks often that he needs to pay more when he's already paid. He worked his way up and it comes across to me that people claiming 250,000 is the same as 5,000,000 are insulting people like him.
Percentiles don't mean a damn thing to me, I see how people are actually living and go by that. We don't take fancy trips, buy expensive things. We're good at budgeting (we live on coupons) and we occasionally splurge, yes but that is not criminal I think all families save up and splurge a little if they want to take a trip or whatever. I'm sorry if I come across offensive or whatever I'm just tired of being told my family is evil because we make 250,000 now we didn't always and I don't see a reason why my parents should be punished for being normal hard working people.
______________________________________________________________________
Fu: Do you directly provide jobs? Do you have to pay benefits/ect for employees? Sorry, I don't think business should be made a villain. If there are loopholes and taxes are high of course companies are going to take advantage of them, why? IT'S EXPENSIVE TO DO BUSINESS IN THE US NOW common sense!
I think both are obscene, 47% not paying in if true (I don't remember where I heard it or if it is true) is unsustainable, you know it, I know it, we all know it.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
That I paid more taxes on less than $50,000 of income than three companies did on a combined profit of nearly $50 billion is disgusting. It is indefensible. We give away billions every year to large corporations so they can cry poverty and ship jobs overseas. You say it is too expensive to do business here. I say we're too hospitable. What is the point of a 35% marginal tax rate if it never gets paid? It's just a Republican straw man at this point. Eliminate subsidies, credits and deductions for corporations and then look at the rate on the books. Those corporations are inevitably going to do business here.
To the issue of people receiving more than they pay, it's the nature of the progressive tax system. It's fair. From those according to ability, to those according to need. Someone living below the poverty line can't afford to part with any of his or her income. It's why a flat tax is regressive, not fair. You also ignore things like sales taxes, taxes on telecommunications, car registration, driver's license fees, and other service fees or taxes. Those raise money for governments below the federal level, and they're all highly regressive. The working poor are already in a bad situation. A flat tax with few or no deductions is just too much.
To the issue of people receiving more than they pay, it's the nature of the progressive tax system. It's fair. From those according to ability, to those according to need. Someone living below the poverty line can't afford to part with any of his or her income. It's why a flat tax is regressive, not fair. You also ignore things like sales taxes, taxes on telecommunications, car registration, driver's license fees, and other service fees or taxes. Those raise money for governments below the federal level, and they're all highly regressive. The working poor are already in a bad situation. A flat tax with few or no deductions is just too much.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]That I paid more taxes on less than $50,000 of income than three companies did on a combined profit of nearly $50 billion is disgusting. It is indefensible. We give away billions every year to large corporations so they can cry poverty and ship jobs overseas. You say it is too expensive to do business here. I say we're too hospitable. What is the point of a 35% marginal tax rate if it never gets paid? It's just a Republican straw man at this point. Eliminate subsidies, credits and deductions for corporations and then look at the rate on the books. Those corporations are inevitably going to do business here.
To the issue of people receiving more than they pay, it's the nature of the progressive tax system. It's fair. From those according to ability, to those according to need. Someone living below the poverty line can't afford to part with any of his or her income. It's why a flat tax is regressive, not fair. You also ignore things like sales taxes, taxes on telecommunications, car registration, driver's license fees, and other service fees or taxes. Those raise money for governments below the federal level, and they're all highly regressive. The working poor are already in a bad situation. A flat tax with few or no deductions is just too much.[/quote]
The welfare state has been proven to be unsustainable. A flat tax keeps people responsible, allows a climate where people can move up without being "punished", and would only hurt people because a large percentage are not paying taxes now. 15% is 15% if you make 40,000 or 40,000,000. I respect the working class and believe individuals can you know take care of themselves without the government. I have friends that do it, my family has done it, and all of us come from different places. There should be programs to help those that genuinely can't help themselves but large redistribution of wealth like we're starting to see now is unsustainable and VICTIMIZES the working class if you ask me. I don't think there are many people that genuinely want to depend on the government.
