Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Shoot the shit with other metal folk. Free discussion on any topic that doesn't suit the other forums. Avoid mentioning carpet.
Post Reply
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

...fails to announce desire to cash in on health care reform lobbying. That bit about tiring of the partisan bickering seems to be a blatant lie. His timing is suspect. Why hamstring one's own party as he has done, with the late announcement? The simple answer may be that he's never been a party politician, which can be a good thing. He was never attached to the Democrat's name or agenda. He was a fiscal and social conservative, but such that he passed for a Democrat in relatively conservative Indiana, and he usually voted his own way.



My conspiracy theory:

Evan Bayh's late announcement of his intention to depart the Senate at the end of his term was a way of trying to hand the Republican party one more seat. I don't believe it's because he's a DINO, rather, the Republicans seem to be ever slightly more pliant when it comes to lobbying by health care interests. I predict Evan Bayh lands at a lobbying firm that handles such, or on the corporate board of a company that stands to benefit from health care reform.



Allow me to state that I have no proof of Evan Bayh's intentions, only that I believe this course of action to be a likely one given the questions that have been raised in the past concerning his wife's professional positions and affiliations. He could want to run a frozen banana stand for all I know.



Image



I can hope, right?
User avatar
Grudge
Metal God
Posts: 10548
Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 10:23

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Grudge »

:zzz:
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

I can't promise you'd care, even if you lived in America and could vote. But this is big time news, I swear.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

It has been made clear to me that leaving late is actually a FAVOR to his party; they don't need to run a messy primary. The crony of choice can now be installed. Huzzah!
User avatar
jawn galliano
Yahtzee Genius
Posts: 24065
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by jawn galliano »

the healthcare industry is going to be the one coming out on top after the whole mess is over, and it shouldn't surprise anyone to see politicians ending up in positions similar to what fu predicts. that's just how it works, you help out an interest with your political clout, they reward you with a cushy high-power position when you decide the government thing is getting old.



i think you're doing yourself a disservice by labeling it a conspiracy theory. conspiracy theories are far-fetched, have no basis in reality, etc. etc.
Noyka
Ancient One
Posts: 4935
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
Location: California

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Noyka »

What the fuck are you smoking calling him a fiscal conservative? Nobody who votes for massive spending bills like the stimulus and the current healthcare bill can even think of calling themselves fiscal conservatives. Remember most Americans are moderates who lean a little right (this is what most polls show) so politicians like to play themselves as fiscal conservatives when often times they aren't.



Of course he'll get a nice cushy lobbying job, a lot of senators get those jobs after being "loyal" long enough. I'm tired, as the rest of America is, of having the Washington way shoved down my throat and in my face. I know if I don't pay attention and speak my mind though these crooks will just continue to walk all over everyone.



Who cares if republicans take charge? It doesn't matter right now they're scared and might actually listen to what most Americans want if that isn't the case some real change needs to occur but doubt that's even posisble in this country right now.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

[quote name="Noyka"]What the fuck are you smoking calling him a fiscal conservative? Nobody who votes for massive spending bills like the stimulus and the current healthcare bill can even think of calling themselves fiscal conservatives. Remember most Americans are moderates who lean a little right (this is what most polls show) so politicians like to play themselves as fiscal conservatives when often times they aren't.



Of course he'll get a nice cushy lobbying job, a lot of senators get those jobs after being "loyal" long enough. I'm tired, as the rest of America is, of having the Washington way shoved down my throat and in my face. I know if I don't pay attention and speak my mind though these crooks will just continue to walk all over everyone.



Who cares if republicans take charge? It doesn't matter right now they're scared and might actually listen to what most Americans want if that isn't the case some real change needs to occur but doubt that's even posisble in this country right now.[/quote]



I only describe Bayh as he styles himself. I understand that there are very few true fiscal conservatives in elected office. And on economic issues, you are correct. The nation trends center-right. On social issues, however, the nation trends center-left. What does this mean? For starters, a libertarian might do well if his or her economic platform was decidedly non-Randian, and was something more along the lines of pragmatism determined by efficacy and utilitarian benefit. That is, assuming, said person exists and can find a big enough soap box.



