Page 1 of 1
Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 13:16
by Lavabug
Need a portable usb hard disk in the 2.5" format, around 500gb capacity, eSata would be great too. Can anyone share their experiences with any specific brands that make external hard disks? I'm thinking of samsung or WD drives.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 16:40
by Abzu
I usually assemble my own from internal HDDs and enclosures.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 17:12
by Lavabug
[quote name="desolation"]I usually assemble my own from internal HDDs and enclosures.[/quote]
I thought of this but I've had shit experiences with enclosures, their build quality generally sucks, my 3.5" enclosure stopped working after a year(disk still works fine) and a 2.5" I have is starting to act up, sometimes my pc doesn't recognize it(granted the disk itself is starting to die, but the usb jack was installed at an improper angle, might start wearing with use).
Do you know of a quality/branded 2.5" enclosure that can be found on the internets? If not I might go with a samsung I think.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 18:57
by bills bro
yea, my experiences with enclosures have all been shit.
i have a seagate, it's working well after 4 years. i bought it because of limited space on my laptop, so it just sits on my desk.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 19:00
by Lavabug
[quote name="sade"]yea, my experiences with enclosures have all been shit.
i have a seagate, it's working well after 4 years. i bought it because of limited space on my laptop, so it just sits on my desk.[/quote]
Seagate makes external ones? I'll look into those, nothing but good experiences with seagate disks for me.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 20:01
by jawn galliano
seagate does make externals, i've never used their 2.5" but for what its worth, i had a really bad experience with one of their 3.5" external drives. i bought one in late january to replace my aging 500GB external, and the new drive failed on me after less than 24 hours, after i'd already transferred almost all my data over to it. i wound up swapping it for another WD, which have generally been pretty good in my experience.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 16 Mar 2010, 20:15
by Mesarthim
seagate is your best bet.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 17 Mar 2010, 04:46
by Abzu
My Eagle Consus SATA-USB enclosure has run reliably well (and cool) for 3 years of rigorous use now. I don't know what their 2.5" selection is, but my 3.5" enclosure and WD Caviar have served me well. I've always had better luck with WD Caviar than any other hdd line.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 18 Mar 2010, 22:34
by Lavabug
Hm, I had the WD in mind for a while but I have had 2 bad experiences with internal WD drives, so that kinda puts me off. I'm moving in the fall of this year and need all my stuff on a disk that isn't gonna fail in a year or two
I was going to go with the Seagate because of the long warranty but I found a really good deal on a Samsung S2 500gb:
The only drawback is that its a usb-native hard disk, meaning it can only be used with Samsung's enclosure, not possible to swap enclosures if it ever fails. Also found a LaCie rikiki 500gb for the same price but I've heard horror stories about LaCie.
Should I hold off for a Seagate freeagent? Any personal or 2nd hand accounts would be helpful.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 19 Mar 2010, 06:53
by Abzu
The only bad experience I've had with a WD was an old 250GB MyBook external drive. Fucker overheated.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 03:50
by Charles Bronson
WD my books are ok, but they slow your computer down.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 04:16
by jawn galliano
not really, the USB only drives are slow as fuck though. i seriously regret not shelling out for a firewire drive when i replaced my old one, i'm probably gonna replace it as soon as i can with another FW drive and just use the 1.5TB USB for additional storage on my ps3 where the speed won't matter so much
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 05:23
by Abzu
firewire is going to fall by the wayside.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 05:44
by Meat Engine
Yep. Intel is already working on a fiber optic interface to replace USB, if I'm not mistaken.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 06:28
by jawn galliano
oh, okay, i'll just buy one of those nonexistent drives, which will pair up very nicely with my nonexistent fiberoptic peripheral interface
that would work a lot better than just getting one that works with an interface i already have and can currently make use of
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 06:37
by Meat Engine
We were just pointing out that firewire never took hold like USB and USB 2.0, and will not have a chance, either.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 06:47
by jawn galliano
yeah i know but there was an opportunity to be a smartass, i can't pass that up
anyway, my point, if i have one, is that firewire's history and future are fairly irrelevant to me, because i currently own a machine that supports it and don't have any real urgent need to replace it in the coming years. if my next machine doesn't, i guess i can just use the USB or esata interfaces instead.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 06:55
by Abzu
[quote name="hard-on bearer Incognito"]yeah i know but there was an opportunity to be a smartass, i can't pass that up
anyway, my point, if i have one, is that firewire's history and future are fairly irrelevant to me, because i currently own a machine that supports it and don't have any real urgent need to replace it in the coming years. if my next machine doesn't, i guess i can just use the USB or esata interfaces instead.[/quote]
...and that trite bit is irrelevant to our discussion of peripheral connection standards.
Re: Good external hard disk?
Posted: 22 Mar 2010, 12:50
by Lavabug
USB 3.0 is pretty much gonna replace FW and eSata.
And to stay on topic: I went with the Seagate and won an ebay auction, but the seller politely refused to ship to my location because it was absurdly expensive so I'll have to cancel the payment. When I get my bling back I'll keep my eyes peeled on ebay for another one.