Page 1 of 3
Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 23:53
by Grudge
Oscar-winning US filmmaker Oliver Stone says Adolf Hitler was 'enabled by Western bankers'
By Michael Casey (CP) – 1 day ago
BANGKOK, Thailand — Adolf Hitler was a psychopath and a monster but rose to power thanks to big business leaders and other supporters who appreciated his vow to destroy communism and control workers, Hollywood filmmaker Oliver Stone said Monday.
Stone, who is working on a 10-part documentary on the 20th century titled "The Secret History of the United States," said the German dictator was "enabled by Western bankers" and managed to "seduce" Germany's military industrial complex.
"Hitler is a monster. There is no question. I have no empathy for Hitler at all. He was a crazy psychopath," Stone told reporters in the Thai capital. "But like Frankenstein was a monster, there was a Dr. Frankenstein. He is product of his era."
Stone was in Bangkok to give a lecture to high school students on the role of film in peace-building as part of a visit organized by the Vienna-based International Peace Foundation.
He said the aim of his documentary, which two historians are helping him with, was to offer a fuller understanding of the 20th century and how some of those lessons may be relevant to President Barack Obama in 2010.
"What has America become? How can we in America not learn from Germany in the 1930s," the Oscar-winning director asked.
<!-- m -->
http://www.google.com/hostednews/canadi ... oYwU-aV9rg<!-- m -->
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 00:31
by Haunty
This is the same Oliver Stone who thinks J.F.K. was assassinated by some renegade group of gay guys.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 00:39
by Grudge
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 00:40
by Haunty
Check out his movie "JFK" on the subject. I can't remember exactly what he's getting at, but it's something like that.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 00:41
by Grudge
[quote name="HbW"]Check out his movie "JFK" on the subject. I can't remember exactly what he's getting at, but it's something like that.[/quote]
not good enough
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 00:42
by Verbal
JFK was shot. That much we know. Probably a middle-class white male mid 30s lives alone etc. OMG he seemed like such a normal hard-on bearer.
I am a master profiler.
And JFK was poisoned.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 09:55
by Abzu
+1 Magic Bullets (10 Damage, 5 Mana)
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 13:52
by captain twat. IV.
He wasn't?
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 17:52
by Haunty
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]
[quote name="HbW"]Check out his movie "JFK" on the subject. I can't remember exactly what he's getting at, but it's something like that.[/quote]
not good enough[/quote]
Go look it up. If you're going to go throwing his name around like he's got some sort of authority, you ought to know just what he's stood for over the years.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 00:01
by Ninny
Oliver thinks the cubans killed JFK
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 00:03
by Verbal
Oliver probably is JFK.
Or at least killed him.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 00:54
by Grudge
So Hitler wasn't enabled by western bankers then.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 02:05
by Noyka
You know who did inspire the Nazis? Progressives of the early 20th century, it's a mindset that enabled the Eugenics movement and the Nazis definitely took from that and furthered what those assholes were trying to do. I think it's frightening how nobody learns about the Eugenics movement, in fact progressives are often hailed as heroes when they caused untold amount of destruction and pain. If people are kept ignorant we're bound to make the same mistakes and I'm terrified that's what's going to happen.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 06:00
by Abzu
You know who caused the [insert widely accepted evildoer group of the past] to go ahead and [insert big tragedy and atrocity of the past]? It was the [insert group or organization to whom you are opposed for scapegoating]. It's true, just look at history! If you don't believe me, you must be one of them.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 06:12
by Verbal
Absu, I think you are a conspirator.
Like the terminator, but less sexy.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 07:15
by Abzu
MABB conspiracy! :tit:
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 10:36
by Noyka
[quote name="abzu"]You know who caused the [insert widely accepted evildoer group of the past] to go ahead and [insert big tragedy and atrocity of the past]? It was the [insert group or organization to whom you are opposed for scapegoating]. It's true, just look at history! If you don't believe me, you must be one of them.[/quote]
Eugenics movement was a fact, it's not a conspiracy it happened and the nazis did take from it. Your attempt at mocking me just shows you obviously don't know about this movement so please read up on it before trying to brush it off as a conspiracy.
