Page 1 of 2
Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 07:54
by Abzu
http://idle.slashdot.org/firehose.pl?op ... /26/161200
Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted by samzenpus on Friday February 26, @11:52AM
from the making-mom-proud dept.
27-year-old Angie Jackson has decided that it isn't inappropriate or in any way distasteful to live-tweet about her experience taking RU-486, also known as the abortion pill. According to Jackson nothing is off-limits on Twitter. "I don't feel like I'm doing anything different from what I do every day," said Jackson. "But now I have people calling me a killer; it's surreal."
[youtube]59Ud3g2ymOM[/youtube]
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:00
by Verbal
She didn't take any pill there though . . ?
And for fuck's sake. You ARE killing a little baby. The debate is whether killing it when it is very small should be allowed.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:45
by Abzu
There are other videos from it on her YouTube account.
I am pro-abortion.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:47
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
I'd hit it, and then tweet about it
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:51
by Verbal
At any time?
Would you have no problem with a last minute abortion? And if so, would you also not have a problem if the parents decide after they see they baby, "meh", and want it aborted then?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:59
by Meat Engine
This whole issue is a complex one. I imagine that, for the most part, considering abortion is not without some difficulty. The whole trimester thing seems a bit arbitrary. Do you draw the line just before the point at which the child can be delivered, even premature? What about late term emergencies? I have no problem saying that I am too ignorant to form a defensible opinion on this matter, except to say that they should not be totally illegal.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 09:04
by Verbal
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 09:16
by Meat Engine
That's pretty much a microcosm of most arguments on the subject. A cluster of cells is alive, but it's not yet an individual. Where is the transition? My questions are mainly concerned with the when. Your proposition concerning the development of a nervous system is not without merit. Medical necessity must also be considered.
I have no problem with the other component, if they should even be allowed. It's not an act to be taken lightly, and it is not without personal consequences. I say there's no good argument for banning the practice, or restricting the use to certain conditions like rape or whatever. An unwanted pregnancy may be a teaching tool to an otherwise irresponsible couple, but baby should not be born firstly as a teaching tool. It's too punitive.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 09:34
by Syysysyd
it's not an individual until it comes out of the womb

Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 09:35
by Verbal
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 10:16
by Verbal
Seeing as this other issue is related, I thought I'd revive it also: <!-- l --><a class="postlink-local" href="
http://www.mabb.us/forum/viewtopic.php? ... etarian</a><!-- l -->
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 10:32
by jawn galliano
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]A cluster of cells is alive, but it's not yet an individual. Where is the transition? My questions are mainly concerned with the when.[/quote]
your best bet is to simply read through the various perspectives on the question and pick whichever one jives best with you. development is a gradual process beginning even before fertilization when you get right down to it, and our various milestones and classifications are just in place to make the information of what is happening easier to digest (fertilization, for example, isn't a single moment but essentially a shorthand term summarizing a complex chain of events occurring over the course of like a full day).
there is no definitive answer to the question, and the whole thing is ultimately just a proxy argument for 'where do we draw the arbitrary line of demarcation'.
it's my impression that pro-lifers tend to say 'conception' as the moment of life's beginning, 'cuz that's when you get a soul. if you've looked into the question and process and examined it on a level of detail beyond that argument, you're doing pretty well, i think.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 10:49
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Verbal"]Seeing as this other issue is related, I thought I'd revive it also: <!-- l --><a class="postlink-local" href="
http://www.mabb.us/forum/viewtopic.php? ... etarian</a><!-- l -->[/quote]
Rather than bump that topic, I can be brief. I like meat. I eat meat. Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled. That said, I acknowledge that factory farming carries with it serious ethical issues concerning the conditions of the animals, and potentially devastating health issues pertaining to the widespread use of antibiotics and growth hormones. A new parallel to The Jungle by Upton Sinclair, concerning the conditions of the animals instead of the conditions of the processing, might be useful. Or not. How many people still read to be educated?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 10:55
by Noyka
[quote name="Antonius Block"]it's not an individual until it comes out of the womb

[/quote]
It has potential to be an individual. You have no right to say it can't without reason.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 10:59
by Verbal
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled.[/quote]
What?
And that doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not we should eat meat now.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 11:14
by Verbal
If you think it's okay if the child will end up retarded, then do you think it's also okay to kill babies with Down's syndrome?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 11:16
by jawn galliano
it's not an individual until it comes out of the womb

