Page 1 of 1

Doom Eternal review

Posted: 03 Jul 2020, 11:25
by Grudge
I bought it when it got discounted down to $30 recently on Steam. Just finished it, so here are my thoughts.

The bad

It is a little too simple and straightforward. This felt like I was playing a Mario game with demons. Colorful candy-like drops fall on you literally like a shower when you kill demons. And it's basically just some very simple jumping and climbing puzzles, and they are usually rectangular boxes or squares.

It is so completely linear that the slightest bit of exploration off the track is called "secrets" which you find by basically glancing left or right instead of the direction this game wants you to go in, and that's about it. They are not the slightest bit difficult to find and provide only very minor divergences.

This game (I recall like the previous one) has green lights that tell you exactly where you need to go and what to do, holds your hand throughout the game. I don't know what kind of moron you would have to be to, in addition to this, turn on the compass and objective marker for this game but they have those in this too (I turned them off). Also the story is convoluted, confusing, contradictory and not really interesting.

It also has a short play-through time.

The good

The combat ofcourse. The additional options to bust up enemies in the game are well considered. Since ammo is a little scarcer you have to switch a lot between weapons and actions like chainsawing, flamethrowing and punching which I think gets rid of the monotony of using a one size fits all approach. I liked the double jumps and mid-air dashes.

The weapons for the most part are great and improved over the previous game, except for the crappy Ballista. I thought that was a bad replacement for the Gauss gun from the previous game. My go-to weapons were the mobile turret chain gun and the grenade launcher shotgun.

The difficulty is designed fairly; I played on the second hardest difficulty and it was as challenging as it should have been.

The game ran very smoothly, I had all-max graphics at 1440p resolution and it never dropped below 160 fps on my system. For lower grade setups it should still run smoothly as it is a pretty well-optimized game.

The so-called role-playing elements where you upgrade either your character, your suit or your weapon are a superficial system, there's hardly any sense of making a real-trade off where the choice you make really differentiates your character. This is because with the slightest bit of effort you can find nearly all the upgrades to make a fully decked out character. Regardless, some is better than nothing.

Overall

I enjoyed it. But in hindsight maybe I wouldn't have paid $30 for it. There have been other new shooters that I consider works of art that this doesn't come close to (like Prey) because it's just a basic Mario style platformer with guns and demons. My recommendation is, don't buy into the hype. I didn't, that's why I waited until the price dropped. A good price to pick this up would be maybe $20.

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 03 Jul 2020, 15:30
by User
good review

i could never make a distinction in value from $20 to $30 for a videogame

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 03 Jul 2020, 16:33
by zim
solid review

30 dollars is where i draw the line for most games these days with an except here and there

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 03 Jul 2020, 19:26
by neckred
I snatched it for $40 less than two months after release. Refuse to pay $60 for a video game these days. This shits aren't cartridges.

Nightmare difficulty the first play through. Out of pure insanity. Glad I did such.

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 05 Jul 2020, 11:49
by Grudge
User wrote:good review

i could never make a distinction in value from $20 to $30 for a videogame
Ok, let me rephrase that then. Don't pay full price, don't rush to buy, because this is not a revolutionary game that you're missing out some great experience on. It's just decent fun, and I would have been fine waiting even a year or two to get it.

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 05 Jul 2020, 17:44
by User
ok. this thread inspired me to play the 2016 doom. it must be like that?

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 06 Jul 2020, 02:48
by Grudge
Yes, with the improvements noted above.

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 06 Jul 2020, 02:50
by jawn galliano
yeah it's really remarkable how well the game runs. i don't think i have max quality settings, but i've never had it drop a frame on my 5 year old GTX970/i5 system.

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 07 Jul 2020, 04:33
by neckred
recently took 2016 for a spin again. tis quite strange, after playing DE twice through

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 25 Jul 2020, 07:37
by Corpsepyre
I enjoyed it quite a lot. A little more than the 2016 game, for sure, though both are good. My only real complaints are some of the later levels and the Marauder. Fuck him. :greenie:

Re: Doom Eternal review

Posted: 23 Aug 2020, 19:10
by agony bagony
prequels are better