In fact I suggest most on this board do that, you might be surprised what you learn. Progressive isn't a party or a political association it's a mindset that is poisoning many in the western world currently.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 12:07
by jawn galliano
nobody's disputing that institutional eugenics programs were in widespread use throughout the 20th century, it's a plain fact. it's just silly to reduce the whole problem to being a product of evil 'progressives', and it is pretty obvious that is just code for 'liberals'. following from that, it is also just a tad disingenuous as well, considering the majority of states all had eugenics programs, quite a few of those being established in conservative states. the thinly-veiled left/right argument is useless here (and pretty much everywhere else, for that matter).
if this were a religion thread, you'd probably be saying the same except substituting progressives with darwinists, as that argument is a darling with the ID crowd. fun fact, it's also equally wrong in that context too!
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 12:10
by Verbal
Yea, but Eugenics actually happened.
Thus proving my point.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 12:14
by jawn galliano
i knew it! you can never trust those vermonters. unsexy terminators, the whole lot of 'em!
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 12:55
by Noyka
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]nobody's disputing that institutional eugenics programs were in widespread use throughout the 20th century, it's a plain fact. it's just silly to reduce the whole problem to being a product of evil 'progressives', and it is pretty obvious that is just code for 'liberals'. following from that, it is also just a tad disingenuous as well, considering the majority of states all had eugenics programs, quite a few of those being established in conservative states. the thinly-veiled left/right argument is useless here (and pretty much everywhere else, for that matter). a
if this were a religion thread, you'd probably be saying the same except substituting progressives with darwinists, as that argument is a darling with the ID crowd. fun fact, it's also equally wrong in that context too![/quote]
First off progressives are not liberals. In all honesty you lost credibility with me by saying that. It was a movement that happened in the late 1800s to early 1900s. It's a movement that brought us things like minimum wage, unions, eugenics, amongst other things, basically a precursor to the modern progressive movement. You are a moron if you think progressives don't exist in the republican party. Also you seem to think I'm a conservative, I'm not it should be obvious with some of my other beliefs but apparently some people think "OMG THEY UNDERSTAND HISTORY AND SEE HOW THINGS CONNECT OMG THEY MUST BE BAD LETS LABEL THEM CONSERVATIVE THAT INSTANTLY DISCREDITS THEM" which isn't always true. Some conservatives are free thinking individuals, so are some liberals.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 13:08
by cat hallucination
what's the real problem with the progressive movement? i have a lot of thoughts about it, but to me one problem could be when ideals thought up by stoners in a living room are pushed on families and companies who have hundreds and thousands of years of tradition and reasoning behind them. granted, some of the ideas might be good, and the government votes so and passes them as laws, but uh oh...
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 13:50
by jawn galliano
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]nobody's disputing that institutional eugenics programs were in widespread use throughout the 20th century, it's a plain fact. it's just silly to reduce the whole problem to being a product of evil 'progressives', and it is pretty obvious that is just code for 'liberals'. following from that, it is also just a tad disingenuous as well, considering the majority of states all had eugenics programs, quite a few of those being established in conservative states. the thinly-veiled left/right argument is useless here (and pretty much everywhere else, for that matter). a
if this were a religion thread, you'd probably be saying the same except substituting progressives with darwinists, as that argument is a darling with the ID crowd. fun fact, it's also equally wrong in that context too![/quote]
First off progressives are not liberals. In all honesty you lost credibility with me by saying that. It was a movement that happened in the late 1800s to early 1900s. It's a movement that brought us things like minimum wage, unions, eugenics, amongst other things, basically a precursor to the modern progressive movement. You are a moron if you think progressives don't exist in the republican party. Also you seem to think I'm a conservative, I'm not it should be obvious with some of my other beliefs but apparently some people think "OMG THEY UNDERSTAND HISTORY AND SEE HOW THINGS CONNECT OMG THEY MUST BE BAD LETS LABEL THEM CONSERVATIVE THAT INSTANTLY DISCREDITS THEM" which isn't always true. Some conservatives are free thinking individuals, so are some liberals.[/quote]
um, first, if you're going to try and paint progressives as these horrid inhumane monsters, you might not want to list minimum wages and unions alongside eugenics as their worst transgressions. i understand there are valid criticisms of both in our current post-industrial society, but it's hard to argue they were a bad thing during the run-up of industrialization. but that's all a bit moot.
