Page 1 of 1
A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 04:09
by Meat Engine
I heard it was because of the random drug screenings they do on craft personnel.

He should have known better, and just gone to work hungover like everyone else.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 04:12
by jawn galliano
it's just as effective, and you'll never have to deal with handling another man's urine when you need a clean sample!
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:10
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
employee drug screenings

Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:15
by Lavabug
Why? It's the employer's choice to screen his employees for drugs. You could always not apply to a job if they do drug screenings, the market is free after all.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:17
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
most employers do so due to government pressure; it's simply too costly
also, wage slavery ≠ free market
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:26
by Lavabug
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]most employers do so due to government pressure; it's simply too costly
[/quote]
Costly how? What fee do you have to pay to avoid requiring drug tests as an employer? And since when do big retail franchises take orders from anyone?
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:39
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="Lavabug"]Costly how? What fee do you have to pay to avoid requiring drug tests as an employer?[/quote]
<!-- m -->
http://www.braunconsulting.com/bcg/news ... ing03.html<!-- m -->
[quote name="Lavabug"] And since when do big retail franchises take orders from anyone?[/quote]
Um, regulations? Of course, large corporations are the ones responsible for putting regulations in place, in order to raise the barrier of entry for entrepreneurship.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:43
by Lavabug
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]Costly how? What fee do you have to pay to avoid requiring drug tests as an employer?[/quote]
<!-- m -->
http://www.braunconsulting.com/bcg/news ... ing03.html<!-- m -->
[/quote]
All that says is that drug testing is cost-ineffective, not that screening is required by government regulations. My point still stands.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:51
by Redd
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]also, wage slavery ≠ free market[/quote]
There's wage slavery in a "free market" system too. Would you really want to go to work in a free market (or any other system)? I'm sure if you could sit around and do whatever you wanted and still got food, housing, etc. you wouldn't work. People only work to get money, hence, wage slavery. We're all slaves to a job of some sort unfortunately, because we all need to eat.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 06:58
by Lavabug
Before the thread turns into another festering borefest about the merits and downsides of economic doctrine X, I just wanted to underscore something for you catacat:
You should look for consistency in your ideas here. You either have to defend a recreational habit against the implications of a laissez-faire hiring policy, or you respect the employer's freedom to the personnel select the personnel he wants and go work somewhere else/start your own business, as is stipulated in a free-market system. You can't have it both ways.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 07:39
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Maybe I haven't mentioned this yet, but I'm a left-libertarian. I believe principled libertarianism should synthesize with the radical labor movement. Not only that, but that true laizzes-faire, free market principles, taken to their logical conclusions, would lead to a lateral spread of wealth where "workers" and "bosses" disappear in favor of autonomous contractors (the "entrepreneuriat") and workers' syndicates.
And given that "laizzes-faire" typically means, "free exchange in the absence of coercion", then how could employee drug testing be at all considered laizzes-faire? Even in the absence of government coercion, this still entails coercion on the part of the employer.
If you care, take a look at this presentation,
Capitalism Vs. the Free Market, by Sheldon Richman
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 07:49
by Redd
[quote name="Subcomandante Marcos"]Maybe I haven't mentioned this yet, but I'm a left-libertarian. I believe principled libertarianism should synthesize with the radical labor movement. Not only that, but that true laizzes-faire, free market principles, taken to their logical conclusions, would lead to a lateral spread of wealth where "workers" and "bosses" disappear in favor of autonomous contractors (the "entrepreneuriat") and workers' syndicates.
And given that "laizzes-faire" typically means, "free exchange in the absence of coercion", then how could employee drug testing be at all considered laizzes-faire? Even in the absence of government coercion, this still entails coercion on the part of the employer.
If you care, take a look at this presentation,
Capitalism Vs. the Free Market, by Sheldon Richman[/quote]
And I still don't want to work some job that I won't want to go to half the time. I'd rather stay at home, travel, etc. but I can't do that, because in pretty much any system I have to work to live. In a free market system, can I get money for sitting on my ass at home reading a book? Assuming the answer is yes, can I live comfortably off that money? Can I travel around the world with that money?
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 07:55
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
Obviously certain logical imperatives need to be met. Eat food or die. Eat good food or get sick and fat.
The problem here is not people having to work, it's that when they want to work, they're blocked from engaging in entrepreneurship through regulations, Federal Reserve's money tampering, etc. and are thus forced to bargain on terms set by the capitalist class.
[quote name="Kevin Carson"]The central function of the government’s “safety” and “consumer protection” regulations, in most cases, is either to exclude competing providers of a good or service from the market, to circumscribe the areas of competition between them, or to set a floor on the capitalization required for doing business and thus impose a mandatory minimum overhead. The overall effect, as Paul Goodman put it in People or Personnel, is to create a 300% or 400% markup in the cost of doing anything, and render us all dependent on institutional providers with bureaucratic cultures and high overhead costs. By mandating centralized, high-tech, and skill-intensive ways of doing things, the state makes it harder for ordinary people to translate their own skills and knowledge into use-value. Tollgates are erected between effort and consumption, so that it becomes harder to meet our subsistence needs through our own direct labor or through barter with other small producers outside the wage system. As a result, “decent poverty becomes impossible.”[/quote]
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:19
by Redd
Okay, so what I'm getting from this is: eliminate the Fed, deregulate small business. Correct?
Andrew Jackson destroyed the Second Bank of the United States, yet we have the Fed today (which has a lot more control than the SBUS). Fat lot his anti-central bank policies did in the long run. And what about big business? Further regulations, correct? While I am totally in support of stricter regulations (especially in regards to environmental pollution and the slave-driving they do in Asian countries), these companies still have enough money to buy out our politicians and lobby Congress until there's no tomorrow. I would love to see laws prohibiting big business from buying out government, however, but I don't see it happening, especially when government itself is a business and does what it must to get money.
Oh, and don't think I'm pro-capitalism or whatever. I make little to no distinction between the different forms of a monetary society.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:24
by Meat Engine
I should point out here that I fall in the middle of this issue. I would rather not see anyone fired for failing a drug screening for something they did during off-hours, but I respect my employer's position on the matter. It's very clear. You may be screened for drugs at any time via urine test, and a positive result may mean immediate dismissal.
Keep the laissez-faire system, by the way. I want none of it. I rather enjoy the protections afforded to me by OSHA, the FDA, the NHTSA and others.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:25
by zim
you guys bitch too much. seriously, shut the fuck up.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:26
by Verbal
Ssshhhh zim. Men are talking.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:29
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="The Fu Monster"]I should point out here that I fall in the middle of this issue. I would rather not see anyone fired for failing a drug screening for something they did during off-hours, but I respect my employer's position on the matter. It's very clear. You may be screened for drugs at any time via urine test, and a positive result may mean immediate dismissal.
Keep the laissez-faire system, by the way. I want none of it. I rather enjoy the protections afforded to me by OSHA,
the FDA, the NHTSA and others.[/quote]
are you serious? Actually, I'm going to just assume you're not serious about this and not read this thread anymore
Of all parts of the government to take sides with, you pick the fucking FDA