I would like to offer that a recession is a really bad time to be tooting the horn of fiscal conservatism. FDR tried that in 1937. It wiped out the progress made with the New Deal up to that point. The U.S. has run up higher debt as a percentage of GDP and recovered from it. Like the previous time, there are cuts to be made when the footing is a little more stable. I can offer ideas on how to reign in the budget all day long. End the occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan, withdraw all U.S. troops from within foreign borders, and give the defense budget a minimum 50% haircut. Abolish the DEA. Abolish the BATFE. That's what the FBI and Treasury Departments are for. There's your spending reduction. Streamline the personal income tax code. If we absolutely must have it, get rid of the confusion. Progressive tax rates for the various income brackets with no deductions and no caps (Social Security is suddenly solvent in perpetuity). The corporate tax code is broken. Set a flat rate with no possible deductions, and the IRS will collect money for a change (the CBO says something like 95% of corporations have no net tax burden in the current system).



All of the above will only require the political capital no person could hope to accumulate, the will no politician will ever have, and an invasion of pod people to replace nearly every representative and senator. We can build on this.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="Noyka"]Remember most Americans are moderates who lean a little right (this is what most polls show) [/quote]

:lol:
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]Remember most Americans are moderates who lean a little right (this is what most polls show) [/quote]

:lol:[/quote]



As I pointed out, she is kind of half right. Many Americans probably believe they are fiscal conservatives. I would imagine, however, if you started asking them what programs the government should fund, it would probably add up quickly. I don't expect there are a lot of Americans out there that want the government to cut spending on education, defense or entitlements.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="The Fu Monster"]
[quote name="desolation"]
[quote name="Noyka"]Remember most Americans are moderates who lean a little right (this is what most polls show) [/quote]

:lol:[/quote]



As I pointed out, she is kind of half right. Many Americans probably believe they are fiscal conservatives. I would imagine, however, if you started asking them what programs the government should fund, it would probably add up quickly. I don't expect there are a lot of Americans out there that want the government to cut spending on education, defense or entitlements.[/quote]

I just laugh whenever anyone puts even a modicum of faith in polls. They cannot ever represent more than they poll and what do you think the proportion of people who participate is compared to the rest of the voting population? Political polls are typically near-useless.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
Noyka
Ancient One
Posts: 4935
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
Location: California

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Noyka »

It depends on who does them and when a number of polls get the same results you can say there's probably some truth to it. Still don't believe them? Look at the outrage in the country towards Obama's economic policies you can see they do not approve of "spending your way our of a recession".



How can you say now isn't the time for fiscal conservativism? FDR's new deal LENGTHENED the depression anyone who has read anything on that era knows this.



95% of businesses don't pay taxes? That makes no sense, I like the idea of a flat tax and not burdening people by pushing class warfare which is what our current system does in many ways. Low tax rates actually get the government more revenue because those with money will come to where the rates are reasonable. Those who make a lot (a lot of celebs) move to areas they don't have to pay 40% income taxes (IE out of New York and California). You think your ideas will work? Look to California this is where the nation can head if we don't get some fiscal reform.
User avatar
jawn galliano
Yahtzee Genius
Posts: 24065
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 04:24

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by jawn galliano »

[quote name="Noyka"]It depends on who does them and when a number of polls get the same results you can say there's probably some truth to it.[/quote]



that's just an indicator of reliability, not necessarily accuracy.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

[quote name="Noyka"]It depends on who does them and when a number of polls get the same results you can say there's probably some truth to it. Still don't believe them? Look at the outrage in the country towards Obama's economic policies you can see they do not approve of "spending your way our of a recession".



How can you say now isn't the time for fiscal conservativism? FDR's new deal LENGTHENED the depression anyone who has read anything on that era knows this.