my point is this: whether you like it or not, in the context you're using it, progressivism (liberalism, conservatism, x-ism blah blah blah) is a (are all) loaded term(s) with pretty well established implications. even if it's not your intent, it still comes across as arguing on the basis of political affiliation, which is a pretty empty starting point for an argument, especially given the nature of party politics in the US. political affiliations are meaningless because progressive in 2010 doesn't necessarily mean what it did in 1910, and you'd probably be hard pressed to find an overwhelming consensus on what that means in either period anyway.
if you're going to make history the basis of your position, you need to go a little further than saying certain people who identify themselves a certain way advocate such and such, and they basically spawned these guys who are hanging around doing something now (which is apparently bad, i guess, whatever it is?). at best, we can get an idea of what that term meant at a certain point of time. there's a whole mess of social, economic, and political factors that contribute to the course of events, and which all need to be examined in context if you're going to get anywhere. examine the motivations and influences behind things like the eugenics movement.
its just lucky its 2:20AM and i have class in the morning and don't have time to elaborate on every last little thing running through my head right now, this shit was about to get real. thousand word essay on a message board type real.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 18:26
by Abzu
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]nobody's disputing that institutional eugenics programs were in widespread use throughout the 20th century, it's a plain fact. it's just silly to reduce the whole problem to being a product of evil 'progressives', and it is pretty obvious that is just code for 'liberals'. following from that, it is also just a tad disingenuous as well, considering the majority of states all had eugenics programs, quite a few of those being established in conservative states. the thinly-veiled left/right argument is useless here (and pretty much everywhere else, for that matter).
if this were a religion thread, you'd probably be saying the same except substituting progressives with darwinists, as that argument is a darling with the ID crowd. fun fact, it's also equally wrong in that context too![/quote]
Yeah, this. And, Noykerz, you should know better than to think I am mocking you.
Plus I am the sexy terminators.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 18:28
by Abzu
[quote name="Noyka"]It's a movement that brought us things like
minimum wage,
unions, eugenics, amongst other things, basically a precursor to the modern progressive movement.[/quote]
Those bastards!

Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 18:54
by captain twat. IV.
Describe your deffinition of progressive.I think you two (no,not you abzu) have something mixed up.It seems Noyka is speeking of something clearly rational and F.M is coming from an entirely different perspective.
??
I'll throw in my two cents later.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 28 Jan 2010, 21:21
by jawn galliano
yes, if you would read my post i am coming from the perspective that blaming the atrocities of the 20th century on an ill-defined political affiliation which maybe kinda sorta defines a group of people who weren't actually an organized group of people, is pointless and doesn't actually tell us anything about why things happened, it only clues you in a little more on the 'what' part.
noyka is coming from the perspective of, progressives, therefore eugenics and nazis. this perspective is wrong because it doesn't tell us anything of substance. if you're going to harp on about how you understand history, you have to actually demonstrate it and not cop out by saying 'progressives did it!'. that may be true, but what use is it?
look at it this way: we all know the nazis were responsible for the holocaust, is the take-away lesson from WW2 supposed to be, don't allow nazis anymore? i think you know as well as i do this isn't a real solution. it's also pretty much the only one that follows from the argument 'progressives are bad and did bad things and inspired the nazis!'.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 03:26
by Noyka
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]nobody's disputing that institutional eugenics programs were in widespread use throughout the 20th century, it's a plain fact. it's just silly to reduce the whole problem to being a product of evil 'progressives', and it is pretty obvious that is just code for 'liberals'. following from that, it is also just a tad disingenuous as well, considering the majority of states all had eugenics programs, quite a few of those being established in conservative states. the thinly-veiled left/right argument is useless here (and pretty much everywhere else, for that matter). a
if this were a religion thread, you'd probably be saying the same except substituting progressives with darwinists, as that argument is a darling with the ID crowd. fun fact, it's also equally wrong in that context too![/quote]
First off progressives are not liberals. In all honesty you lost credibility with me by saying that. It was a movement that happened in the late 1800s to early 1900s. It's a movement that brought us things like minimum wage, unions, eugenics, amongst other things, basically a precursor to the modern progressive movement. You are a moron if you think progressives don't exist in the republican party. Also you seem to think I'm a conservative, I'm not it should be obvious with some of my other beliefs but apparently some people think "OMG THEY UNDERSTAND HISTORY AND SEE HOW THINGS CONNECT OMG THEY MUST BE BAD LETS LABEL THEM CONSERVATIVE THAT INSTANTLY DISCREDITS THEM" which isn't always true. Some conservatives are free thinking individuals, so are some liberals.[/quote]
um, first, if you're going to try and paint progressives as these horrid inhumane monsters, you might not want to list minimum wages and unions alongside eugenics as their worst transgressions. i understand there are valid criticisms of both in our current post-industrial society, but it's hard to argue they were a bad thing during the run-up of industrialization. but that's all a bit moot.
