Page 1 of 3

If you could press a button

Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 23:18
by Ninny
If you could press a button and receive a million dollars but a total stranger dies, what would you do?



1/ Press the button, receive $1000,000, the total stranger dies



2/ Not press the button, not receive $1000,000, the total stranger lives

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 23:20
by zim
..i would probably do it

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 23:23
by Ninny
Are you sure?

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 23:28
by zim
a complete stranger with no connection to my family, someone i've never or probably would have never met. or ever hear of their death when it happened, maybe.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 23:31
by Hugo.
I would be tempted, but it's the kind of hing that could come back and bite you in the ass.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 00:26
by ANGEL OF DESEASE
this thread is interesting, and could sounds easy answering , but is not.



I think that the death of a person we absolutely don't know could not let us feel real pain. If someone say that suffer from the death of a total unknow person is just an hypocrite imo.

But anyway, my soul says me that life in general >> money, so I would not be quiet to enjoy money but knowing that someone is dead for this.



Option 2 for the hey oh dee. :santa:

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 01:41
by rhino
option 2. although being a "millionaire" does sound appealing but i think things would go wrong, life would turn easy but also too weird with family and friends, and people wanting to be your "fellating lover", and i really couldnt do with knowing my greed has made someone die and their family members suffer, dont think i could live a peaceful life knowing that

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 02:44
by Teresa
I'd push the fuck out of it.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 02:50
by D.O.A.
absolutely not

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 03:33
by jawn galliano
the idealist in me says no, but the unemployable and almost homeless pragmatist in me says push the shit out of that button

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 04:02
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="Teresa"]I'd push the fuck out of it.[/quote]

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 04:10
by Verbal
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]the idealist in me says no, but the unemployable and almost homeless pragmatist in me says push the shit out of that button[/quote]



I take it that financial aid thing didn't go to plan?

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 04:11
by supa tuna
ummm, fucking 1

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 04:12
by Verbal
And this question depends on a lot of things. And I don't really care anyway.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 04:46
by FUKKET
".....you push button #1 and the stranger is.... YOU!"



:twlightzone: :redneck:

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:02
by zim
[quote name="FUKKET"]".....you push button #1 and the stranger is.... YOU!"



:twlightzone: :redneck:[/quote]



:thingy: :lol:

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:05
by Noyka
I wouldn't press it, murder isn't worth any amount of money.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:07
by Verbal
There could be a situation where you would change your mind on that.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:24
by jawn galliano
[quote name="Johnny"]
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]the idealist in me says no, but the unemployable and almost homeless pragmatist in me says push the shit out of that button[/quote]



I take it that financial aid thing didn't go to plan?[/quote]



it did (although it was a smaller award than i was supposed to get), but disbursement takes a while, and i still owe rent for this month which was due weeks ago :redneck:

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:26
by Noyka
[quote name="Johnny"]There could be a situation where you would change your mind on that.[/quote]



Some beliefs are strong enough where no situation can change them

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:30
by Verbal
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="Johnny"]There could be a situation where you would change your mind on that.[/quote]



Some beliefs are strong enough where no situation can change them[/quote]



Bullshit. That is, assuming the person's brain is functioning at an at-least-average level.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:32
by FUKKET
this is a killer thread!











:pun-intended: :redneck: :rshot:

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:37
by Noyka
[quote name="Johnny"]
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="Johnny"]There could be a situation where you would change your mind on that.[/quote]



Some beliefs are strong enough where no situation can change them[/quote]



Bullshit. That is, assuming the person's brain is functioning at an at-least-average level.[/quote]



You sir are full of shit if you honestly think we're all so weak that our beliefs will change for money. Murder for self defense (depending on the situation, this is a very grey area) is one thing but for money? That's a whole different thing that I honestly believe most people who value life would never stoop to. It's not idealistic or naive to think this so don't give me that.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:47
by Verbal
You actually need me to conjure up a hypothetical situation for you?

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:49
by Redd
Liz, don't bother. Johnny's values are completely distorted, so distorted that it's acceptable for him to kill someone for a few pieces of paper.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:55
by Verbal
How about somebody who's homeless and sick and has a daughter who is only 12 but is working as a prostitute. Also has all kinds of diseases that are readily treatable if they could afford medication. Including food treatment for the starvation. Also, her baby son is gone past crying as he is too weak.



Would you actually think less of that person for pushing that button for even a fraction that amount?

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:58
by Redd
Makes more sense to me to eliminate the conditions that created that terrible situation in the first place -- and not just for one person/small group of people but for everyone.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:00
by Verbal
That wasn't an option though, was it?