95% of businesses don't pay taxes? That makes no sense, I like the idea of a flat tax and not burdening people by pushing class warfare which is what our current system does in many ways. Low tax rates actually get the government more revenue because those with money will come to where the rates are reasonable. Those who make a lot (a lot of celebs) move to areas they don't have to pay 40% income taxes (IE out of New York and California). You think your ideas will work? Look to California this is where the nation can head if we don't get some fiscal reform.[/quote]



You've got your facts wrong, lady. The New Deal worked from 1933 to 1937 until FDR bowed to pressure and cut spending and raised taxes (See <!-- m -->http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/1 ... economics/<!-- m -->). That caused a second dip in the economy which was not rectified until the WWII economic boom. Keynesian economics works - Austrian/the official city of the chicago cubs/supply side economists have just waged a ridiculous campaign to discredit the policies. You say people don't believe in spending the way out of a recession. I bet if you asked if they opposed extended unemployment insurance or additional food assistance during a recession, they'd say no. And that's good, because those two items give the largest economic impact per dollar spent. Tax cuts, not so much.



I said something like 95% of CORPORATIONS in the U.S. pay no effective marginal tax. There are a lot of loopholes in the code. On the books the marginal rate is very high. After you consider the way money can be shifted around to tax friendly subsidiaries, or offset with clawbacks, the payout is very low. Small businesses don't have the same benefits. The CBO did a report on just this topic, and I am trying to find it. It's quite illuminating.



Let's talk about California for a second. They are a tax averse state. No one wants to raise taxes. Reagan saw to it that property taxes could not be used to fund education. They were fucked out of $40 billion dollars near the end of the Gray Davis era when Enron, Duke Energy and other energy companies manufactured an energy crisis post-deregulation. They're also being strangled by a growing prison industrial complex, which has led to unsustainable levels of incarceration. California's problems don't arise from some sort of crazy spending spree. They've just been taken for a ride.



TLDR: The government can take temporary measures to blunt a recession or depression that involve deficit spending, but said measures need to be weighed for potential economic impact. Most people don't know this, but happen to like some of the measures that work well.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="hard-on bearer Incognito"]
[quote name="Noyka"]It depends on who does them and when a number of polls get the same results you can say there's probably some truth to it.[/quote]



that's just an indicator of reliability, not necessarily accuracy.[/quote]

This.







Goddamn the Republican National Committee were well good and made a fool of on The Daily Show last night.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
Noyka
Ancient One
Posts: 4935
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
Location: California

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Noyka »

People's reactions, at least fiscally, back up what polls are saying though.



Also Fu, do more research on FDR, New Deal, and what you're actually supporting. Seriously one of my passions is studying the late 1800s-early 1900s progressive era FDR and Wilson did a lot of damage to this nation people like you might simply not be aware of. The New Deal is a huge part of this. It was the first turn towards social democracy (not socialism as some know it) and a lot of people don't realize that. Sure huge spending bills might get short term results but long term they do a ton of damage hence the Depression being lengthened and manufacturing from WWII contributing to getting us out not the New Deal. Remember the men went to war and women went to work during WWII. This created real jobs, real growth not the fake growth like we're seeing now. Am I saying WARS ARE GOOD FOR JOBS? No, I'm saying growing the private sector and manufacturing in particular is.



Remember, to the victor goes the spoil that's why even with Civil War history you never hear about the tariffs and tyranny the north was imposing on the south, state rights are hardly mentioned. If they are it's during reconstruction and only with Johnson (who face it was a flop) and viewed in a negative light. This is how it was with the 3 most recent classes I've taken on history. Civil War wasn't over slavery it was over state's rights and the livlihoods of people being taken away. Lincoln didn't even want to pass the emancipation proclamation he didn't want the drama. Yet he's turned into some hero by some.
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

You seem to ignore the graph where basic economic indicators improved post 1933. That's when the New Deal went into effect. People like to think the jobs were make-work ones, but it's not the whole case. A lot of public infrastructure was improved. Post-1937, the New Deal was rolled back with decreased spending and increased taxation. That is what lengthened the depression, not the New Deal itself. I have yet to see a proper repudiation of one of the core Keynesian principles, that TEMPORARY deficit-financed government spending can be used to stimulate weak demand in a down economy, so long as the spending is properly targeted. There can be a problem in winding down said spending, but it isn't a grave scenario.