my point is this: whether you like it or not, in the context you're using it, progressivism (liberalism, conservatism, x-ism blah blah blah) is a (are all) loaded term(s) with pretty well established implications. even if it's not your intent, it still comes across as arguing on the basis of political affiliation, which is a pretty empty starting point for an argument, especially given the nature of party politics in the US. political affiliations are meaningless because progressive in 2010 doesn't necessarily mean what it did in 1910, and you'd probably be hard pressed to find an overwhelming consensus on what that means in either period anyway.
if you're going to make history the basis of your position, you need to go a little further than saying certain people who identify themselves a certain way advocate such and such, and they basically spawned these guys who are hanging around doing something now (which is apparently bad, i guess, whatever it is?). at best, we can get an idea of what that term meant at a certain point of time. there's a whole mess of social, economic, and political factors that contribute to the course of events, and which all need to be examined in context if you're going to get anywhere. examine the motivations and influences behind things like the eugenics movement.
its just lucky its 2:20AM and i have class in the morning and don't have time to elaborate on every last little thing running through my head right now, this shit was about to get real. thousand word essay on a message board type real.[/quote]
Later I'll bring you specific people, right now I'm hard pressed for time. Margaret Sanger is my favorite of the progressives/eugenics movement to show how far some of these people went. I can also use John Holdrin as a modern example of how far some progressives (not liberals) want to go now. Really I'm just ranting, I have no issues with liberals or conservatives and I have friends on both sides of the aisle. The thing is most people have forgotten what progressives were and to a point still are and I get frustrated with people for this. To me it's black and white but like you pointed out most don't think like that, I wouldn't expect them to. People call Obama a progressive, I'm not so sure he is. There's a big line between liberal and progressive and yes some of his policies could be considered progressive but I'm not sure.
Sorry for going off on you Abzu, I've had a long last two days

Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 03:30
by Noyka
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]yes, if you would read my post i am coming from the perspective that blaming the atrocities of the 20th century on an ill-defined political affiliation which maybe kinda sorta defines a group of people who weren't actually an organized group of people, is pointless and doesn't actually tell us anything about why things happened, it only clues you in a little more on the 'what' part.
noyka is coming from the perspective of, progressives, therefore eugenics and nazis. this perspective is wrong because it doesn't tell us anything of substance. if you're going to harp on about how you understand history, you have to actually demonstrate it and not cop out by saying 'progressives did it!'. that may be true, but what use is it?
look at it this way: we all know the nazis were responsible for the holocaust, is the take-away lesson from WW2 supposed to be, don't allow nazis anymore? i think you know as well as i do this isn't a real solution. it's also pretty much the only one that follows from the argument 'progressives are bad and did bad things and inspired the nazis!'.[/quote]
That's not what I'm saying. I'm saying people started in with the progressive movement, they started the framework of government should take care of you the government can decide things for you. Somehow their good intentions went into the territory of we can decide who lives and even who breeds. Therefore eugenics got started and people like Margaret Sanger (the founder of Planned Parenthood) furthered it. Their failed attempt didn't cause nazis but it did influence them some. Some American progressives were talking about perfecting some of the methods the nazis used (I'll get specific people later). You seem to think I'm an irrational right winger when it's clear you have no idea what I'm trying to say.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 03:36
by Verbal
What the tit is a progressive?
And while you're at it, what's a liberal?
What the hell do these types of words mean!?
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 03:51
by Redd
Don't you dare bring tits into this, Johnny.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 03:54
by Verbal
And while you're at it.
And while you're a tit.
Homophonic clauses!
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 04:00
by Redd
The tits are innocent. Leave them alone!
