Page 1 of 1
The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 20 Jan 2010, 03:15
by Grudge
And Nouriel Roubini had been warning about it for some time now. Japan Airlines, Asia's biggest carrier just went bankrupt and 15,600 jobs were lost. A lot of banks are still in a mess. Are you bummed out that just when you thought you had weathered the worst of it, it's going to get bad again? Is Obama (the communist) responsible for it all when he spread socialism far and wide and made Marxism a state policy? Is it the Federal Reserve? What are your opinions?
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 20 Jan 2010, 03:23
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
economic turmoil is the result of the state colluding with business to impose insurmountable barriers of entry upon anyone wanting to engage in commerce. This forces most would-be entrepreneurs to become wage-slaves, who have little or no recourse in the event that their employer makes a dumb decision that affects job security (which is often, as most big-time employers are utterly detached from any sort of market limitations)
Kevin Carson outlines how this works in the healthcare world -
Open Source Healthcare. Repeat ad nauseum for every industry imaginable.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 20 Jan 2010, 03:26
by Grudge
You know that's a goddamn lie.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 22 Jan 2010, 04:39
by neckred
government's #1 priority is itself, regardless who is in power and regardless of what is said

oh snaps
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 10:30
by Abzu
I feel that for capitalism to truly flourish, it needs to be a partially controlled environment. Competition and diversity need to be allowed.
Perhaps a system should be developed modeling after biodiversity seen in nature. Can evolutionary models be applied to economics?
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 23 Jan 2010, 10:44
by cat hallucination
i read something about migrating bird flock patterns being applied to economics.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 04:03
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="abzu"]I feel that for capitalism to truly flourish, it needs to be a partially controlled environment. Competition and diversity need to be allowed.
Perhaps a system should be developed modeling after biodiversity seen in nature. Can evolutionary models be applied to economics?[/quote]lol
regulation stifles competition
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 05:48
by jawn galliano
yeah, it's a good thing that with a complete absence of regulation, firms can never grow too powerful to use their market position to prevent others from entering and competing.
you seem to be forgetting that capitalists don't care about capitalism, they care about accumulating the most power possible. once they have sufficient resources to buy out competitors and raise the barriers of entry, they will do so every goddamned time if they're allowed.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 11:37
by cat hallucination
i don't think there's anything wrong with allowing competition, and i think it's good to give aid to people and businesses who are defeated. and you do this by taxing the rich and taxing luxeries and unneccesary products.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 13:47
by Grudge
[quote name="Chaohinon"]regulation stifles competition[/quote]
a) It can also boost competition (anti-monopoly/trust laws, tax exemptions for underdeveloped sectors)
b) See Famous Mortimer's post
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 13:57
by Grudge
[quote name="abzu"]Perhaps a system should be developed modeling after biodiversity seen in nature. Can evolutionary models be applied to economics?[/quote]
Can you elaborate what you mean in this question?
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 24 Jan 2010, 14:05
by cat hallucination
something that i don't like at all is the attitude to "defeat" your competition and "put them out of business." it's immoral and self-defeating. but, putting regulations on that is the same in a way. instead, i think the government should give aid to the defeated.
i think the wild card is money and money only. focus "regulations" on that, with taxes and aid.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 25 Jan 2010, 15:57
by Haunty
Impossible Mission Force

Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 25 Jan 2010, 19:54
by Lavabug
[quote name="Famous Mortimer"]yeah, it's a good thing that with a complete absence of regulation, firms can never grow too powerful to use their market position to prevent others from entering and competing.
you seem to be forgetting that capitalists don't care about capitalism, they care about accumulating the most power possible. once they have sufficient resources to buy out competitors and raise the barriers of entry, they will do so every goddamned time if they're allowed.[/quote]
[/discussion]
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]
[quote name="abzu"]Perhaps a system should be developed modeling after biodiversity seen in nature. Can evolutionary models be applied to economics?[/quote]
Can you elaborate what you mean in this question?[/quote]
I think he wants to draw a similarity between the efforts to preserve endangered species to ensure biodiversity with efforts to save small businesses from getting raped and drowned out by bigger, less fair-competition-loving greedy ones.
*INCOMING TRANSMISSION*:
Insanely retarded post from Uber Grim Retard in 3... 2... 1...