Have you ever run a business or taken a business class? I'm curious because I don't think you understand business. I mean I'm no expert (I've never run one myself obviously) but I have had classes (not that, that counts for much) I have two parents that are very business/finance oriented and have experience in the fields and I learn from them and business here is expensive, they move where the rates are cheaper, it's not a republican thing it's a common sense thing something you seem to lack. America doesn't just give money to corporations what the hell are you on about? If you're talking about the bailouts, nobody was for that and that was a power grab done by mostly democrats so yeah.
I addressed the sales tax, I think we should add a federal tax on luxury items, that would be fair. Wait? So the working class have to pay sales tax too? Oh gasp! Everyone does, it's part of living. Sorry I just don't believe in victimizing people which is what I feel progressives do and it angers me. I believe if anything these hand outs take away incentive to pull oneself up. Your view of the world and mine are totally opposite but this what is important to hear, both sides if you agree with it or not. There is no such thing as a free ride in a monetary society. You are dreaming if you think what you want is actually sustainable because it's failed other places big time.
To the issue of people receiving more than they pay, it's the nature of the progressive tax system. It's fair. From those according to ability, to those according to need. Someone living below the poverty line can't afford to part with any of his or her income. It's why a flat tax is regressive, not fair. You also ignore things like sales taxes, taxes on telecommunications, car registration, driver's license fees, and other service fees or taxes. Those raise money for governments below the federal level, and they're all highly regressive. The working poor are already in a bad situation. A flat tax with few or no deductions is just too much.[/quote]
The welfare state has been proven to be unsustainable. A flat tax keeps people responsible, allows a climate where people can move up without being "punished", and would only hurt people because a large percentage are not paying taxes now. 15% is 15% if you make 40,000 or 40,000,000. I respect the working class and believe individuals can you know take care of themselves without the government. I have friends that do it, my family has done it, and all of us come from different places. There should be programs to help those that genuinely can't help themselves but large redistribution of wealth like we're starting to see now is unsustainable and VICTIMIZES the working class if you ask me. I don't think there are many people that genuinely want to depend on the government.
Have you ever run a business or taken a business class? I'm curious because I don't think you understand business. I mean I'm no expert (I've never run one myself obviously) but I have had classes (not that, that counts for much) I have two parents that are very business/finance oriented and have experience in the fields and I learn from them and business here is expensive, they move where the rates are cheaper, it's not a republican thing it's a common sense thing something you seem to lack. America doesn't just give money to corporations what the hell are you on about? If you're talking about the bailouts, nobody was for that and that was a power grab done by mostly democrats so yeah.
I addressed the sales tax, I think we should add a federal tax on luxury items, that would be fair. Wait? So the working class have to pay sales tax too? Oh gasp! Everyone does, it's part of living. Sorry I just don't believe in victimizing people which is what I feel progressives do and it angers me. I believe if anything these hand outs take away incentive to pull oneself up. Your view of the world and mine are totally opposite but this what is important to hear, both sides if you agree with it or not. There is no such thing as a free ride in a monetary society. You are dreaming if you think what you want is actually sustainable because it's failed other places big time.
- Meat Engine
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4451
- Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
- Contact:
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Oh noes, you had better tell Germany and the Netherlands that the welfare state doesn't work. Maybe their welfare system works because they haven't heard the news! Or it could be that you're wrong. It does work. It is sustainable. Germany runs the second highest trade surplus in the world. It has the strongest European economy. It has a less significant unemployment problem than the United States. I know what you're thinking now. Ireland has problems. Spain has problems. Greece has problems. They are less related to the welfare state than they are to the whole economic picture.