Allow me an example. The American Society of Civil Engineers has estimated a need for roughly $3 trillion in basic infrastructure improvements. That is not new projects, like light rail, only maintenance and code compliance for existing infrastructure. That would have been a good target for an even larger stimulus than the one we got. The private market doesn't determine when these projects are scheduled, rather, municipal and state governments do. These governments contract with private firms to complete the work. Financing a portion of these projects through deficit spending would have been a fair way to create temporary work over a period of a few years, smoothing out the transition back to what we consider to be nominal unemployment. Cash For Clunkers and the first time home buyer tax credit represent programs that inflate economic growth, but infrastructure improvements by their nature are staggered over years. The private sector isn't going to magic its way out of a recession.



The U.S. went into even greater debt as a percentage of GDP by the end of WWII, and faced a post-war recession, as the men returned to manufacturing jobs, and the output dropped to pre-war levels. Potential manufacturing output had increased, setting the stage for the U.S. rise to manufacturing prominence, but it was hardly the rosy scenario of economic recovery. As our manufacturing stands right now, the best way to increase demand for goods manufactured in the United States is to depress the value of the dollar against other currencies. Internal consumption is a poor way to stimulate manufacturing demand during a recession. At some point, exports need to rise. Running a trade deficit a slow war of attrition on the goal of near full employment. The manufacturing sector should be even worse if not for the large public welfare program run to benefit Northrop-Grumman, Lockheed-Martin, Boeing, General Dynamics and other defense contractors. Becoming a manufacturing leader once again is a goal that we should share, but we need to start making things that people want. To give you an example, a wind farm was recently constructed in my county. The windmills were designed in Denmark and manufactured in South Korea. This is work that one would think could have been accomplished solely in Texas, but that is apparently not the case.



Want to revitalize U.S. manufacturing? Rethink our free trade agreements. NAFTA had the predictable effect of pulling us down towards Mexico's level, rather than raising it to our level. We exported our manufacturing jobs, and U.S. agribusiness wiped out their agricultural jobs. Illegal immigration increased, environmental protections decreased, and both sides lost. Some nationwide goal or planning framework can't hurt, either. I really, really hate to agree with Thomas Friedman about anything, but the U.S. needs to revitalize its manufacturing through new energy technologies. We should be making windmills, solar panels, turbines, high efficiency electric motors and countless other things that WILL be needed. The market for cluster bombs is, understandably, limited. The free market only rarely sees beyond what is needed now. Right now we are an oil-based economy, but that will not always be the case.



I would also like to point out that no where in the history of the United States up to the Civil War is secession identified as a legitimate recourse for a state in the union. One could argue the states declared independence from England as one, and only became identified as states of a union, rather than colonies of a foreign country, through the formation of the union first in the Articles of Confederation and then in the Constitution. Extending that reasoning, states do not exist independent of the union. People can revolt. States cannot secede. I haven't even touched the moral arguments against the secession of the southern states, or the inability of South Carolina's secession documents to illustrate a singularly oppressive situation that could potentially see the legitimacy of a state government, rather than the populace, declaring total independence. I don't, however, idolize Lincoln. He suspended habeas corpus and allowed Sherman to wage his campaign of total war. He did the right thing, however, both legally and morally, in preserving the union.
Noyka
Ancient One
Posts: 4935
Joined: 16 Apr 2009, 08:16
Location: California

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Noyka »

I said temporary benefits occur but in the long run it's nothing but harmful that is a fact, it's been proven and will be proven again with current economics. Manufacturing through "green" jobs like you are suggesting actually causes jobs to be lost, in Spain for ever green job created two jobs are lost. Solar panels and wind mills are wasteful we should focus on thermoenergy and tidal energy but that's an entirely different argument.