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:15
by Redd
Improving peoples' lives while harming none is always an option.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:17
by Noyka
"give a man a fish. feed him for a day; teach a man to fish, feed him for life"

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:19
by supa tuna
give a man a million dollars, he won't need anything else every again.



you know.



cause he'll have A MILLION DOLLARS

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:19
by jawn galliano
sure, as long as you're really, really, really narrow with your definition of 'harm'



and probably a bit loose with the meaning of 'none'

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:25
by Redd
[quote name="dickzilla"]give a man a million dollars, he won't need anything else every again.



you know.



cause he'll have A MILLION DOLLARS[/quote]



Let's put him on a deserted island with no fresh water, no food, no resources, oh and no communication to the outside world plus no one is looking for him. But he still has his million dollars. He'll have fun trying to live.



@ FM:

Give me your definition of "harm" and "none" then.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:27
by Verbal
[quote name="Redd"]Improving peoples' lives while harming none is always an option.[/quote]



While I disagree with that, it still doesn't necessarilyt answer the question.



You seriously cannot think of a hypothetical situation where you would push the button? No one really knows what they'd do in these ridiculous scenarios, but I think it's naive to not think there is a situation where you could be swayed into pushing it.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:28
by Noyka
[quote name="dickzilla"]give a man a million dollars, he won't need anything else every again.



you know.



cause he'll have A MILLION DOLLARS[/quote]



What happens if the currency suddenly changes and all paper money is considered worthless? He has a million pieces of paper.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:28
by Verbal
[quote name="Noyka"]"give a man a fish. feed him for a day; teach a man to fish, feed him for life"[/quote]



That, apart from being completely banal, has absolutely nothing to do with the question.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:28
by Verbal
Oh sweet Jesus.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:32
by djonni greazo
1. no fucking doubt about it. random person dies so i get 1mil?! fuck yeah... there's thousands of random people dying every day, one more will make no difference you "moral high ground" retards

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:33
by Verbal
Redd, the fact you can makeup a difficult situation where the money would be useless is irrelevant.



There obviously are situations where pushing the button would solve the problems. Even less money would. The point is that there surely is, for anybody, a conceivable situation where they would press the button.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:33
by cat hallucination
no, unless i knew who the stranger was and they wanted to be euthanized or were scheduled to be fried on the chair that day.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:34
by zim
some people just need to die :die:

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:34
by Verbal
[quote name="cat hallucination"]no, unless i knew who the stranger was[/quote]



Did you just say that?



EDIT: Okay, I suppose the word stranger wasn't very clearly defined.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:36
by Redd
[quote name="Johnny"]Redd, the fact you can makeup a difficult situation where the money would be useless is irrelevant.



There obviously are situations where pushing the button would solve the problems. Even less money would. The point is that there surely is, for anybody, a conceivable situation where they would press the button.[/quote]



You missed my point. What people need is resources, not pieces of paper. And getting a million dollars is not solving a problem of poverty -- that is patchwork. Let's say a tornado rips through a town and destroys every home in it, but the homes are rebuilt the same exact way -- that is patchwork. But if you build the homes lower into the ground and make them dome shaped, THAT is problem solving.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:37
by cat hallucination
well let me answer your question with another question, "is charles manson a stranger to you?"

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:38
by Verbal
[quote name="Redd"]
[quote name="Johnny"]Redd, the fact you can makeup a difficult situation where the money would be useless is irrelevant.



There obviously are situations where pushing the button would solve the problems. Even less money would. The point is that there surely is, for anybody, a conceivable situation where they would press the button.[/quote]



You missed my point. What people need is resources, not pieces of paper. And getting a million dollars is not solving a problem of poverty -- that is patchwork. Let's say a tornado rips through a town and destroys every home in it, but the homes are rebuilt the same exact way -- that is patchwork. But if you build the homes lower into the ground and make them dome shaped, THAT is problem solving.[/quote]



That has nothing to do with the question though.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:39
by Verbal
[quote name="cat hallucination"]well let me answer your question with another question, "is charles manson a stranger to you?"[/quote]



I corrected myself.



I edited my post.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:39
by Redd
You are missing my point, Johnny. Just because it's not a "yes" or a "no" to the original question doesn't mean that it's not relevant.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:42
by cat hallucination
right, just sayin' though. totally random selection.

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:43
by rhino
shut the fuck up gleeso

Re: If you could press a button

Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 06:44
by Verbal
[quote name="Redd"]You are missing my point, Johnny. Just because it's not a "yes" or a "no" to the original question doesn't mean that it's not relevant.[/quote]



It's completely irrelevant to the question about whether you could conceive a situation, etc. where you would push the button.