Page 1 of 1
What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 12:58
by Grudge
To me, unnatural is a very unnecessary term.
1) Tall buildings, city centers, smoking factory chimneys, asphalt on the ground, these are all categorized as unnatural. A bird's nest should also be considered unnatural then, as would a beehive.
2) Humans are nature's children, and we are following all it's rules of survival, adaptation, propagation. Our environment affects us, and we affect it, just like all creatures. We speed up chemical reactions inside laboratories, we create 'synthetic' materials. Nature does these things in its own way too.
3) Since when did the bricks, the roads, the steel with which we construct urban environments (that are called unnatural) cease to be comprised of natural elements? There isn't anything we create that isn't fashioned out of something that wasn't already there, and the creations of humans are comprised most certainly of elements that occur in nature.
By no means is this an 'anti-environment' post. I fully understand the importance of a healthy eco-system.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 13:01
by SlowRanco
what
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 13:04
by Grudge
please reduce the size of that photo Slowranco.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 13:24
by cat hallucination
this is an environmental ethics issue. the article addressed the blurry difference between what is "natural" and "unnatural". why is it better to be natural than unnatural? the universe evolved into humans, who created the unnatural. but, what is the meaning, and what is the problem in this question?
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 13:30
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
To be judged on a case-by-case basis
A simple road usually isn't a problem. However, releasing pollutants, as far as I'm concerned, isn't that far off from detonating a nuke, and should be resisted thus.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 13:33
by Grudge
Again, this isn't the issue, which should have been clear when I stated that this not about 'anti-environmentalism'.
Ofcourse the eco-system should be preserved. Ofcourse this involves restricting destruction of forests, and emission of pollutants.
I'm just talking about the term, 'unnatural'.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 14:01
by Noyka
[quote name="Chaohinon"]To be judged on a case-by-case basis
A simple road usually isn't a problem. However, releasing pollutants, as far as I'm concerned, isn't that far off from detonating a nuke, and should be resisted thus.[/quote]
This might seem dumb but:
What exactly do you consider pollutants?
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 14:07
by Lavabug
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]Again, this isn't the issue, which should have been clear when I stated that this not about 'anti-environmentalism'.
Ofcourse the eco-system should be preserved. Ofcourse this involves restricting destruction of forests, and emission of pollutants.
I'm just talking about the term, 'unnatural'.[/quote]
People just use "unnatural" for simplification. Buildings and roads are anthropogenic in their origin, they aren't assembled by natural geological processes. Synthetic would be more accurate, but w/e. Atoms are atoms, we can separate and refine them to fit our needs, but in the end they all come from a core of an exploded star, a natural process.
It would be more accurate to say the arrangement of matter in a city is unnatural, but all the elements used to construct it are indeed a product of nature as you put it.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 14:12
by jawn galliano
yeah, but organic doesn't really have much meaning either. it was formerly used to distinguish compounds produced by living organisms from nonliving compounds, the assumption being that organic compounds could only be synthesized by living things. that assumption was shot down quite a long time ago (18th century maybe?)
i agree completely with imran here, i've always found the natural/unnatural dichotomy to be a bit silly. it's all composed of the same handful of molecular building blocks found throughout the universe. if something can demonstrably exist within nature, what's unnatural about it?
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 14:30
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="Noyka"]
[quote name="Chaohinon"]To be judged on a case-by-case basis
A simple road usually isn't a problem. However, releasing pollutants, as far as I'm concerned, isn't that far off from detonating a nuke, and should be resisted thus.[/quote]
This might seem dumb but:
What exactly do you consider pollutants?[/quote]Christians, Jews, etc.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 16:47
by Holocaust
[quote name="Skinfection"]would you say tv's were natural?[/quote]
Ultimately, yes.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 18:09
by Lavabug
If you want to get extremely literal, then yes everything in the universe down to the subatomic is natural, after all it is part/product of nature. But most of the matter in the universe is just hydrogen thrown about, not a refinement of heavier elements like the compounds in our electrical appliances, buildings, etc. I think most people use the term unnatural for the sake of simplicity.