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 10:33
by Abzu
Competition and product/service/business diversity breed innovation and progress. This is also very true in the natural world. The preservation of competition and diversity in the economic world should help to sustain it.
Of course, with finite resources (the planet's mass is not increasing at a noticeable rate [taking into account the negligible mass of NEOs that burn up and sometimes crash], obviously) and a growing population, any growth based economic models are born to fail.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 22:18
by Hugo.
England showed growth of 0.01% in the fourth quarter of 2009. Come on you Engerland

Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 22:20
by Verbal
I probably grew 0.01% in the fourth quarter of 2009.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 23:17
by Grudge
[quote name="abzu"]Competition and product/service/business diversity breed innovation and progress. [/quote]
Competition is but one of the many factors which encourage innovation. Competition, on the other side of the coin, is also destructive. Examples exist of competition being so destructive so as to retard development rather than ensure progress. Also, how does diversity of product/service/business breed innovation? Shouldn't it be the other way round? Innovation breeding diversity of products/services?
[quote name="abzu"]This is also very true in the natural world. The preservation of competition and diversity in the economic world should help to sustain it.[/quote]
The extent of the role played by competition in innovation and evolution in the natural world is disputable. Central to mankind's evolution (aside from obvious genetic advantages) was his social character. Imagine that, if out of competition, men never banded with other men to hunt. No one would learn from the other's experience. No one would learn better techniques. The rate of learning would be very very slow. Survival rates would be limited, average lifespans would be reduced, leaving less of the necessary time to innovate and improve. That would have been a disastrous result of competition wouldn't it? You will also find that the more intelligent species in the animal kingdom will display a tendency to be social and cooperative with other animals belonging to their species.
The wheel was not invented to compete with others. It was invented to traverse faster. Agriculture was not discovered to beat the enemy. It came from studying nature to increase subsistence. Mathematics was not developed with competition in mind either.
Do you need to compete with someone to discover a cure for a disease? Or does the existence of the problem itself necessitate the exertion of mental and physical effort for its resolution?
Who are the scientists at CERN competing against?
Competition thus is not the core stimulus of innovation. It is not the final word.
[quote name="abzu"]Of course, with finite resources (the planet's mass is not increasing at a noticeable rate [taking into account the negligible mass of NEOs that burn up and sometimes crash], obviously) and a growing population, any growth based economic models are born to fail.[/quote]
I think about this often. It all the more necessitates that the economy should be steered according to a central plan, rather than in the anarchic manner it is going on today.
I have read several very informative articles on this very topic. It is a legitimate concern in my eyes. They can be found at Monthly Review.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 23:20
by Mesarthim
capitalism left unchecked. see: Ticketmaster.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 26 Jan 2010, 23:29
by Grudge
Report carried by
Financial Times. Innovation in China will occur through collective scientific research as opposed to occuring from firms competing against each other. An interesting bit carried in this report is that Russia, since becoming capitalist, fell far behind in scientific research (and subsequently, innovation).
China set for global lead in scientific research
<!-- m -->
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/3d0c1606-0a19 ... abdc0.html<!-- m -->
By Clive Cookson in London
Published: January 26 2010 02:00 | Last updated: January 26 2010 02:00
China has experienced the strongest growth in scientific research over the past three decades of any country, according to figures compiled for the Financial Times, and the pace shows no sign of slowing.
Jonathan Adams, re-search evaluation director at Thomson Reuters, said China's "awe-inspiring" growth meant it was now the second-largest producer of scientific knowledge and was on course to overtake the US by 2020 if it continued on its trajectory.
Thomson Reuters , which indexes scientific papers from 10,500 journals, analysed the performance of four emerging markets countries - Brazil, Russia, India and China - over the past 30 years.
China far outperformed every other nation, with a 64-fold increase in peerreviewed scientific papers since 1981, with particular strength in chemistry and materials science.
"China is out on its own, far ahead of the pack," said James Wilsdon, science policy director at the Royal Society in London .
"If anything, China's recent research performance has exceeded even the high expectations of four or five years ago, while India has not moved as fast as expected and may have missed an opportunity."
Although its quality remains mixed, Chinese research has also become more collaborative, with almost 9 per cent of papers originating in China having at least one US-based co-author.
"We are seeing more than the growth of a strong domestic research base," said Mr Adams. "Regional networks of scientific collaboration are developing fast, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region."
