Page 1 of 1

Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 06 Feb 2010, 04:02
by Meat Engine
OR - the Senate needs to revisit its procedural rules. He just put a hold on something like 70 judicial nominees, and will relent until he gets a ransom. Specifically, he wants the much talked about $40 billion in-air refueling tanker deal with EADS to move forward, and he wants another $45 million for a FBI facility. Seriously, why is it that one senator can obstruct a nomination indefinitely? These are supposed to be thumbs up/thumbs down matters regardless of who is in power. Flesh out the nominee's qualifications and then have a vote. Indefinite holds and the filibuster need to go. It allows one side to decide that doing nothing is the new norm.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 06 Feb 2010, 16:58
by Haunty
Yeah, it really needs to go. I guess the idea is that they're all supposedly protecting America from the other side fucking it up. Really though, they're just scared that they're going to lose their pants if they don't get their big-budget contracts pushed through.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 07 Feb 2010, 04:20
by Noyka
But just passing things through because it helps your party would be a bigger issue if there was no way to block bills/nominations/other such shit.



The whole system is broken.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 07 Feb 2010, 04:56
by Meat Engine
Any government that requires a super-majority to conduct routine business will surely find itself in peril. My problem in this particular instance, however, is that there is no principle behind his actions. He simply wants a ransom. It was the same way a few months ago to get the Democrats-in-name-only to back the HCR bills in the House and the Senate. They were bribed, and that set a really bad precedent. These nominations should not be rubber stamped through the Senate by any means, but they should be properly scrutinized and allowed to come up for a vote in a timely fashion.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 07 Feb 2010, 06:56
by Noyka
There is no such thing as a moderate democrat right now, most of them are progressives (or greedy assholes like Landreau and Nelson) masquerading as liberals they just care about their party. I thought it was tactless how some progressives and liberals went after Lieberman's wife because he didn't support the health care bill, they basically forced him to vote for it. Some democrats in the past have been fiscally conservative and socially liberal, that doesn't make them a democrat in name only. There are republicans like that as well, that doesn't make them a republican in name only either. I think the whole party thing is out dated. Republicans lack values just as much as democrats as well.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 07 Feb 2010, 10:15
by Haunty
This topic isn't going to go much of anywhere. That's why I'm just going to go ahead and derail it right now.

Image

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 07 Feb 2010, 15:17
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Noyka"]There is no such thing as a moderate democrat right now, most of them are progressives (or greedy assholes like Landreau and Nelson) masquerading as liberals they just care about their party. I thought it was tactless how some progressives and liberals went after Lieberman's wife because he didn't support the health care bill, they basically forced him to vote for it. Some democrats in the past have been fiscally conservative and socially liberal, that doesn't make them a democrat in name only. There are republicans like that as well, that doesn't make them a republican in name only either. I think the whole party thing is out dated. Republicans lack values just as much as democrats as well.[/quote]



I consider myself a progressive. Most of those Democrats are not progressives. A principled progressive would have co-sponsored HR676, the single payer amendment. I realize that there is a Congressional Progressive Caucus, but all but two members folded when it was time to vote against the private insurance windfall that has been labeled Obamacare, including the self-proclaimed democratic socialist Bernie Sanders. I wish they'd kill both bills and start with the easy stuff. Let's see if any person would vote against forbidding exclusion based on a pre-existing condition, recission and lifetime benefit caps. It would be political suicide to do so. HR676 should be the starting point. With the threat of that, you can probably force the negotiations to result in a system that closely mirrors that of the Swiss and the Dutch. There are no public insurers. Private insurers provide a minimum level of coverage at a near 100% loss ratio, and then make money (and they do), by offering supplemental coverage packages. Really sick people covered by the bare minimum are subsidized.



To address the way Hadassah Lieberman was treated...it was fair. There is an obvious conflict of interest there. The same goes for Evan Bayh's wife, but she has been largely spared from scrutiny.