Farm subsidies are a giveaway to large factory farmers, not small family ones. There are energy research grants that go to oil companies who have no energy plans past running the wells dry. Accounting rules allow businesses to defer loss deductions to years when their tax bill would be more substantial. The fact is that it isn't as expensive to do business here as the Chamber of Commerce would have people believe. There is no VAT. Graft isn't an institution. The problem is those pesky workers expect a certain standard of living. A wage that they can live off of without, as you say, depending on the government.
I have to ask if you understand economics at all. A person making $20,000 a year in a low-paying job can't afford a 15% tax rate. They probably can't even afford a 5% tax rate. A person making $20,000,000 a year can easily afford a higher than 50% tax rate. I'm not saying tax a mega-millionaire at that rate, but I am making a point. Flat taxes sound nice and fair, but when you look at who suffers and who benefits, it's not fair at all. The person making $20,000 will spend 100% of his or her income, and probably more with state and federal aid. The person making $20,000,000 will not spend close to 100%. Much if it will be hoarded, or used to buy a luxury that does not contribute much to the economy. There you have it. It makes moral and economic sense, if we are going to tax income, for those that are able to pay a higher rate.
You seem to have an incorrect notion of progressives. I'll fill you in. I don't want control of people's lives. I want people to be in control of their lives. Working two full time jobs just to support a family isn't control. Staying at a job you hate because it's the only way of getting medical insurance isn't control. Telling someone to pull themselves up in an economy that has become increasingly stratified is a cruel joke. Upward mobility is a thing of the past.
Farm subsidies are a giveaway to large factory farmers, not small family ones. There are energy research grants that go to oil companies who have no energy plans past running the wells dry. Accounting rules allow businesses to defer loss deductions to years when their tax bill would be more substantial. The fact is that it isn't as expensive to do business here as the Chamber of Commerce would have people believe. There is no VAT. Graft isn't an institution. The problem is those pesky workers expect a certain standard of living. A wage that they can live off of without, as you say, depending on the government.
I have to ask if you understand economics at all. A person making $20,000 a year in a low-paying job can't afford a 15% tax rate. They probably can't even afford a 5% tax rate. A person making $20,000,000 a year can easily afford a higher than 50% tax rate. I'm not saying tax a mega-millionaire at that rate, but I am making a point. Flat taxes sound nice and fair, but when you look at who suffers and who benefits, it's not fair at all. The person making $20,000 will spend 100% of his or her income, and probably more with state and federal aid. The person making $20,000,000 will not spend close to 100%. Much if it will be hoarded, or used to buy a luxury that does not contribute much to the economy. There you have it. It makes moral and economic sense, if we are going to tax income, for those that are able to pay a higher rate.
You seem to have an incorrect notion of progressives. I'll fill you in. I don't want control of people's lives. I want people to be in control of their lives. Working two full time jobs just to support a family isn't control. Staying at a job you hate because it's the only way of getting medical insurance isn't control. Telling someone to pull themselves up in an economy that has become increasingly stratified is a cruel joke. Upward mobility is a thing of the past.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Jesus fucking christ, Liz. 
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Oh noes, you had better tell Germany and the Netherlands that the welfare state doesn't work. Maybe their welfare system works because they haven't heard the news! Or it could be that you're wrong. It does work. It is sustainable. Germany runs the second highest trade surplus in the world. It has the strongest European economy. It has a less significant unemployment problem than the United States. I know what you're thinking now. Ireland has problems. Spain has problems. Greece has problems. They are less related to the welfare state than they are to the whole economic picture.
Farm subsidies are a giveaway to large factory farmers, not small family ones. There are energy research grants that go to oil companies who have no energy plans past running the wells dry. Accounting rules allow businesses to defer loss deductions to years when their tax bill would be more substantial. The fact is that it isn't as expensive to do business here as the Chamber of Commerce would have people believe. There is no VAT. Graft isn't an institution. The problem is those pesky workers expect a certain standard of living. A wage that they can live off of without, as you say, depending on the government.