It has potential to be an individual. You have no right to say it can't without reason.
i've seen this same 'potential' line of reasoning used to argue that IUD's and really all forms of contraception are immoral. do you agree or disagree?
i mean, if we're going to take the potential thing to its conclusion, isn't failing to get pregnant after every ovulation also immoral? after all, that egg had potential to become an individual. and let's not even get started on ejaculations that don't wind up fertilizing anything, holy shit!
women who have had multiple abortions simply because they are too dumb to use birth control shall be denied this option, and instead have their ovaries removed. we dont need more stupid spilling out of your uterus. (though the reverse should also be applied to dudes who go around getting random women preggo)
most of america already tried this in the 1930s-1970s as a form of institutional policy, and it didn't work out so well. forced sterilization just isn't a workable idea within the framework and ideology of this country.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 11:26
by Verbal
[quote name="Skintoxication"]if one were to find out early enough during pregnancy, i dont see why not. again, it should be a personal choice, government has no place here.[/quote]
I meant after they are born.
If you think it's okay for abortions for retarded fetuses, then why is it suddenly not okay once they're born?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 11:26
by Verbal
Another issue is people with advanced dementia. The "person" is dead, but yet they take up huge amounts of resources and cause distress to those around them.
Kill 'Em All!
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 11:36
by Verbal
I think everyone here is onboard with "Science" and all that. That medical treatments need to be tested properly. Tests on the paediatric popultion, and the baby subsection in particular, seem to sometimes set off people's ethical radar. Not sure why. Something about consent. Anyway, I was thinking that maybe people could breed anencephalic babies (the ones without any brain, apart from maybe a brainstem). Or some equivalent. I'm no expert, but I think such a thing is possible, if done using in vitro fertilisation and all that. The Scientists can then have free roam to do whatever the hell they want. Such babies can sometimes live for quite a while, so it probably wouldn't be just the neonate population that would benefit. It would surely help research into many aspects of human biology.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 12:25
by captain twat. IV.
It's none of my buisness so I couldn't give a fuck.

Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 17:43
by Abzu
[quote name="Verbal"]At any time?
Would you have no problem with a last minute abortion? And if so, would you also not have a problem if the parents decide after they see they baby, "meh", and want it aborted then?[/quote]
No, I am for abortion is the currently legal (US) range. Don't be stupid.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 18:57
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled.[/quote]
What?
And that doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not we should eat meat now.[/quote]
There is a thesis that the nutrition provided by meat allowed the brain to grow to the point of more complex reasoning. Should we eat meat? As long as we continue to rely on animal byproducts, I see no reason for half measures.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 20:27
by Hugo.
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled.[/quote]
What?
And that doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not we should eat meat now.[/quote]
Dont be a stupid cunt. We should continue to devour the flesh of animals and savour it's tender juiciness. MMmmmm... evolution..
You have at least three too many opinions, johnny.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 20:47
by Verbal
[quote name="Skintoxication"]
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="Skintoxication"]if one were to find out early enough during pregnancy, i dont see why not. again, it should be a personal choice, government has no place here.[/quote]
I meant after they are born.
If you think it's okay for abortions for retarded fetuses, then why is it suddenly not okay once they're born?[/quote]
two completely different scenarios. overruled.[/quote]
They're not though. A baby just before it's born, and one just after?
And if you think it's okay to have abortions during the third trimester, then to be consistent you must also surely be in favour of aborting babies who are actually born premature. Somewhere between when they're born and when they "should" have been born.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 20:50
by Verbal
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Verbal"]At any time?
Would you have no problem with a last minute abortion? And if so, would you also not have a problem if the parents decide after they see they baby, "meh", and want it aborted then?[/quote]
No, I am for abortion is the currently legal (US) range. Don't be stupid.[/quote]
How was that stupid? You said you're in favour of abortion. It's not obvious if you only mean before a certain time. I even had a question mark for fuck's sake! What is the currently legal US range? And do you have any particular reason to be in favour of it?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 20:59
by Hugo.
Abortion and lower crime rates go hand in hand, dont they?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 21:03
by Verbal
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled.[/quote]
What?
And that doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not we should eat meat now.[/quote]
There is a thesis that the nutrition provided by meat allowed the brain to grow to the point of more complex reasoning. Should we eat meat? As long as we continue to rely on animal byproducts, I see no reason for half measures.[/quote]
But can we not get everything we need from "fake" meat. And supplements? Etc. As far as I know, there is no nutritional necessity to eat meat. All the nutrition in meat can be gotten by other means, can it not? Saying that our eating meat was a key part of our getting to this point as a species seems irrelevant. Even if it were to somehow be shown that our ancestors "decision" to start eating meat made our evolutionary path "better".
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 23:43
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled.[/quote]
What?
And that doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not we should eat meat now.[/quote]
There is a thesis that the nutrition provided by meat allowed the brain to grow to the point of more complex reasoning. Should we eat meat? As long as we continue to rely on animal byproducts, I see no reason for half measures.[/quote]
But can we not get everything we need from "fake" meat. And supplements? Etc. As far as I know, there is no nutritional necessity to eat meat. All the nutrition in meat can be gotten by other means, can it not? Saying that our eating meat was a key part of our getting to this point as a species seems irrelevant. Even if it were to somehow be shown that our ancestors "decision" to start eating meat made our evolutionary path "better".[/quote]
Should we continue to use animal products and byproducts, but deny the use of meat? As I said, I see no use in half measures. Were meat to be banned for human consumption, animals would still be held captive. They would be raised for products, and die in captivity. Certain wild animal populations would still need to be culled.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 00:39
by Verbal
There's a difference between eating something and taking its milk or wool. And all I was doing was questioning your point that "Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled." as part of an argument in favour of eating meat. It just doesn't make sense as far as I can see.
I sarded writing a long post so I just copied two from the above-linked thread.
It's pretty awful how most of the animals we eat are treated. I think it's pretty ignorant to assume they don't suffer greatly. Seeing as we are intelligent enough to have moral/ethical ideas regarding human life/suffering. . why should the other animals not be included? We are nice to retarded humans. Nobody breeds them, keeps them locked up in cages, and then painfully slaughters them either for our amusement, or for food.
Granted the other animals are not as intelligent as humans (in most cases), but they definitely feel pain and suffering.
If it's okay to treat other animals the way we do (especially the more intelligent ones), then why should we be so nice to retarded humans? I think there is a big inconsistency there.
Vegetables have no nervous system. Nobody thinks they're any more able to suffer than water is. There's obviously a spectrum from primitive animals through to the more intelligent ones. I'm not sure how the potentially hard lives of people harvesting vegetables is a justiication for the way most animals are treated. Although that's probably not what you mean. You maybe mean, "Why make such a fuss about other animals while there are humans suffering?" I'm not saying pigs should have equal rights to humans. I'm saying I think the present generally accepted standard people have for how other animals should be treated, and the present generally accepted standard people have for how humans should be treated is not at all representative of the differences between us. Given that they are, in effect, our retarded cousins.
Pardon any obvious errors I'm making, but I suppose any moral or ethical "code" or something should not only consider humans.
Surely it makes more sense to decide based on a number of things, like the animal's ability to suffer, feel pain, fear, etc .. rather than an all or nothing "Is it human or not?" approach.
I'm not necessarily against eating meat. I just can't see how the miserable painful lives that we inflict on a lot of them and are presently tolerated by people is justifiable. Surely anyone would agree with that at least? If they were farmed and slaughtered in a more humane way, maybe that'd be okay. I don't know.
I'm against hunting. I can't see how anyone wouldn't be. Would people be ok with sending a bunch of people with Down Syndrome into the woods and then hunting them down, and all that goes with it? Would the fact it's fun to do be a reasonable justification for it?
I realise you can go overboard. People can ask how anyone can justify buying anything for themselves that's not completely necessary for survival. How can you justify buying that cup of absu's beverage when there are people dying of starvation. Etc. I don't expect anyone to be like that. I think it's up to the individual to decide what they want to do.
I guess, in summary, I think if people have a problem with any form of human suffering, to be consistent, they shouldn't dismiss the suffering of other animals just because they're not human. It's not just being human that makes something worth caring about.
Apologies for repitition.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 01:39
by djonni greazo
shut up gleeso. meat is delicious, so i'll keep eating it. let them die, so i can eat them, i say. and that shall be the whole of the law

Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 01:45
by Verbal
Rapist enjoy rape, should it therefore be ACCEPT?!
Humans probably taste nice also. Why is eeating human such a taboo? Equally UNACCEPT.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 01:49
by djonni greazo
so, should we kill all the natural predators because they eat meat? don't be ridiculous

Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 01:50
by Verbal
Did I say that?
If some retard kills someone they don't go to jail for murder.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 02:50
by supa tuna
[quote name="Verbal"]Did I say that?
If some gleeso kills someone they don't go to jail for murder.[/quote]

Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 02:53
by Verbal
Clever.
Have a gold star. And later we can put it on the fridge.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 02:55
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Verbal"]There's a difference between eating something and taking its milk or wool. And all I was doing was questioning your point that "Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled." as part of an argument in favour of eating meat. It just doesn't make sense as far as I can see.
I sarded writing a long post so I just copied two from the above-linked thread.
It's pretty awful how most of the animals we eat are treated. I think it's pretty ignorant to assume they don't suffer greatly. Seeing as we are intelligent enough to have moral/ethical ideas regarding human life/suffering. . why should the other animals not be included? We are nice to retarded humans. Nobody breeds them, keeps them locked up in cages, and then painfully slaughters them either for our amusement, or for food.
Granted the other animals are not as intelligent as humans (in most cases), but they definitely feel pain and suffering.
If it's okay to treat other animals the way we do (especially the more intelligent ones), then why should we be so nice to retarded humans? I think there is a big inconsistency there.
Vegetables have no nervous system. Nobody thinks they're any more able to suffer than water is. There's obviously a spectrum from primitive animals through to the more intelligent ones. I'm not sure how the potentially hard lives of people harvesting vegetables is a justiication for the way most animals are treated. Although that's probably not what you mean. You maybe mean, "Why make such a fuss about other animals while there are humans suffering?" I'm not saying pigs should have equal rights to humans. I'm saying I think the present generally accepted standard people have for how other animals should be treated, and the present generally accepted standard people have for how humans should be treated is not at all representative of the differences between us. Given that they are, in effect, our retarded cousins.
Pardon any obvious errors I'm making, but I suppose any moral or ethical "code" or something should not only consider humans.
Surely it makes more sense to decide based on a number of things, like the animal's ability to suffer, feel pain, fear, etc .. rather than an all or nothing "Is it human or not?" approach.
I'm not necessarily against eating meat. I just can't see how the miserable painful lives that we inflict on a lot of them and are presently tolerated by people is justifiable. Surely anyone would agree with that at least? If they were farmed and slaughtered in a more humane way, maybe that'd be okay. I don't know.
I'm against hunting. I can't see how anyone wouldn't be. Would people be ok with sending a bunch of people with Down Syndrome into the woods and then hunting them down, and all that goes with it? Would the fact it's fun to do be a reasonable justification for it?
I realise you can go overboard. People can ask how anyone can justify buying anything for themselves that's not completely necessary for survival. How can you justify buying that cup of absu's beverage when there are people dying of starvation. Etc. I don't expect anyone to be like that. I think it's up to the individual to decide what they want to do.
I guess, in summary, I think if people have a problem with any form of human suffering, to be consistent, they shouldn't dismiss the suffering of other animals just because they're not human. It's not just being human that makes something worth caring about.
Apologies for repitition.[/quote
I brought up the whole meat/evolution thing, because I always find it to be something of note. We may be the manimals we are now because a long time ago someone bashed something over the head with a rock and ate it. I find the idea, confirmed or not, amusing.
Keeping animals captive to harvest milk or wool isn't that far from keeping them captive to raise for food. The condition of large scale dairy farms is hardly ideal. We have ethics for animal testing. We should have similar ethics for farming.
And hunting is a really good idea in some circumstances. Wild hogs in Texas are culled year round due to the damage they can cause to farmland and ranch land. They reproduce like crazy and eat everything. A small portion of the deer hunting season is devoted to game management, so scrawny spikes can be removed from the gene pool. So long as these animals are used for food, I see no reason that the practice can't continue. It's certainly more cost effective than putting these animals on birth control.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 03:06
by Verbal
"Keeping animals captive to harvest milk or wool isn't that far from keeping them captive to raise for food." I'd sure as hell notice the difference between death and a haircut. But, I agree, the condition under which the animals are kept, regardless of what they're used for, should be more "ethical".
Whatever about whether it's okay to kill a particular animal for our convenience, I think it should be done in a less savage way than hunting.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 03:37
by Meat Engine
Hunting from a helicopter?

Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 03:44
by supa tuna
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 03:55
by djonni greazo
come on gleeso, you can do better than that. of course every (or most of) sensible person abhors the conditions in which those animals are kept. but thanks for stating the obvious

there just isn't anything (reasonable.. and of consequence. or at least
i cannot think of anything really) that the people of planet earth can do to change that.
and of course those farms/slaughterhouses/whatever are there for
convenience. but it's more about the
consumer's convenience (i'm not talking about the shitty conditions/abominable killing techniques, of course). sorry, but i'd rather spend my precious time studying or doing something constructive than go prancing around in the forest hunting for deer (or something) to get my daily dose of delicious meat
and i was "attacking" you for the general "vibe" of your posts that "killing animals (regardless of the degree of cruelty involved) is bad because we can get everything from plants." if i misinterpreted, my apologies.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 05:05
by Verbal
What do you mean? You can't see how it can be improved, therefore what? I shouldn't even have mentioned it?
I never said that eating meat is bad regardless of the way the animals are killed/treated. I never said it was good either. The only points I think I've actually made were that I think more people should give a shit about the way animals are treated. Or at least point out the inconsistency between people's reactions to human suffering and animal suffering and how it maybe isn't always representative of the differences between them. And the rest was questioning other people's reasons for things. Playing devil's advocate.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 05:21
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="djonni greazo"]come on gleeso, you can do better than that. of course every (or most of) sensible person abhors the conditions in which those animals are kept. but thanks for stating the obvious

there just isn't anything (reasonable.. and of consequence. or at least
i cannot think of anything really) that the people of planet earth can do to change that.
and of course those farms/slaughterhouses/whatever are there for
convenience. but it's more about the
consumer's convenience (i'm not talking about the shitty conditions/abominable killing techniques, of course). sorry, but i'd rather spend my precious time studying or doing something constructive than go prancing around in the forest hunting for deer (or something) to get my daily dose of delicious meat
and i was "attacking" you for the general "vibe" of your posts that "killing animals (regardless of the degree of cruelty involved) is bad because we can get everything from plants." if i misinterpreted, my apologies.[/quote]I don't think I'd consider factory farming to be convenient. It's come at the expense of raw dairy products, grass-fed meat (thus a severe lack of omega-3), organic produce, proliferation of worthless wheat/corn products, and the ability to choose from among local farmers.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 11:17
by Noyka
[quote name="hard-on bearer Incognito"]
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="Antonius Block"]it's not an individual until it comes out of the womb

[/quote]
It has potential to be an individual. You have no right to say it can't without reason.[/quote]
i've seen this same 'potential' line of reasoning used to argue that IUD's and really all forms of contraception are immoral. do you agree or disagree?
[/quote]
I don't think contraception is immoral I'm extremely liberal when it comes to sex ed and all that. Sperm on its own cannot become a baby therefore it is not potentially an individual until it combines with an egg.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 11:28
by Verbal
An embryo also needs input in order to grow/survive.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 11:34
by Noyka
If we say abortion is okay we slowly start slipping to late term abortion is okay and gene manipulation. Aren't there already practices where people will fertilize several eggs at once outside of the womb and decide what baby they want based on the traits? I can't remember if that's a real practice or not but if it is it's an example of why I think valuing life is important. If we start saying abortion is okay no matter the circumstances then we start slowly starting to think other things are okay.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 11:41
by Verbal
With the in vitro thing I think they sometimes only implant the ones without a particular genetic defect. I don't know if they look for anything other than that. There are also, as far as I know, usually embryos left over because only a couple are usually implanted. They end up in the bin. Maybe the recycling bin, I'm not sure.
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 11:51
by Verbal
And that slippery slope argument is terrible for a few reasons. One being, it can be argued both ways. If we allow people to get their way and bestow some sort of rights on a single human cell, because it might turn into a proper sentient human, then maybe you'd have people taking that to extremes and saying that OMG we evolved from bacteria, therefore all bacteria could maybe potentially in a few billion years evolve into something as "intelligent" as an human. Therefore we can't kill bacteria!
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 13:52
by jawn galliano
noyka, are you also opposed to embryonic stem cell research?
Re: Woman Live-Tweets Her Abortion
Posted: 05 Mar 2010, 16:13
by Ninny
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]
[quote name="Verbal"]
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]Were it not for meat, human evolution may well have stalled.[/quote]
What?
And that doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not we should eat meat now.[/quote]
There is a thesis that the nutrition provided by meat allowed the brain to grow to the point of more complex reasoning. Should we eat meat? As long as we continue to rely on animal byproducts, I see no reason for half measures.[/quote]
I thought it was leaving the woods and dwelling the plains that helped us evolve. On a plain walking upright is an advantage, walking upright demands more brain capacity. We must continue to leave the woods or else we´ll devolve