The political system can only be fixed when the mechanisms that enforce the two-party system are dismantled. More voices are better, to a point. I would like to see mandatory majorities for winning national elections. Instant runoff voting would keep the cost flat. Restricting the money and campaign windows, would be nice as well. It works in other countries. Lastly, I'd like term limits on both senators and representatives. These people get less effective with seniority, not more effective.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 08 Feb 2010, 04:40
by Noyka
[quote name="Deathrace King"]
[quote name="Noyka"]There is no such thing as a moderate democrat right now, most of them are progressives (or greedy assholes like Landreau and Nelson) masquerading as liberals they just care about their party. I thought it was tactless how some progressives and liberals went after Lieberman's wife because he didn't support the health care bill, they basically forced him to vote for it. Some democrats in the past have been fiscally conservative and socially liberal, that doesn't make them a democrat in name only. There are republicans like that as well, that doesn't make them a republican in name only either. I think the whole party thing is out dated. Republicans lack values just as much as democrats as well.[/quote]



I consider myself a progressive. Most of those Democrats are not progressives. A principled progressive would have co-sponsored HR676, the single payer amendment. I realize that there is a Congressional Progressive Caucus, but all but two members folded when it was time to vote against the private insurance windfall that has been labeled Obamacare, including the self-proclaimed democratic socialist Bernie Sanders. I wish they'd kill both bills and start with the easy stuff. Let's see if any person would vote against forbidding exclusion based on a pre-existing condition, recission and lifetime benefit caps. It would be political suicide to do so. HR676 should be the starting point. With the threat of that, you can probably force the negotiations to result in a system that closely mirrors that of the Swiss and the Dutch. There are no public insurers. Private insurers provide a minimum level of coverage at a near 100% loss ratio, and then make money (and they do), by offering supplemental coverage packages. Really sick people covered by the bare minimum are subsidized.



To address the way Hadassah Lieberman was treated...it was fair. There is an obvious conflict of interest there. The same goes for Evan Bayh's wife, but she has been largely spared from scrutiny.



The political system can only be fixed when the mechanisms that enforce the two-party system are dismantled. More voices are better, to a point. I would like to see mandatory majorities for winning national elections. Instant runoff voting would keep the cost flat. Restricting the money and campaign windows, would be nice as well. It works in other countries. Lastly, I'd like term limits on both senators and representatives. These people get less effective with seniority, not more effective.[/quote]



You honestly believe single payer would be a good option? That option would turn from an option to mandatory for everyone, it's happened in other nations it's possible it'll happen here. Our government has failed at running every other program so why the hell should we trust them with healthcare? With private there is choice, something that should remain. If the coverage is bad in theory you can switch providers. This was lost when we allowed ourselves to have employers decide healthcare for us. There's a lot of tweaks we can make to our system before destroying it with a single payer option. The type of system you're describing would work great if we didn't have such a difference in wealth nationwide. The nations you mentioned, to my knowledge, don't have that big of difference in wealth nationwide. Tort reform is something I think we all can get behind it'd save not only from lawsuits but unnecessary procedures doctors do to prevent lawsuits. We can also work on allowing insurance to be bought across state lines, I know this is tricky but we can start working towards it. Preexisting conditions need to get the boot no question about that everyone deserves access. We need to remember health care is not a right it is a service but all should have the ability to buy it or receive it via medicad/medicare two programs that need serious revamping.



Restricting term limits is something we all can get behind, limiting money spent on campaigns as well.



How was that fair? Everything I read on it made it seem like it was overblown and really trying to get at the senator which was wrong.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 08 Feb 2010, 04:42
by Verbal
I consider myself an arpeggio.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 08 Feb 2010, 10:54
by Abzu
Oh fuck-a-doodle-doo here we go again. :necro:

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 08 Feb 2010, 15:28
by Haunty
Fu will either learn about Akane and get bored of it, or he'll keep going. Either way, I dont' really feel the need to get involved.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 08 Feb 2010, 20:33
by Meat Engine
[quote name="Vampire Potter"]
[quote name="Deathrace King"]
[quote name="Noyka"]There is no such thing as a moderate democrat right now, most of them are progressives (or greedy assholes like Landreau and Nelson) masquerading as liberals they just care about their party. I thought it was tactless how some progressives and liberals went after Lieberman's wife because he didn't support the health care bill, they basically forced him to vote for it. Some democrats in the past have been fiscally conservative and socially liberal, that doesn't make them a democrat in name only. There are republicans like that as well, that doesn't make them a republican in name only either. I think the whole party thing is out dated. Republicans lack values just as much as democrats as well.[/quote]