Brazil has also been building up a formidable research effort, particularly in agricultural and life sciences. In 1981 its output of scientific papers was one-seventh that of India; by 2008 it had almost caught up with India.
Russia, which has previously been seen as a leader in scientific research, produced fewer papers than Brazil or India in 2008.
Just 20 years ago, on the eve of the Soviet Union's disintegration, Russia was a scientific superpower, carrying out more research than China, India and Brazil combined.
Since then it has been left behind not only by the world-beating growth of Chinese science but also by India and Brazil.
Huge changes in the world's scientific landscape are revealed in the analysis of the output of the four Bric countries since 1981.
According to Mr Wilsdon, three main factors are driving Chinese research. First is the government's enormous investment, with funding increases far above the rate of inflation, at all levels of the system from schools to postgraduate research.
Second is the organised flow of knowledge from basic science to commercial applications. Third is the efficient and flexible way in which China is tapping the expertise of its extensive scientific diaspora in north America and Europe, tempting back mid-career scientists with deals that allow them to spend part of the year working in the west and part in China.
Although the statistics measure papers in peerreviewed journals that pass a threshold of respectability, "the quality [in China] is still rather mixed", said Mr Adams. But it was improving: "They have some pretty good incentives to produce higher quality research in future."
Like China, India has a large diaspora - and many scientifically trained NRIs (non-resident Indians) are returning, but they go mainly into business rather research. "In India there is a very poor connection between high-tech companies and the local research base," said Mr Wilsdon. "Even the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs), the highest level institutions in the system, find it difficult to recruit top faculty."
A symptom of this is the poor performance of India in international comparisons of university standards. The 2009 Asian University Rankings, prepared by the higher education consultancy QS , shows the top Indian institution to be IIT Bombay at number 30; 10 universities in China and Hong Kong are higher.
Part of India's academic problem might be the way red tape tied up its universities, said Ben Sowter, head of the QS intelligence unit. Another issue was that the best institutions were so overwhelmed with applications from would-be students and faculty within India that they do not cultivate the international outlook essential for world-class universities.
This looks set to change as India's human resource minister has stepped up efforts to build links with US and UK institutions.
In contrast to China, India and Russia, whose research strengths tend to be in the physical sciences, chemistry and engineering, Brazil stands out in health, life sciences, agriculture and environmental research.
Of Russia, Mr Adams said: "The issue is the huge reduction in funding for research and development in Russia after the fall down in a giant display of homosexuality of the Soviet Union."
"Although there has been an exodus of many of the rising stars of research, there is still a great pool of talent there.
"It is not in the interests of the rest of the world for the exodus to continue, and we need more co-funding arrangements to help Russian research get back up to speed."
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 03:27
by Redd
[quote name="abzu"]Competition and product/service/business diversity breed innovation and progress. This is also very true in the natural world. The preservation of competition and diversity in the economic world should help to sustain it.
Of course, with finite resources (the planet's mass is not increasing at a noticeable rate [taking into account the negligible mass of NEOs that burn up and sometimes crash], obviously) and a growing population, any growth based economic models are born to fail.[/quote]
And competition over these resources leads to their destruction (if there's less of a resource, the more you can jack the price up). It leads to destruction of the environment -- it's cheaper to dump waste than to dispose of it properly (and it's cheaper to keep using unclean processing methods, you don't have to develop any new technology). Oh, and let's not forget all the human exploitation inherent in this system. Oh... and war.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 08:23
by Abzu
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]Also, how does
diversity of product/service/business breed innovation? Shouldn't it be the other way round? Innovation breeding diversity of products/services?[/quote]
It is cyclical. The diversity and innovation help to perpetuate one another. Look at the tech industry.
[quote name="abzu"]This is also very true in the natural world. The preservation of competition and diversity in the economic world should help to sustain it.[/quote]
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]The extent of the role played by competition in innovation and evolution in the natural world is disputable. Central to mankind's evolution (aside from obvious genetic advantages) was his social character. Imagine that, if out of competition, men never banded with other men to hunt. No one would learn from the other's experience. No one would learn better techniques. The rate of learning would be very very slow. Survival rates would be limited, average lifespans would be reduced, leaving less of the necessary time to innovate and improve. That would have been a disastrous result of competition wouldn't it? You will also find that the more intelligent species in the animal kingdom will display a tendency to be social and cooperative with other animals belonging to their species.[/quote]
The point there is not competition but biodiversity (which carries competition with it as the side note, not the point). Also, if you wish to go into the evolution metaphor deeper, you cannot exclude to simply mankind. Doing that disregards millenia of biological development.