I have to ask if you understand economics at all. A person making $20,000 a year in a low-paying job can't afford a 15% tax rate. They probably can't even afford a 5% tax rate. A person making $20,000,000 a year can easily afford a higher than 50% tax rate. I'm not saying tax a mega-millionaire at that rate, but I am making a point. Flat taxes sound nice and fair, but when you look at who suffers and who benefits, it's not fair at all. The person making $20,000 will spend 100% of his or her income, and probably more with state and federal aid. The person making $20,000,000 will not spend close to 100%. Much if it will be hoarded, or used to buy a luxury that does not contribute much to the economy. There you have it. It makes moral and economic sense, if we are going to tax income, for those that are able to pay a higher rate.
You seem to have an incorrect notion of progressives. I'll fill you in. I don't want control of people's lives. I want people to be in control of their lives. Working two full time jobs just to support a family isn't control. Staying at a job you hate because it's the only way of getting medical insurance isn't control. Telling someone to pull themselves up in an economy that has become increasingly stratified is a cruel make believe fairy. Upward mobility is a thing of the past.
[/quote]
Oh noes Germany cut back big time on their spending and are a fraction of the size of the US oh and they don't have to crazy wealth gaps we have, if I'm not mistaken both countries have been cutting back big time and making things work I'm not sure about that though.
The subsidies are government trying to control business, nothing more, nothing less. They aren't a hand out to business they are a pay back to industries that help keep those in power in power a lot of times. Bad example.
It improves business and gives a CHANCE for the poor to move up, something a progressive tax system doesn't have it punishes for moving up and victimizes those who it doesn't punish. No I have a view that differs from yours and it is not a thing of the past. You are the one living in a fairy tale if that's what you think. I'm cruel because I believe whole heartedly that individuals can be independent and don't need the government to victimize and control them like has happened elsewhere? I'm sorry but that statement is beyond old. Like I said, different world views deal with it.
Maybe, but if we make business expensive here we're going to start losing revenue big time they will go where it is cheaper. Guess who suffers then? The people you claim to represent with a progressive tax system. Sorry, I see things differently and simply don't agree with your theory. We have different world views and that's all.
The forcing of people to work to get healthcare isn't my idea, my idea is using the free market system properly to make it cheaper not having a single group (government) in charge. That ultimately leads to things like encouraging end of life decisions that are cheaper instead of what the individual may want. Everyone deserves a chance. The reason our economy is the way it is right now if because of government intervention like the subsidies which are screwing with a once working system.
I don't pretend to be an expert but I do understand the basics of economics, I'm not a moron. You never did answer my question on business, I assume you have no experience because you seem to think business expenses are nothing when that couldn't be farther from the truth, a basic business accounting class will teach anyone that.
Farm subsidies are a giveaway to large factory farmers, not small family ones. There are energy research grants that go to oil companies who have no energy plans past running the wells dry. Accounting rules allow businesses to defer loss deductions to years when their tax bill would be more substantial. The fact is that it isn't as expensive to do business here as the Chamber of Commerce would have people believe. There is no VAT. Graft isn't an institution. The problem is those pesky workers expect a certain standard of living. A wage that they can live off of without, as you say, depending on the government.
I have to ask if you understand economics at all. A person making $20,000 a year in a low-paying job can't afford a 15% tax rate. They probably can't even afford a 5% tax rate. A person making $20,000,000 a year can easily afford a higher than 50% tax rate. I'm not saying tax a mega-millionaire at that rate, but I am making a point. Flat taxes sound nice and fair, but when you look at who suffers and who benefits, it's not fair at all. The person making $20,000 will spend 100% of his or her income, and probably more with state and federal aid. The person making $20,000,000 will not spend close to 100%. Much if it will be hoarded, or used to buy a luxury that does not contribute much to the economy. There you have it. It makes moral and economic sense, if we are going to tax income, for those that are able to pay a higher rate.