I consider myself a progressive. Most of those Democrats are not progressives. A principled progressive would have co-sponsored HR676, the single payer amendment. I realize that there is a Congressional Progressive Caucus, but all but two members folded when it was time to vote against the private insurance windfall that has been labeled Obamacare, including the self-proclaimed democratic socialist Bernie Sanders. I wish they'd kill both bills and start with the easy stuff. Let's see if any person would vote against forbidding exclusion based on a pre-existing condition, recission and lifetime benefit caps. It would be political suicide to do so. HR676 should be the starting point. With the threat of that, you can probably force the negotiations to result in a system that closely mirrors that of the Swiss and the Dutch. There are no public insurers. Private insurers provide a minimum level of coverage at a near 100% loss ratio, and then make money (and they do), by offering supplemental coverage packages. Really sick people covered by the bare minimum are subsidized.



To address the way Hadassah Lieberman was treated...it was fair. There is an obvious conflict of interest there. The same goes for Evan Bayh's wife, but she has been largely spared from scrutiny.



The political system can only be fixed when the mechanisms that enforce the two-party system are dismantled. More voices are better, to a point. I would like to see mandatory majorities for winning national elections. Instant runoff voting would keep the cost flat. Restricting the money and campaign windows, would be nice as well. It works in other countries. Lastly, I'd like term limits on both senators and representatives. These people get less effective with seniority, not more effective.[/quote]



You honestly believe single payer would be a good option? That option would turn from an option to mandatory for everyone, it's happened in other nations it's possible it'll happen here. Our government has failed at running every other program so why the hell should we trust them with healthcare? With private there is choice, something that should remain. If the coverage is bad in theory you can switch providers. This was lost when we allowed ourselves to have employers decide healthcare for us. There's a lot of tweaks we can make to our system before destroying it with a single payer option. The type of system you're describing would work great if we didn't have such a difference in wealth nationwide. The nations you mentioned, to my knowledge, don't have that big of difference in wealth nationwide. Tort reform is something I think we all can get behind it'd save not only from lawsuits but unnecessary procedures doctors do to prevent lawsuits. We can also work on allowing insurance to be bought across state lines, I know this is tricky but we can start working towards it. Preexisting conditions need to get the boot no question about that everyone deserves access. We need to remember health care is not a right it is a service but all should have the ability to buy it or receive it via medicad/medicare two programs that need serious revamping.



Restricting term limits is something we all can get behind, limiting money spent on campaigns as well.



How was that fair? Everything I read on it made it seem like it was overblown and really trying to get at the senator which was wrong.[/quote]



Medicare is a single-payer program and works great. The payment structure is not very forgiving to primary care doctors, but that can be fixed. The VA works great too. Medicaid is not great, because it is operated by the states. Some do better than others. The existing system is broken. Insurance companies provide no added value. It would be different if every customer for a given insurer was thrown into a single risk pool with a single set of regulation and a mandatory loss ratio of no less than 85%, but that is not the case. Insurance companies get to operate countless risk pools to keep the cost high. They are permitted to have state-wide monopolies on coverage, keeping the costs high. Tort reform is a negligible impact on cost, around 2-3%. I'm also not a big fan. There's no limit as to how bad a doctor or surgeon can fail except mortality. Why limit the right of the victim or victim's family to seek recompense? Allowing insurance policies to be sold across state line will result in bad policies being sold out of states with bad regulation to people that have little other option. Those two points are conservative screed, and nothing more.



The United States spends the largest portion of its GDP on health care and gets the lowest return out of the major industrialized countries. That is a fact. The quality of the best care is not in question. Were I to get cancer or need a transplant, I would like to be treated in the U.S. The question is of the ability of most people to afford such care. Right now nearly 50 million people have no access to regular medical care, and countless other millions can easily face a problem that results in bankruptcy, something that does not happen in our counterparts. Over 30,000 people die in the U.S. every year because they have no access to regular medical care. It only took 3000 deaths to start two wars and a spending spree that continues unabated. Where is the war on behalf of the people that die for want of a better system?

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 09 Feb 2010, 05:48
by Noyka
[quote name="masturbake"]Fu will either learn about Akane and get bored of it, or he'll keep going. Either way, I dont' really feel the need to get involved.[/quote]



What the hell does Akane have to do with any of this? :huh:



We're just throwing opinions around, nobody is getting upset or anything.