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 06:40
by Noyka
Progressives:
Self-identified progressives are more supportive of government intervention in the
economy, both in terms of regulating business and redistributing income, than the general
public. (government take overs and bailouts)
Progressives are protective of civil liberties. (criminals getting more rights than victims)
When asked to choose between equality and freedom a majority of progressives say that
equality is more important. (Redistribution of wealth and Affirmative action)
Progressive tend to support government efforts to safeguard the environment. (and costing thousands of jobs see California's Dust Bowl)
Progressives are less religious on average than other ideological groups. (not always true, global warming and environmentalism is their religion")
Progressives tend to be unwilling to tolerate government regulation of morality. (Except if you disagree with them)
Progressives tend to have positive views of immigrants. (Illegal immigrants, screw those who come in the legal way)
Progressives are committed to diplomacy as the cornerstone of foreign policy.
Progressives tend to be better educated and to earn more money than the average
respondent. (and they're not afraid to brag about it to cover their own short falls)
Liberals and Conservatives:
http://www.studentnewsdaily.com/other/c ... l-beliefs/
Libertarian:
http://catb.org/~esr/faqs/libertarianism.html
Nobody believes 100% what any of these political belief systems do. Err most people don't but there's your general idea.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 06:56
by Verbal
[quote name="Redd"]The tits are innocent. Leave them alone![/quote]
Since when are you an expert!
(ZING.)
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 07:02
by Verbal
[quote name="Noyka"]Progressives:
Self-identified progressives are more supportive of government intervention in the
economy, both in terms of regulating business and redistributing income, than the general
public. (government take overs and bailouts)
Progressives are protective of civil liberties. (criminals getting more rights than victims)
When asked to choose between equality and freedom a majority of progressives say that
equality is more important. (Redistribution of wealth and Affirmative action)
Progressive tend to support government efforts to safeguard the environment. (and costing thousands of jobs see California's Dust Bowl)
Progressives are less religious on average than other ideological groups. (not always true, global warming and environmentalism is their religion")
Progressives tend to be unwilling to tolerate government regulation of morality. (Except if you disagree with them)
Progressives tend to have positive views of immigrants. (Illegal immigrants, screw those who come in the legal way)
Progressives are committed to diplomacy as the cornerstone of foreign policy.
Progressives tend to be better educated and to earn more money than the average
respondent. (and they're not afraid to brag about it to cover their own short falls)
Liberals and Conservatives:
http://www.studentnewsdaily.com/other/c ... l-beliefs/
Libertarian:
http://catb.org/~esr/faqs/libertarianism.html
Nobody believes 100% what any of these political belief systems do. Err most people don't but there's your general idea.[/quote]
I tried to read that, but I can't. I realise that I asked. But nothing bores me as much as that kind of shit.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 07:08
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
you know Noyka, before I loaded up the MABB, I thought to myself, "I really hope I don't have to read a post comparing Planned Parenthood to Nazi eugencists"
and you FUCKING DID IT ANYWAY
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 07:56
by Noyka
[quote name="Chaohinon"]you know Noyka, before I loaded up the MABB, I thought to myself, "I really hope I don't have to read a post comparing Planned Parenthood to Nazi eugencists"
and you FUCKING DID IT ANYWAY[/quote]
I wasn't comparing planned parenthood to Nazi Eugenics however Margaret Sanger definitely supported eugenics, have you read anything about her at all? The ties are undeniable.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 07:59
by Verbal
What's "planned parenthood"?
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 08:01
by Abzu
Likely an anti-abortionist slant on it. I'll have to read later.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 08:02
by Noyka
[quote name="Johnny"]What's "planned parenthood"?[/quote]
The largest family planning institute in America. They do abortions, woman's health, and provide birth control to people. For all the good they do they do a lot of bad as well.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 08:03
by Verbal
What bad do they do?
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 08:31
by Noyka
Some doctors associated with them have done late term abortions. Also they push abortion as a birth control option instead of actually educating people.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 08:38
by Abzu
[quote name="Noyka"]Some doctors associated with them have done late term abortions. Also they push abortion as a birth control option instead of actually educating people.[/quote]
bullllllllllllllshit
I've been a few of these places and they offer both birth control and education (in literature and conversations between doctors and patients). I've never witnessed nor heard of them pushing abortion as a birth control option - just the opposite. Additionally, "Some doctors associated with them," does not denote the organization doing bad.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 08:46
by Noyka
[quote name="abzu"]
[quote name="Noyka"]Some doctors associated with them have done late term abortions. Also they push abortion as a birth control option instead of actually educating people.[/quote]
bullllllllllllllshit
I've been a few of these places and they offer both birth control and education (in literature and conversations between doctors and patients). I've never witnessed nor heard of them pushing abortion as a birth control option - just the opposite. Additionally, "Some doctors associated with them," does not denote the organization doing bad.[/quote]
Funny:
302.6 million is made from abortions for Planned Parenthood that is 1/3 of their income. Oh and 265 million comes from the government, 1/3 of their income....so much for being "non profit".
