Page 1 of 1
So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 05:22
by Meat Engine
Okay, for those not in the know, Arizona passed a law requiring law enforcement to stop any person suspected of being an undocumented immigrant for the purposes of verification. The law doesn't outline how these people are supposed to look , or what is considered a reasonable suspicion. It basically turns Arizona into a Constitution-free zone (as if there weren't enough of those already), and attempts to turn vice squad departments into the Gestapo or some such. Where do you guys stand on the whole issue? It's very complex.
I'm of the opinion that "illegal immigration" is a symptom of a larger problem, specifically, free trade agreements with countries that do not have comparable standards of living and worker protections. Mexico has its own immigration problems with countries like Honduras and Guatemala. Those people move north to work the few agriculture jobs left, or to work in factories that have been moved south since NAFTA. Mexicans no longer have their agriculture jobs and compete with immigrants for factory jobs, so they come north. We don't have factory jobs like we did in the 60's, but we've got lots of food processing jobs that many people won't consider. Agribusiness from the U.S. is killing jobs south of the border, and cheap labor is luring manufacturing jobs from our side.
What do we do? To address the symptom, I say fix the whole guest worker program. If a person wants to work here, make it easy. Remove one of the more basic causes by giving incentive to going through the system. Process expediently, afford them the same rights and protections that a citizen worker would have, and get them paying into the system. Why risk exploitation and deportation when you can do it legally and pay into a system you might one day use? Conservatives tend to have it all wrong in this regard. People are going to come here, legally and illegally. The goal should be to emphasize legal behavior.
To address the root cause, you have to repeal NAFTA and similar treaties. Negotiate new ones to be pull-up propositions. NAFTA pulled us toward's Mexico's level, when the opposite should have happened. We're going to pay, one way or the other. Better to pay more for what we consume than to have the fruits of our labor taxed.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 05:43
by jawn galliano
if i'm not mistaken, hasn't AZ had some pretty questionable roadblock scheme going on for some time now? something like, they can effectively stop anyone for any reason so long as it's within 200 miles of the US/Mexico border? i definitely remember reading about some setup in that general description within the last couple years. it sounds like they're essentially removing the border proximity restriction.
my gut feeling is this is a massive power-grab for law enforcement, and i fully expect it to be abused regularly when the bar for potentially detaining someone is as low and ill-defined as 'reasonable suspicion'.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 05:50
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
solution: beat joe arpaio to death with a shovel
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 05:53
by jawn galliano
i can't understand why it hasn't happened already. he seems like the kind of dude who's got a lot of enemies with violent tendencies and little hesitation when it comes to indulging them.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 05:56
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Well, he has a "posse" of fellow shit-eating pigs who follow him everywhere. I'd be scared to death to say one bad word about them if I lived in Maricopa.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 06:07
by Meat Engine
He and the DA are in bed together. If a county commissioner or city councilman wants to make a stink, the DA will indict for some BS and Sheriff Joe will find some evidence. They're thugs.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 06:31
by Loki
I sard looking for the article, but isn't this the same area that just passed a law allowing people to carry concealed firearms with no permits or training, so long as they bought the gun in Arizona?
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 07:10
by Meat Engine
There are states that allow open carry with no restrictions or requirements.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 07:19
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
I don't see how you can lump those two things together.
border control = fascism
people freely arming themselves = every fascist's worst nightmare
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 07:23
by Meat Engine
Second Amendment detractors should really consider the context of the fighting at Lexington and Concord, then consider again the Second Amendment. The Chinaman is not the issue. Let's get back to immigration. When you get down to it, our birthplaces are accidents. I believe, in principle at least, that people should be free to travel and work where they please. Extracting services from a country is a touchier issue, but simply living and working should not be.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 09:44
by Teresa
This greatly displeases me. I'ma bust a cap etc.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 09:45
by Teresa
Shit, that sounded sarcastic. IT WASN'T.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 21:33
by Teresa
The more I think about it, the angrier I get. White people don't even belong here. They don't belong anywhere on the continent tbh but now they fuckin' ~own the place while the real owners are left with shit, getting kicked out etc. fuck this, suck my dick. I'm mad as hell, I wanna fight.
ok, i'm done.

Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 21:39
by Mesarthim
I agree with Fu on this one, but you'll never convince republicans to go down that road even though it does make much more sense.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 22:27
by Meat Engine
Conservatives get hard when they hear phrases like "border security". Having a permissive guest worker program does not mean having lax border security. The solution is so far from what the norms and proposed norms have been that it's likely to be ridiculed, but I don't care. What we're doing does not work. Fences don't work. Militarization won't work. Let's go in the other direction on this one.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 00:49
by Grudge
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]I don't see how you can lump those two things together.
border control = fascism
people freely arming themselves = every fascist's worst nightmare[/quote]
It is also the nightmare of capitalists.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 02:10
by Abzu
I agree with Fu.
The big problem is tax-funded services. It's not so much a problem under a single, global government model (theoretically), but that's not a reality. As it is, if you have people traveling and working across national borders, you have to figure out a sustainable, functional means of ensuring tax collection and service providing have an equilibrium.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 02:36
by Meat Engine
[quote name="desolation"]I agree with Fu.