[quote name="Calabaza con Pollo"]
[quote name="Vampire Potter"]
[quote name="Deathrace King"]
[quote name="Noyka"]There is no such thing as a moderate democrat right now, most of them are progressives (or greedy assholes like Landreau and Nelson) masquerading as liberals they just care about their party. I thought it was tactless how some progressives and liberals went after Lieberman's wife because he didn't support the health care bill, they basically forced him to vote for it. Some democrats in the past have been fiscally conservative and socially liberal, that doesn't make them a democrat in name only. There are republicans like that as well, that doesn't make them a republican in name only either. I think the whole party thing is out dated. Republicans lack values just as much as democrats as well.[/quote]



I consider myself a progressive. Most of those Democrats are not progressives. A principled progressive would have co-sponsored HR676, the single payer amendment. I realize that there is a Congressional Progressive Caucus, but all but two members folded when it was time to vote against the private insurance windfall that has been labeled Obamacare, including the self-proclaimed democratic socialist Bernie Sanders. I wish they'd kill both bills and start with the easy stuff. Let's see if any person would vote against forbidding exclusion based on a pre-existing condition, recission and lifetime benefit caps. It would be political suicide to do so. HR676 should be the starting point. With the threat of that, you can probably force the negotiations to result in a system that closely mirrors that of the Swiss and the Dutch. There are no public insurers. Private insurers provide a minimum level of coverage at a near 100% loss ratio, and then make money (and they do), by offering supplemental coverage packages. Really sick people covered by the bare minimum are subsidized.



To address the way Hadassah Lieberman was treated...it was fair. There is an obvious conflict of interest there. The same goes for Evan Bayh's wife, but she has been largely spared from scrutiny.



The political system can only be fixed when the mechanisms that enforce the two-party system are dismantled. More voices are better, to a point. I would like to see mandatory majorities for winning national elections. Instant runoff voting would keep the cost flat. Restricting the money and campaign windows, would be nice as well. It works in other countries. Lastly, I'd like term limits on both senators and representatives. These people get less effective with seniority, not more effective.[/quote]



You honestly believe single payer would be a good option? That option would turn from an option to mandatory for everyone, it's happened in other nations it's possible it'll happen here. Our government has failed at running every other program so why the hell should we trust them with healthcare? With private there is choice, something that should remain. If the coverage is bad in theory you can switch providers. This was lost when we allowed ourselves to have employers decide healthcare for us. There's a lot of tweaks we can make to our system before destroying it with a single payer option. The type of system you're describing would work great if we didn't have such a difference in wealth nationwide. The nations you mentioned, to my knowledge, don't have that big of difference in wealth nationwide. Tort reform is something I think we all can get behind it'd save not only from lawsuits but unnecessary procedures doctors do to prevent lawsuits. We can also work on allowing insurance to be bought across state lines, I know this is tricky but we can start working towards it. Preexisting conditions need to get the boot no question about that everyone deserves access. We need to remember health care is not a right it is a service but all should have the ability to buy it or receive it via medicad/medicare two programs that need serious revamping.



Restricting term limits is something we all can get behind, limiting money spent on campaigns as well.



How was that fair? Everything I read on it made it seem like it was overblown and really trying to get at the senator which was wrong.[/quote]



Medicare is a single-payer program and works great. The payment structure is not very forgiving to primary care doctors, but that can be fixed. The VA works great too. Medicaid is not great, because it is operated by the states. Some do better than others. The existing system is broken. Insurance companies provide no added value. It would be different if every customer for a given insurer was thrown into a single risk pool with a single set of regulation and a mandatory loss ratio of no less than 85%, but that is not the case. Insurance companies get to operate countless risk pools to keep the cost high. They are permitted to have state-wide monopolies on coverage, keeping the costs high. Tort reform is a negligible impact on cost, around 2-3%. I'm also not a big fan. There's no limit as to how bad a doctor or surgeon can fail except mortality. Why limit the right of the victim or victim's family to seek recompense? Allowing insurance policies to be sold across state line will result in bad policies being sold out of states with bad regulation to people that have little other option. Those two points are conservative screed, and nothing more.