It's in the constitution any state can secede from the union. The confederacy had their own government, they declared independence that was constitutional. It was morally okay to allow the high tariffs? I don't think so. It was morally right to use African Americans as a political ping pong ball?
User avatar
Meat Engine
Ancient One
Posts: 4451
Joined: 02 Feb 2010, 02:55
Contact:

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Meat Engine »

[quote name="Noyka"]I said temporary benefits occur but in the long run it's nothing but harmful that is a fact, it's been proven and will be proven again with current economics. Manufacturing through "green" jobs like you are suggesting actually causes jobs to be lost, in Spain for ever green job created two jobs are lost. Solar panels and wind mills are wasteful we should focus on thermoenergy and tidal energy but that's an entirely different argument.



It's in the constitution any state can secede from the union. The confederacy had their own government, they declared independence that was constitutional. It was morally okay to allow the high tariffs? I don't think so. It was morally right to use African Americans as a political ping pong sadist's plaything?[/quote]



The previous stimulus would not be a good indicator. It was fully a third tax cuts, which have the lowest economic impact of any stimulus measure. It also had programs that only provide short term benefits, like Cash For Clunkers and the home buyer tax credit. As I said before, targeted spending on infrastructure and related work gives you proven economic impact. If the goal is to get people working, earning and spending, it is absolutely the best way. If you don't care about people working, unemployment insurance and food stamps is even better. Both options are head and shoulders above doing nothing. Economics has yet to prove Keynes wrong on that count.



Please provide a link to the study that says specifically the creation of green manufacturing jobs directly causes the loss of jobs. What you have brought up sounds suspiciously like someone trying to claim that because Spain is losing jobs by the truckload, it is the fault of the creation of green jobs. What I know of Spain's troubles is that they had a comparatively sized construction bubble that collapsed.



Solar panels are actually pretty great, and improving all of the time. Dow Chemical will roll out photovoltaic roof shingles that can be installed by general contractors and tied into the grid. Traditional panels are seeing increases in efficiency and decreases in manufacturing cost due to the development of panels that can use more common materials. To abandon solar power would be moronic and short sighted. Windmills are excellent too. Large turbines can provide a steady 1.5 MW at load. You can't plan a power grid around them, but you can reduce the number of coal and gas fired plants needed to push extra power into the grid during heavy load. Tidal energy is even better, by virtue of water having a much larger density than air. The technology is still not thoroughly tested, but we should be trying to get in on the ground floor. And I don't know where you expect to get geothermal energy. This isn't Iceland. Hawaii has it in abundance, and parts of the Pacific Northwest might be able to utilize it, but that's it.



The Constitution does not provide a mechanism for secession or the partial dissolution of the Union. Please to be reading it again. Please to be reading the original secession documents from South Carolina as well. The reasons given for secession have primarily to do with the election of Abraham Lincoln in the 1860's, the desire to perpetuate slavery, and the perceived unwillingness of the northern states in the Union to enforce laws mandating the return of escaped slaves. Tariffs are not mentioned at all. While both sides are dirty, the South has sole possession of morality's rock bottom.
User avatar
Abzu
Postwhore
Posts: 45613
Joined: 17 Apr 2009, 08:35
Location: next door

Re: Evan Bayh announces retirement from Senate

Post by Abzu »

[quote name="Noyka"]People's reactions, at least fiscally, back up what polls are saying though.[/quote]

Please illustrate how.



[quote name="Noyka"]Remember the men went to war and women went to work during WWII. This created real jobs, real growth not the fake growth like we're seeing now. Am I saying WARS ARE GOOD FOR JOBS? No, I'm saying growing the private sector and manufacturing in particular is.[/quote]

War hasn't been good for jobs since we abandoned our post as the top manufacturing nation.
ANGEL OF DESEASE wrote:the path of whoring is something wicked and grim, and very philosophical.
;,,;
Post Reply