Page 1 of 1
Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 08:45
by Meat Engine
Thank blondie for this one. <!-- l --><a class="postlink-local" href="
forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=5174&p=83627# ... #p83603</a><!-- l -->
We all participate in the shared delusion of commerce-based market economy, where money serves as a medium of exchange to purchase goods and services. It has no real value. Even before Nixon took us off the Bretton-Woods system, it still had no real value. I never did get why gold and other precious metals are considered fungible. Rarity as a determinant for value is moronic, and precious metals have lots of practical value in electrochemistry. It really is a shame that platinum costs $2000 an ounce, because it makes an excellent reduction catalyst as well as a fantastic electrode material. Alright, tangent over.
My questions are thus; does it blow your mind that money is really that meaningless? What should we even do? I mean, it's better than Pfizer trying to pay my employer in Viagra, and then my employer paying me in Viagra, and then me trying to get some food with some Viagra. Is there really no alternative? Should we just put our hands over our ears and scream until these bad thoughts depart?
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 09:36
by scarica
you should play some video poker or something to take your mind off such things.
<!-- w -->
www.pogo.com<!-- w -->
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 13:40
by captain twat. IV.
No and skintoxication is right.Just see it as a means to get shit..unless of coarse you have a better option?
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 14:32
by Grudge
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Thank blondie for this one. <!-- l --><a class="postlink-local" href="
forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=5174&p=83627# ... #p83603</a><!-- l -->
We all participate in the shared delusion of commerce-based market economy, where money serves as a medium of exchange to purchase goods and services. It has no real value. Even before Nixon took us off the Bretton-Woods system, it still had no real value. I never did get why gold and other precious metals are considered fungible. Rarity as a determinant for value is moronic, and precious metals have lots of practical value in electrochemistry. It really is a shame that platinum costs $2000 an ounce, because it makes an excellent reduction catalyst as well as a fantastic electrode material. Alright, tangent over.
My questions are thus; does it blow your mind that money is really that meaningless? What should we even do? I mean, it's better than Pfizer trying to pay my employer in Viagra, and then my employer paying me in Viagra, and then me trying to get some food with some Viagra. Is there really no alternative? Should we just put our hands over our ears and scream until these bad thoughts depart?[/quote]
There are inferior alternatives.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 16:59
by Hugo.
Why is rarity a moronic determining factor for value?
Rarity= more labour to extract a certain amount =more time spent = more $$$$
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 17:54
by baron von blondle
My point of view is that money facilitates survival and prosperity of the weak and pointless.
I estimate 90% of the world population (especially here in the UK) do pointless jobs for the sole reason of raising more money for a big boss who then spends it on pointless things or hoards it.
it has turned the world literally upside down. a nurse/doctor (essential important skill) is paid less than a hospital manager (pointless revenue generator)
a cleaner/garbage man (essential important role) is paid less than a politician (pointless self satisfying position)
a farmer gets paid next to nothing for his goods whereas a supermarket slaps on it's extra's and makes millions of profit...
and of course close to my heart - a creative musician gets paid very little for his work where a label/publishing company makes the lions share..I could go on....
people have no idea how to grow food, prepare food, hunt for food because all they need are paper/digital tokens to exchange for poorly prepared low grade foods that in turn make them fat and weak.
and the ultimate upsetter....
you are now rated in society and limited or promoted according to your credit rating as defined by the most pointless positions of all - the bankers.
I know this is all rather sketchy and of course an extreme viewpoint BUT it bears thinking about for your sake and your childrens sake. As my old Ma' used to say it's best to have a plan B.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 18:03
by bills bro
[youtube]rQjh9H-ymK4[/youtube]
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 18:06
by Hugo.
Great tune.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 18:55
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why is rarity a moronic determining factor for value?
Rarity= more labour to extract a certain amount =more time spent = more $$$$[/quote]
It saddens me that things so useful as gold or platinum are hoarded instead of used, because of perceived extrinsic value. You don't see lithium being hoarded. You don't see tungsten being hoarded. Why hoard these?
We need money to facilitate commerce. Let's go to the extreme, though. It's a construct for determining the value of things relative to other things, so let's not pretend that gold = money. Robert A. Heinlein touches on this briefly in A Door Into Summer.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 19:45
by Hugo.
Maybe the illuminati are closet alchemists, i dunno.

Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 19:45
by Grudge
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]Why is rarity a moronic determining factor for value?
Rarity= more labour to extract a certain amount =more time spent = more $$$$[/quote]

Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 19:54
by Meat Engine
The value of something is not the sum total of the labor required to fabricate or extract it. You could spend thousands of man hours to shovel shit from a latrine, but it would still be worthless and shit.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 19:55
by Hugo.
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]The value of something is not the sum total of the labor required to fabricate or extract it. You could spend thousands of man hours to shovel shit from a latrine, but it would still be worthless and shit.[/quote]
Yes, but the resultant cleanliness is worth something!
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 20:25
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Zajebiste!"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]The value of something is not the sum total of the labor required to fabricate or extract it. You could spend thousands of man hours to shovel shit from a latrine, but it would still be worthless and shit.[/quote]
Yes, but the resultant cleanliness is worth something![/quote]
My perspective was the shit acquisition perspective, so perhaps the example wasn't too clear. You see what I mean, I hope. Spend a day making the finest shit pie imaginable, and it's still a shit pie.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 20:46
by Hugo.