The United States spends the largest portion of its GDP on health care and gets the lowest return out of the major industrialized countries. That is a fact. The quality of the best care is not in question. Were I to get cancer or need a transplant, I would like to be treated in the U.S. The question is of the ability of most people to afford such care. Right now nearly 50 million people have no access to regular medical care, and countless other millions can easily face a problem that results in bankruptcy, something that does not happen in our counterparts. Over 30,000 people die in the U.S. every year because they have no access to regular medical care. It only took 3000 deaths to start two wars and a spending spree that continues unabated. Where is the war on behalf of the people that die for want of a better system?[/quote]



Medicare is great? That's funny, no doctor takes it because they don't pay for anything the doctor can't afford to take it and it's going bankrupt. We need to limit frivolous law suits, they cost millions tort reform would save more money than people think so would allowinginsurance to be bough across state lines.



50 million is an inflated number, the real number is more like 15-30 million somewhere in that range. Bringing Iraq into this is really not relevant. It was a huge money pit, we all know that. We all want a better system and there are things we can do with our current system and yes medicad and medicare we don't have to tear it down. You said it yourself our quality is the best in the world and we should try to keep it that way with a few tweaks to our current system. People who don't have access for the most part are still being ignored in things that have been purposed. Obamacare still lets them fall through the cracks. The other thing is why do you want to allow a single entity like the government to control your health? Why shouldn't we encourage more doctor to patient relation and individual choice, less bullshit and lower costs. Private insurance isnt' the demon that some make it out to be.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 09 Feb 2010, 12:18
by Haunty
I think somebody editified my post. :judge:

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 09 Feb 2010, 16:04
by seafoam
[quote name="Calabaza con Pollo"]OR - the Senate needs to revisit its procedural rules. He just put a hold on something like 70 judicial nominees, and will relent until he gets a ransom. Specifically, he wants the much talked about $40 billion in-air refueling tanker deal with EADS to move forward, and he wants another $45 million for a FBI facility. Seriously, why is it that one senator can obstruct a nomination indefinitely? These are supposed to be thumbs up/thumbs down matters regardless of who is in power. Flesh out the nominee's qualifications and then have a vote. Indefinite holds and the filibuster need to go. It allows one side to decide that doing nothing is the new norm.[/quote]



heil hitler

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 09 Feb 2010, 20:24
by Meat Engine
[quote name="The White Bitch"]Medicare is great? That's funny, no doctor takes it because they don't pay for anything the doctor can't afford to take it and it's going bankrupt. We need to limit frivolous law suits, they cost millions tort reform would save more money than people think so would allowinginsurance to be bough across state lines.



50 million is an inflated number, the real number is more like 15-30 million somewhere in that range. Bringing Iraq into this is really not relevant. It was a huge money pit, we all know that. We all want a better system and there are things we can do with our current system and yes medicad and medicare we don't have to tear it down. You said it yourself our quality is the best in the world and we should try to keep it that way with a few tweaks to our current system. People who don't have access for the most part are still being ignored in things that have been purposed. Obamacare still lets them fall through the cracks. The other thing is why do you want to allow a single entity like the government to control your health? Why shouldn't we encourage more doctor to patient relation and individual choice, less bullshit and lower costs. Private insurance isnt' the demon that some make it out to be.[/quote]



Doctors still take Medicare. You'll notice that I said compensation for primary care doctors needs to be improved. Right now the structure is too weighted towards specialists. Right now Medicare supports the sector of the population that requires the largest amount of health care dollars per capita. If we went to a single payer system, all the Medicaid dollars will suddenly go into that. All the relatively healthy younger people will start paying paying premiums. Health insurance is one of the basic forms of socialism; single-payer just happens to be the most efficient form of said.



The CBO says 2-3% for tort reform and no more than 5% for opening insurance purchases across state lines. They do not, however, comment on the predictable decline in the quality of coverage. The only way private insurance will ever work is if an insurer is forced to underwrite its policies under one set of regulations, not 50, and if they have to throw everyone they cover into the same risk pool. Set a loss ratio of at least 85%, repeal the statue allowing insurance monopolies, and now you have actual competition. I disagree with the current direction primarily because it does not treat insurance companies like the exaggerated middle men that they are. They add nothing to the process except excessive overhead. That is why single-payer is the superior system. You pick your doctor and treatment. Anyone that says otherwise is lying. The government just deals with the money, and at a much smaller percentage of overhead than a private insurer.

Re: Richard Shelby (R-AL) is a dickhead

Posted: 09 Feb 2010, 21:42
by Abzu
Glenn Beck says fuck you, you are wrong.