You seem to have an incorrect notion of progressives. I'll fill you in. I don't want control of people's lives. I want people to be in control of their lives. Working two full time jobs just to support a family isn't control. Staying at a job you hate because it's the only way of getting medical insurance isn't control. Telling someone to pull themselves up in an economy that has become increasingly stratified is a cruel make believe fairy. Upward mobility is a thing of the past.
[/quote]
Oh noes Germany cut back big time on their spending and are a fraction of the size of the US oh and they don't have to crazy wealth gaps we have, if I'm not mistaken both countries have been cutting back big time and making things work I'm not sure about that though.
The subsidies are government trying to control business, nothing more, nothing less. They aren't a hand out to business they are a pay back to industries that help keep those in power in power a lot of times. Bad example.
It improves business and gives a CHANCE for the poor to move up, something a progressive tax system doesn't have it punishes for moving up and victimizes those who it doesn't punish. No I have a view that differs from yours and it is not a thing of the past. You are the one living in a fairy tale if that's what you think. I'm cruel because I believe whole heartedly that individuals can be independent and don't need the government to victimize and control them like has happened elsewhere? I'm sorry but that statement is beyond old. Like I said, different world views deal with it.
Maybe, but if we make business expensive here we're going to start losing revenue big time they will go where it is cheaper. Guess who suffers then? The people you claim to represent with a progressive tax system. Sorry, I see things differently and simply don't agree with your theory. We have different world views and that's all.
The forcing of people to work to get healthcare isn't my idea, my idea is using the free market system properly to make it cheaper not having a single group (government) in charge. That ultimately leads to things like encouraging end of life decisions that are cheaper instead of what the individual may want. Everyone deserves a chance. The reason our economy is the way it is right now if because of government intervention like the subsidies which are screwing with a once working system.
I don't pretend to be an expert but I do understand the basics of economics, I'm not a moron. You never did answer my question on business, I assume you have no experience because you seem to think business expenses are nothing when that couldn't be farther from the truth, a basic business accounting class will teach anyone that.
- Verbal
- The Melancholy Wizards
- Posts: 25211
- Joined: 18 Apr 2009, 03:05
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
X.
X cant be, because of Y.
X.
X cant be, because of Y
X?
X cant be, because of Y
The letter before Y?
Can't be, because of Y.
X - 1 + 1.
Shut the fuck up
X cant be, because of Y.
X.
X cant be, because of Y
X?
X cant be, because of Y
The letter before Y?
Can't be, because of Y.
X - 1 + 1.
Shut the fuck up
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
Also I'm a big fan of charitable organizations, funded by you know expendable income and you know generally (If reputable) don't waste funds like our government does so you know I'd rather give to that than uncle sam. I'd rather have some control where expendable income goes than no control with the government. If someone wants to give money to the government, they're more than welcome to donate but I don't see most people calling for tax increases doing that I see them going out of their way to find more loopholes.
I'm done ranting now, I won't change your mind and you won't change my mind I think everyone is just starting to look like an ass now, actually we've been a little past that point
[quote name="desolation"]Jesus fucking christ, Liz.
[/quote]
I've felt that way towards several people on this board including myself at some points, honestly though this is just my opinion vs. this mass theory people like to pretend is fact. We'll see who is right and who is wrong eventually.
I'm done ranting now, I won't change your mind and you won't change my mind I think everyone is just starting to look like an ass now, actually we've been a little past that point
[quote name="desolation"]Jesus fucking christ, Liz.
I've felt that way towards several people on this board including myself at some points, honestly though this is just my opinion vs. this mass theory people like to pretend is fact. We'll see who is right and who is wrong eventually.
- Abzu
- Postwhore
- Posts: 45613
- Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
- Location: next door
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
This subject boils down to numbers. Mathematics are not a matter of opinion.
;,,;ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
-
Noyka
- Ancient One
- Posts: 4935
- Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
- Location: California
Re: The Bernie Sanders speech
[quote name="Noyka"]I think everyone is just starting to look like an ass now, actually we've been a little past that point 
[/quote]
[/quote]