Well there are different types of value. Use value, labour value, cultural value and personal and sentimental value. Certain goods are worth more depending on who is consuming them. That shit pie might be worth nothing to you, but you might get a fiver for it from someone looking to fertilize their garden.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 21:35
by Lavabug
Money in itself has no value to me, but the problems that money can solve for me are very real, like eating or getting an education(to ensure I'll actually make enough to live and feed myself on my own someday).
No one gives out food for free, and not everyone works, can work, or is willing to work at a farm, hence not everyone can get paid with food.
And for a iron worker, engineer or a craftsman to head out to a farm to give/do something in exchange every time he needs food is impractical. What better option do we have other than exchanging little slips of paper and coins that are valid practically everywhere?
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 22:11
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Money by and of itself isn't worthless, it's simply an extension of bartering.
It's the fact that (A) our monetary system is based entirely on voodoo (the unlimited printing of money, artificial economic incentives driven by state-sponsored violence, etc.) and (B) you're not legally allowed to step outside of said monetary system. If alternate currencies were legal, we could have some hope of jumping ship before it completely sinks. But I guess that's the point.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 22:26
by Meat Engine
I would like to acknowledge the whole voodoo thing and run with it. Let's not pretend that one day gold and platinum might back up currency, and just say to all it's a construct so you don't have to barter. Let precious metals trade free of the fetters of extrinsic value.
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]Money by and of itself isn't worthless, it's simply an extension of bartering.
It's the fact that (A) our monetary system is based entirely on voodoo (the unlimited printing of money, artificial economic incentives driven by state-sponsored violence, etc.) and (B) you're not legally allowed to step outside of said monetary system. If alternate currencies were legal, we could have some hope of jumping ship before it completely sinks. But I guess that's the point.[/quote]
Some cities have actually experimented with alternate currency that can only be spent in the city. It was meant to incentivize patronage of city businesses. They'd let you buy like 1.2 city dollars for 1 American dollar. I think it happened in NY somewhere. Ithaca?
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 22:37
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Yeah, but that shit is more of a tourist trap, it seems worthless when it can't spread to other areas.
Someone attempted to start the "Liberty Dollar" - a completely gold/silver backed currency - they got shut down by the feds, raided, and last I heard, never had any of their money returned.
Re: Money
Posted: 04 May 2010, 22:51
by Meat Engine
Attempting to implement hard currency is as moronic as that seizure was illegal. I simply don't understand the need to affix gold, silver and other rare items with extrinsic value. Yes, it's been that way for over six thousand years. My counter is, so what?
Re: Money
Posted: 05 May 2010, 03:18
by scarica
we reject the metric system. it's the american way.
Re: Money
Posted: 05 May 2010, 04:19
by Lavabug
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Attempting to implement hard currency is as moronic as that seizure was illegal. I simply don't understand the need to affix gold, silver and other rare items with extrinsic value. Yes, it's been that way for over six thousand years. My counter is, so what?[/quote]
I don't see how its hard to accept that "rarity comes with a price". There are rare earths used in chemistry that are several times more expensive than platinum or gold, but aren't used for jewelry or for backing up currencies, simply because they're even scarcer than the aforementioned.
I believe the purpose of using said metals to back up currencies is because one can easily determine if the gold or platinum one is being handed is authentic with a few tests.
Re: Money
Posted: 05 May 2010, 05:39
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Attempting to implement hard currency is as moronic as that seizure was illegal. I simply don't understand the need to affix gold, silver and other rare items with extrinsic value. Yes, it's been that way for over six thousand years. My counter is, so what?[/quote]
I don't see how its hard to accept that "rarity comes with a price". There are rare earths used in chemistry that are several times more expensive than platinum or gold, but aren't used for jewelry or for backing up currencies, simply because they're even scarcer than the aforementioned.
I believe the purpose of using said metals to back up currencies is because one can easily determine if the gold or platinum one is being handed is authentic with a few tests.[/quote]
I was saying that rarity shouldn't be the sole determinant. Utility must be considered. Gold was useful for the reason you mentioned, and its other properties, like its ability to be struck into coinage or cast into bars. Now though, not so much. Abandon the charade. I dislike the system because it encourages hoarding. Platinum would still be expensive, but would it be $2000 an ounce? I dunno.
Re: Money
Posted: 05 May 2010, 12:01
by Lavabug
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Attempting to implement hard currency is as moronic as that seizure was illegal. I simply don't understand the need to affix gold, silver and other rare items with extrinsic value. Yes, it's been that way for over six thousand years. My counter is, so what?[/quote]
I don't see how its hard to accept that "rarity comes with a price". There are rare earths used in chemistry that are several times more expensive than platinum or gold, but aren't used for jewelry or for backing up currencies, simply because they're even scarcer than the aforementioned.
I believe the purpose of using said metals to back up currencies is because one can easily determine if the gold or platinum one is being handed is authentic with a few tests.[/quote]
I was saying that rarity shouldn't be the sole determinant. Utility must be considered. Gold was useful for the reason you mentioned, and its other properties, like its ability to be struck into coinage or cast into bars. Now though, not so much. Abandon the charade. I dislike the system because it encourages hoarding. Platinum would still be expensive, but would it be $2000 an ounce? I dunno.[/quote]
Steel and copper are immensely useful, more so than gold, but their price/weight ratio is way lower than gold's. Imagine how many thousands tons of steel or copper would need to be transported around just to make a modest trade or sale, when you can exchange the same amount of money with only a fraction of that weight if you're dealing with gold or platinum.