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 10:40
by jawn galliano
nonprofit in short means they don't pay dividends to shareholders. nonprofit organizations still need to meet their operating costs, and income in excess of that can be used to expand. how on earth would a nonprofit business be a viable model if they were categorically forbidden from making any money at all?
i have no idea where the notion that people are advocating for abortion as a legitimate form of birth control comes from, and i have a seriously difficult time imagining there's a shred of truth to that. if this were commonplace, do you think they'd be receiving $265,000,000 in federal funds? if it were happening even in isolated cases, do you think it wouldn't have made it to the media already and erupted into a tremendous clusterfuck of a scandal? you know, complete with congressional investigations and all that good stuff?
also, re: late term abortions, weren't there only like 3 people in the entire country performing those, and only in extreme circumstances, and also one of those very few was murdered not so long ago? you make it sound like there's some vast and shadowy network of underground abortologists doing that shit on the regular
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 10:45
by Verbal
I agree. It's completely insane to think that anybody would recommend abortion over contraception as a form of birth control.
Of course if someone can show me evidence of that this actually happens, I will gladly eat one of my hats.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 10:54
by Noyka
Of course they aren't advocating for abortions as birth control out right but the fact they make such a huge profit on it is no coincidence. This is teaching people who are in poverty to not take responsibility for themselves it is teaching them to not value life. I can't understand why that is acceptable.
A non profit group shouldn't have 1/3 of their income from the government and the government grants increased as private donations decreased. They are not a governmental organization that's what I was saying so much for non profit to. I've worked with a non profit group for a while and hope to work with them more so I have limited experience with them.
Tiller didn't do them for extreme situations he did late term abortions for any reason. That is the one who was shot. I know I have read stories of late term abortions being practiced at Planned PArenthood providers, I'm not sure what the circumstances are and I know there are only 2 doctors left who do late term abortions now.
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 11:01
by Verbal
[quote name="Noyka"]Of course they aren't advocating for abortions as birth control out right[/quote]
Then why did you just say they did?
[quote name="Noyka"]but the fact they make such a huge profit on it is no coincidence. This is teaching people who are in poverty to not take responsibility for themselves it is teaching them to not value life. I can't understand why that is acceptable.[/quote]
What?
[quote name="Noyka"]A non profit group shouldn't have 1/3 of their income from the government and the government grants increased as private donations decreased. They are not a governmental organization that's what I was saying so much for non profit to. I've worked with a non profit group for a while and hope to work with them more so I have limited experience with them.[/quote]
Why shouldn't they get government money?
Re: Oliver Stone: "Adolf Hitler was enabled by Western bankers"
Posted: 29 Jan 2010, 11:10
by Noyka
[quote name="Johnny"]
[quote name="Noyka"]Of course they aren't advocating for abortions as birth control out right[/quote]
Then why did you just say they did?
[quote name="Noyka"]but the fact they make such a huge profit on it is no coincidence. This is teaching people who are in poverty to not take responsibility for themselves it is teaching them to not value life. I can't understand why that is acceptable.[/quote]
What?
[quote name="Noyka"]A non profit group shouldn't have 1/3 of their income from the government and the government grants increased as private donations decreased. They are not a governmental organization that's what I was saying so much for non profit to. I've worked with a non profit group for a while and hope to work with them more so I have limited experience with them.[/quote]
Why shouldn't they get government money?[/quote]
I said they advocate for abortion as a form of birth control. It's more a behind the closed doors sort of thing, to out right do it would make people uncomfortable but they sure as hell will take money from it. They think people are stupid and can't figure things out.
They make a huge profit on abortion. Planned Parenthood clinics are in low income areas and most people who receive helps are lower income.
They shouldn't get as much government money as planned parenthood gets. This makes it not a non-profit group pretending to be a non-profit group. Sure other non-profit groups get grants and what not but no where near the amount planned parenthood gets. 1/3 of the 865 million they make annually.