Of the 15 definitions I found, this one is the most relevant to the use of "natural" in this thread:
12 b : of, relating to, or operating in the physical as opposed to the spiritual world <natural laws describe phenomena of the physical universe>
the assumption being that organic compounds could only be synthesized by living things. that assumption was shot down quite a long time ago (18th century maybe?)
Yep, urea, 19th century I think.
Also on a related note: I question the idea that everything that falls under the category "natural" is intrinsically good. Tsunamis, cosmic rays and earthquakes are natural processes, and so are many toxins you can inhale just from walking into a cave. :pedanticcunt:
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 18:54
by baron von blondle
I'm a confirmed hippie. I like walking on grass, I hate cities after a matter of hours, modern life sucks massive balls.
BUT
what if it's ALL natural? an humanity is a plague, a virus on this great green earth and is ultimately the cancer that will kill it prompting natures great cycle to continue unabated to the next phase.
my tuppenceworth
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 20:08
by Lavabug
Species have gone extinct over the ages and have been replaced by newer dominant ones, but no previous animal had nuclear fission, a developed energy infrastructure, or a massive materials/chemical industry. Any of these used irresponsibly can make life impossible on the earth forever.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 20:34
by Hugo.
[quote name="Lavabug"]Species have gone extinct over the ages and have been replaced by newer dominant ones, but no previous animal had nuclear fission, a developed energy infrastructure, or a massive materials/chemical industry. Any of these used irresponsibly can make life impossible on the earth forever.[/quote]
Infrstructure is the key word here. I like this thread.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 21:38
by baron von blondle
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]Species have gone extinct over the ages and have been replaced by newer dominant ones, but no previous animal had nuclear fission, a developed energy infrastructure, or a massive materials/chemical industry. Any of these used irresponsibly can make life impossible on the earth forever.[/quote]
Infrstructure is the key word here. I like this thread.[/quote]
Earth is a mere pimple in the huge natural (proposed) scheme of things, your nuclear fission and ensuing infrastructure nothing more than a solitary crabs fart bubble in an ocean of possibility.
think OUTSIDE the box human.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 21:47
by Verbal
I could not possibly agree more with Imran.
Sure, people can choose to mean whatever they want by "natural" and "unnatural", but any splitting of things into these two categories seems meaningless.
Like, if we make a "synthetic" "unnatural" drug to treat some condition, or are to consider surgery to be "unnatural", then why don't you also consider a m.onkey picking fleas off another m.onkey, or using a stone to crack a coconut, to be doing something "unnatural" also. If you do, at least you're being consistent. . but what's our point? What's the point of the distinction?
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 18 Nov 2009, 23:16
by Hugo.
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]Species have gone extinct over the ages and have been replaced by newer dominant ones, but no previous animal had nuclear fission, a developed energy infrastructure, or a massive materials/chemical industry. Any of these used irresponsibly can make life impossible on the earth forever.[/quote]
Infrstructure is the key word here. I like this thread.[/quote]
Earth is a mere pimple in the huge natural (proposed) scheme of things, your nuclear fission and ensuing infrastructure nothing more than a solitary crabs fart bubble in an ocean of possibility.
think OUTSIDE the secretary of state cube human.[/quote]
By the grander scheme of things do you mean the universe? The universe to me is a collosal expanse of irrelevance.
:timecube:
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 00:21
by jawn galliano
[quote name="Lavabug"]Also on a related note: I question the idea that everything that falls under the category "natural" is intrinsically good. Tsunamis, cosmic rays and earthquakes are natural processes, and so are many toxins you can inhale just from walking into a cave. :pedanticcunt:[/quote]
seriously, there's all kinds of all-natural stuff out there that is absolutely terrible. datura, ricin, all sorts of venoms, shit man.
i love bringing things like those up to people who go on tirades about natural medicine is so much better than all the artificial lab-developed stuff. unfortunately most of them have no idea what datura or ricin are, so it winds up being mostly for my own amusement :(
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 01:07
by Verbal
There once was a discussion about caesarean section births versus normal vaginal delivery. The question was whether it would actually be safest for everyone to have planned C-sections. When I asked whether this would be the case or not, the fact that normal vaginal delivery is more "natural" was put forward as a reason in it's favour. A reason why it should obviously be the preferred method. This to me is completely insane. Putting aside the fact that I think calling one method more "natural" than the other is meaningless at best, obviously the only way to decide which method is safer would be to do a proper study on the issue. Experiment and see which is better. The thought that one is better, or even more likely to be better, because it's "natural" is completely infuriating.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 01:10
by Grudge
'Unnatural' is unscientific.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 01:22
by baron von blondle
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
By the grander scheme of things do you mean the universe? The universe to me is a collosal expanse of irrelevance.