The big problem is tax-funded services. It's not so much a problem under a single, global government model (theoretically), but that's not a reality. As it is, if you have people traveling and working across national borders, you have to figure out a sustainable, functional means of ensuring tax collection and service providing have an equilibrium.[/quote]
This. You wouldn't want something like medical tourism on the public dime. As it stands, though, I don't think the basic framework is a problem. Employers collect payroll taxes every period. With a simplified tax code, it should be simple for anyone to fill out a tax return. Everything gets tied back to an ID number; immigration status, outstanding taxes, what have you. If a migrant worker one day wants to become a citizen, there is a record of how much he or she has paid into the system for programs like Social Security that are tied to those numbers.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 06:48
by Abzu
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]
[quote name="desolation"]I agree with Fu.
The big problem is tax-funded services. It's not so much a problem under a single, global government model (theoretically), but that's not a reality. As it is, if you have people traveling and working across national borders, you have to figure out a sustainable, functional means of ensuring tax collection and service providing have an equilibrium.[/quote]
This. You wouldn't want something like medical tourism on the public dime. As it stands, though, I don't think the basic framework is a problem. Employers collect payroll taxes every period. With a simplified tax code, it should be simple for anyone to fill out a tax return. Everything gets tied back to an ID number; immigration status, outstanding taxes, what have you. If a migrant worker one day wants to become a citizen, there is a record of how much he or she has paid into the system for programs like Social Security that are tied to those numbers.[/quote]
Word. The only thing bucking that balance now is the illegal workforce. Under the table wages to illegals often send a portion across the border and definitely pay no taxes, but still want legal and medical services when necessary.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 07:32
by Teresa
die
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 00:22
by Abzu
I was thinking about this topic last night and began exploring the notion of national security. I would imagine an undocumented and open border would increase the ease with which terrorists could enter. Closing the borders obviously doesn't solve the problem (there's always a way) but fully opening could worsen. Thoughts?
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 01:56
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
If the government is concerned about terrorism, they should really consider not participating in it
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 02:00
by Meat Engine
I'm not suggesting that people be allowed in without impedance, only that we simplify the process. One would still need the documentation necessary for cross-border travel. I'd just like to make it easier and safer for people to seek gainful employment in another country. Current thresholds push people to enter the country illegally, causing some politicians to call for a crack down. Certain employers will also exploit these workers by threatening to call ICE in retribution for any reporting of abusive labor practices.
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]If the government is concerned about terrorism, they should really consider not participating in it[/quote]
Didn't you hear? The CIA is starting to use smaller missile payloads in balochistan. We're practically peaceniks now.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 02:11
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
And I've heard they're now raping less than 60% of female recruits. Some serious progress has been made.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 07:51
by Meat Engine
I blame Eisenhower. Once the CIA felt the weight of its own brass balls, there was no turning back. Think how much the world might be different had they not replaced Mohammed Mossadegh with the Shah.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 08:21
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
what's funny is that eisenhower is the one who warned us about the dangers of militarized culture. what a dick
But I guess that's keeping in the tradition of presidents who give grand speeches praising the very things they set out to pervert and destroy.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 08:24
by Abzu
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]If the government is concerned about terrorism, they should really consider not participating in it[/quote]
Even if we ceased all activities one could consider to be of a terrorist nature, religious extremists would still be a threat. It's still a valid concern (from within and without, but this topic is on borders).
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 23:15
by Ninny
And then there“s the drug smuggling, crime, disease... you need a bigger fence to keep the mexicans out
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 01:16
by Teresa
tbqh
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 05:35
by zim
white power!
MY EYES HAVE SEEN THE GLORY..
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 09:40
by jawn galliano
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 11:23
by Teresa
I don't see a seagull.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 12:48
by TamPron
[quote name="Teresa"]I don't see a seagull.[/quote]
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 16:36
by Haunty
I'm not gonna point fingers, but someone in here hit the nail on the head.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 01 May 2010, 23:51
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 02 May 2010, 01:48
by Abzu
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]

[/quote]
[insert random crimethinc quotation here]
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 02 May 2010, 01:49
by scarica
I'll admit that I know jack shit of Arizona law or judicial system, but as a l.e.o. I know that laws don't have to specify the probable cause needed for a given scenario. Usually its brought up In court by attorneys and judges. I have yet to see where s persons rights being violated is not considered. Cases are lost over such things. You guys have no clue what fiery hoops law enforcement has to jump through regularly over simpler cases such ad b&e or dui. Just sayin.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 02 May 2010, 03:41
by scarica
A citizen report of an intoxicated driver would be enough to stop the vehicle, thus leading to a successful dui conviction, but there are many elements that must be presented in court. Chances are, there was a fuckup in your friends case that he was unaware of. Could have been something as simple as s procedural error.
Re: So, this whole Arizona thing...
Posted: 02 May 2010, 05:18
by scarica
I couldn't agree more, but the biggest fuckup is the one that got him off the hook.