::::::::::::::::::::
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 08:54
by Meat Engine
I rather like the Safe Food and Drug Act. It's certainly a lot more effective than caveat emptor. It is, however, a perpetual victim of budget stagnation, politicization, and organizational shortcomings. The EPA is great, too. The FCC has been asleep at the wheel for about two decades, but its mission is a good one.
Libertarian philosophy is a black hole when it comes to offering alternative means of widespread protection from fraud or injurious negligence.
Re: A welder was fired today
Posted: 04 Mar 2010, 16:08
by Lavabug
[quote name="Skintoxication"]if its not affecting your job performance, who cares? possibly being denied, or fired from a job because of something you do on your own time is absolutely stupid.[/quote]
That is besides the point, the case is: in a free-market/libertarian-conservative/laissez-faire system, or whatever you want to call it, employers are free to hire whoever they want, using whatever criteria they seem fit, as they are not told how to run their business by any authority.
Likewise, employers could choose not to hire black people, this is perfectly justifiable under such a doctrine. If anyone thinks this is wrong, maybe they should stop heralding economic doctrine X as being the best way to do things, when clearly they are at odds with it themselves. It is a double standard.
In other words, I'm suggesting we start looking at problems critically on a per-case basis, instead of laying out economic doctrine X and let its stipulations do all the thinking for us. I have no ill feelings towards anyone.
