Page 1 of 1
Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 12:14
by Meat Engine
Research has been underway in Japan on technologies to recover traces of uranium contained in seawater. One of the technologies uses a method involving submerging a material that adsorbs uranium in the sea, and chemically separating and refining the collected uranium after the adsorbent material is pulled out of seawater. The cost of recovering uranium through this method is estimated to be about three-fold higher than the current market price of uranium, research and development efforts for cost reduction are also in the works. Costs could be reduced by 40% or more. This would make it about 1.8 times higher than current uranium prices. Plus Japan could get some Vanadium at the same time. Rare earth that they need. Contribution of vanadium would lower uranium costs by $4 per pound.
<!-- m -->
http://nextbigfuture.com/2010/12/japan- ... ed-in.html<!-- m -->
This is pretty cool. To achieve meaningful carbon dioxide reduction in our lifetimes, coal power plants need to give way to nuclear power plants. There is no way around it. If all power plants ran on uranium, we would run out of conventional sources of it, and this seems to be a viable replacement, for both the uranium and the trace rare earths that make electronics manufacture possible.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 16:06
by Lavabug
I found this article a bit misleading. I don't understand why there's no comparison between the relative concentrations of u-238 (useless) and u-235 (useful) in sea water and the regular source for uranium (mines rich in pitchblende). In plain soil there's something like 20kg of uranium in every square acre, only .02% of which is useful for power generation. In sea water it is even less abundant:
Uranium's average concentration in the Earth's crust is (depending on the reference) 2 to 4 parts per million,[8][12] or about 40 times as abundant as silver.[9] The Earth's crust from the surface to 25 km (15 mi) down is calculated to contain 1017 kg (2 × 1017 lb) of uranium while the oceans may contain 1013 kg (2 × 1013 lb).[8] The concentration of uranium in soil ranges from 0.7 to 11 parts per million (up to 15 parts per million in farmland soil due to use of phosphate fertilizers), and its concentration in sea water is 3 parts per billion.[12]
<!-- m -->
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium<!-- m -->
Not only is the concentration greater in land by a factor of at least 10^3, but the total amount of uranium thought to exist on land is also greater than the total present in the oceans.
Imo this should be taken with approximately 58.4gr of salt.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 16:17
by shadowalk
Finally a chance for my tribe to produce our very own nuclear weapon.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 17:19
by Lavabug
Also I thought I'd add that my premise may be wrong if the proportion of U-235 to 238 in sea water is waaaay bigger than in soil/mines, but my intuition tells me the oceans aren't chock full of rare radioactive isotopes. The little I know about geology and chemical abundance tells me this is highly unlikely.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 17:23
by Meat Engine
I think the idea is that if we needed to fuel every power plant with uranium, conventional mining would soon come up short. Then there's also the issue of the inevitable uranium cartel.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 18:03
by Haunty
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]I think the idea is that if we needed to fuel every power plant with uranium, conventional mining would soon come up short. Then there's also the issue of the inevitable uranium cartel.[/quote]
Nuclear thugs.

Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 11 Dec 2010, 19:10
by Lavabug
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]I think the idea is that if we needed to fuel every power plant with uranium, conventional mining would soon come up short. Then there's also the issue of the inevitable uranium cartel.[/quote]
It would sooner come up short from sea exploitation, seeing how there's a smaller net amount of the element in seawater.
Even mined Uranium poses no real threat, btw. Refining U-235 (fissionable) out of Uranium ore to make bombs involves huge facilities with extremely powerful centrifuges, transportation (huge masses of ore = grams of U-235), and specialized technicians that can only be afforded by developed nations.
[youtube]69UpMhUnEeY[/youtube]
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 12 Dec 2010, 02:31
by Meat Engine
When the uranium cartels come, countries will still need to refine what they use. It is the safest way.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 12 Dec 2010, 13:50
by captain twat. IV.
Cut the rest of the trees down,they are fuckheads anyway.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 13 Dec 2010, 23:49
by Hugo.
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]I think the idea is that if we needed to fuel every power plant with uranium, conventional mining would soon come up short. Then there's also the issue of the inevitable uranium cartel.[/quote]
I know what you mean. If we are to become so dependant on uranium, then infrastructure for sea extraction will need to be established, no matter how low it's concentration.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 20 Dec 2010, 07:06
by Abzu
We really need to put our focus on a diversified array of renewable methods. Coal, uranium, and fossil fuels are finite and our energy consumption is quite sharply on the rise.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 20 Dec 2010, 09:40
by Meat Engine
Thorium
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 21 Dec 2010, 20:28
by Hugo.
Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 21 Dec 2010, 22:34
by Lavabug
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?[/quote]
Because a single one doesn't produce anywhere near as much power to meet even a regular household needs, to say nothing of a skyscraper's needs.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 00:27
by Abzu
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?[/quote]
Because a single one doesn't produce anywhere near as much power to meet even a regular household needs, to say nothing of a skyscraper's needs.[/quote]
http://www.scientificamerican.com/artic ... w-the-flow
Also, I know someone who runs his entire house on a single turbine. He's about average with consumption: TV, computer, refrigerator, other appliances, etc.
Even if a turbine can't run the whole skyscraper, it can offset the building's draw on the grid. If every skyscraper did this, there'd be a significant effect.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 00:41
by Hugo.
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?[/quote]
Because a single one doesn't produce anywhere near as much power to meet even a regular household needs, to say nothing of a skyscraper's needs.[/quote]
I never said anything about running the skyscraper outright.
a) It would go some length to offsetting the buildings electricity consumption.
b)Such an area is prime real estate for windfarms. You cant just build them anywhere.
Then you have intelligently designed (

) ventures like this is Bahrain.

Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 01:16
by Abzu
MechaVagina of Doom
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 01:48
by Hugo.
Hey thats my mum!
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 03:13
by Hugo.
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?[/quote]
Because a single one doesn't produce anywhere near as much power to meet even a regular household needs, to say nothing of a skyscraper's needs.[/quote]
Wait, what? I'm no expert, but most turbines used on windfarms here are powerful enough to power about 1000 households per year.
My only suggestion is that a turbine failing at that height in a built up area would be

Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 03:41
by Abzu
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?[/quote]
Because a single one doesn't produce anywhere near as much power to meet even a regular household needs, to say nothing of a skyscraper's needs.[/quote]
Wait, what? I'm no expert, but most turbines used on windfarms here are powerful enough to power about 1000 households per year.
My only suggestion is that a turbine failing at that height in a built up area would be

[/quote]
Ohhhh man that would be fucking nuts.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 06:27
by Meat Engine
A safer option for rooftops is things that will help reduce the heat transfer between the inside of the building and outside of the building, like rooftop green spaces. You can put gardens, greenhouses and whatnot there. You're not adding energy to the grid, but you are reducing the cooling load in the building by some small part. Every little bit helps, because there are no magic bullets.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 22 Dec 2010, 20:15
by Hugo.
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why arent there wind generators on every single skyscraper?[/quote]
Because a single one doesn't produce anywhere near as much power to meet even a regular household needs, to say nothing of a skyscraper's needs.[/quote]
Wait, what? I'm no expert, but most turbines used on windfarms here are powerful enough to power about 1000 households per year.
My only suggestion is that a turbine failing at that height in a built up area would be

[/quote]
Ohhhh man that would be fucking nuts.[/quote]
They are 55m+ in diametere.
I'm sure a windelectric venture of such would have a collosal factor of safety.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 23 Dec 2010, 04:32
by Meat Engine
I wonder if you could safely anchor a turbine of industrial size to the roof of a tall building. You would have to design the building ahead of time for that purpose, I think. One can still put a number of the small, residential sized turbines in place, but they won't work as well as one big one.
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 24 Dec 2010, 02:03
by Abzu
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Every little bit helps, because there are no magic bullets.[/quote]
/thread
Re: Extracting uranium and rare earths from seawater
Posted: 24 Dec 2010, 07:26
by Hugo.
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]I wonder if you could safely anchor a turbine of industrial size to the roof of a tall building. You would have to design the building ahead of time for that purpose, I think. One can still put a number of the small, residential sized turbines in place, but they won't work as well as one big one.[/quote]
The channels between buildings could be an option either.