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]Do you
need to compete with someone to discover a cure for a disease? Or does the existence of the problem itself necessitate the exertion of mental and physical effort for its resolution?[/quote]
I do not think you understand the difference between 'requires' and 'encourages'/'fosters'.
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]Competition thus is not the core stimulus of innovation. It is not the final word.[/quote]
It's nicer for your statement to portray mine in some assumed absolutist form, but it just isn't that way.
[quote name="abzu"]Of course, with finite resources (the planet's mass is not increasing at a noticeable rate [taking into account the negligible mass of NEOs that burn up and sometimes crash], obviously) and a growing population, any growth based economic models are born to fail.[/quote]
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]I think about this often. It all the more necessitates that the economy should be steered according to a central plan, rather than in the anarchic manner it is going on today.[/quote]
Imran, I could not agree more, sir.
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]I have read several very informative articles on this very topic. It is a legitimate concern in my eyes. They can be found at Monthly Review.[/quote]
Please direct me!

Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 08:25
by Abzu
[quote name="Redd"]
[quote name="abzu"]Competition and product/service/business diversity breed innovation and progress. This is also very true in the natural world. The preservation of competition and diversity in the economic world should help to sustain it.
Of course, with finite resources (the planet's mass is not increasing at a noticeable rate [taking into account the negligible mass of NEOs that burn up and sometimes crash], obviously) and a growing population, any growth based economic models are born to fail.[/quote]
And competition over these resources leads to their destruction (if there's less of a resource, the more you can jack the price up). It leads to destruction of the environment -- it's cheaper to dump waste than to dispose of it properly (and it's cheaper to keep using unclean processing methods, you don't have to develop any new technology). Oh, and let's not forget all the human exploitation inherent in this system. Oh... and war.[/quote]
How's the weather over there, miles away from my context? That said, I mostly agree with you there.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 08:40
by Redd
I'm saying competition is unhealthy and monetary systems breed destructive behavior.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 08:41
by Abzu
I disagree.
Fighting over something, like a resource, is not good. Fighting in competition with something to simply push forward and enhance oneself is very healthy.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 08:44
by Redd
So in health class yesterday, we were doing a review game where if you answered a question right, your team got points. These two groups got up and started screaming at each other. This was a review game designed to help us, but instead it created negative behavior. Cooperation, not competition, is what we need.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 08:57
by Abzu
[quote name="Redd"]So in health class yesterday, we were doing a review game where if you answered a question right, your team got points. These two groups got up and started screaming at each other. This was a review game designed to help us, but instead it created negative behavior. Cooperation, not competition, is what we need.[/quote]
To make that kind of determination, you need more than one control group. We did something similar when I was in school and there was no such behavior. We all just pushed harder to answer correctly. The variable causing the aggressive element may not be competition itself, but something in the students.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 09:11
by Redd
Yes, I do agree that we need more variables, but also your conditions when you were growing up matter as well: were you rich? were you poor? did your parents instill certain beliefs about competition into you? or was it your teachers that did that? etc. But I highly doubt that it's some other aggressive attribute in them. In a competitive/monetary system you get ahead when you throw your friends under the bus. The more ruthless you are, the farther you get ahead. In other words: negative behavior is rewarded.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 09:16
by Abzu
[quote name="Redd"]Yes, I do agree that we need more variables, but also your conditions when you were growing up matter as well: were you rich? were you poor? did your parents instill certain beliefs about competition into you? or was it your teachers that did that? etc. But I highly doubt that it's some other aggressive attribute in them. In a competitive/monetary system you get ahead when you throw your friends under the bus. The more ruthless you are, the farther you get ahead. In other words: negative behavior is rewarded.[/quote]
My class was relatively well mixed insofar as economic level goes.
The point is that competition was not the factor.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 09:20
by Redd
Maybe not in your class, but when I say competition is detrimental I mean generally. This is just one teeny tiny little group.
Re: The IMF chief is warning of a second recession
Posted: 27 Jan 2010, 09:26
by Abzu
and I say thee nay.