:timecube:[/quote]
I can assure you that you are far more irrelivent to the universe and it's bigger than you or your dad.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 01:40
by jawn galliano
not cool man, leave the parents out of this!
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 01:49
by Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm-Flailing Tube Man
[quote name="Johnny"]There once was a discussion about caesarean section births versus normal vaginal delivery. The question was whether it would actually be safest for everyone to have planned C-sections. When I asked whether this would be the case or not, the fact that normal vaginal delivery is more "natural" was put forward as a reason in it's favour. A reason why it should obviously be the preferred method. This to me is completely insane. Putting aside the fact that I think calling one method more "natural" than the other is meaningless at best, obviously the only way to decide which method is safer would be to do a proper study on the issue. Experiment and see which is better. The thought that one is better, or even more likely to be better, because it's "natural" is completely infuriating.[/quote]
calm the fuck down son
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 02:55
by Hugo.
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
By the grander scheme of things do you mean the universe? The universe to me is a collosal expanse of irrelevance.
:timecube:[/quote]
I can assure you that you are far more irrelivent to the universe and it's bigger than you or your dad.[/quote]
Debatable.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 04:18
by baron von blondle
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
By the grander scheme of things do you mean the universe? The universe to me is a collosal expanse of irrelevance.
:timecube:[/quote]
I can assure you that you are far more irrelivent to the universe and it's bigger than you or your dad.[/quote]
Debatable.[/quote]
please do
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 05:04
by Noyka
[quote name="Chaohinon"]
[quote name="Noyka"]
This might seem dumb but:
What exactly do you consider pollutants?[/quote]Christians, Jews, etc.[/quote]
I'm sigging this
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 05:31
by Lavabug
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
Earth is a mere pimple in the huge natural (proposed) scheme of things, your nuclear fission and ensuing infrastructure nothing more than a solitary crabs fart bubble in an ocean of possibility.
think OUTSIDE the secretary of state cube human.[/quote]
Sense.
Could you please make some?
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 17:55
by baron von blondle
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
Earth is a mere pimple in the huge natural (proposed) scheme of things, your nuclear fission and ensuing infrastructure nothing more than a solitary crabs fart bubble in an ocean of possibility.
think OUTSIDE the secretary of state cube human.[/quote]
Sense.
Could you please make some?[/quote]
translation into panglish for poorly educated simpletons. = "earth is small, universe is big - earth and humans not important. the end".
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 18:26
by Abzu
When you look at it in the context of bees building beehives and people building stripmalls, where it becomes unnatural is where it deviates from the purpose as lain out by other building species.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 18:43
by Grudge
[quote name="abzu"]When you look at it in the context of bees building beehives and people building stripmalls, where it becomes unnatural is where it deviates from the purpose as lain out by other building species.[/quote]
As you have yourself stated, the purpose is decided by the species. Just as we (a species) decide the purpose of our constructs.
Or are we the exception to this rule?
Is the degree of 'naturalness' of our creations to be ascertained by relating it to the creations of other species? This is an arbitrary comparison you are making.
The only conclusion one can derive from your post is that humans are unnatural while everything else is natural, and that is why when a human creates something to suit his purposes it is unnatural, but when an animal does it, it is natural.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 19:25
by Lavabug
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
Earth is a mere pimple in the huge natural (proposed) scheme of things, your nuclear fission and ensuing infrastructure nothing more than a solitary crabs fart bubble in an ocean of possibility.
think OUTSIDE the secretary of state cube human.[/quote]
Sense.
Could you please make some?[/quote]
translation into panglish for poorly educated simpletons. = "earth is small, universe is big - earth and humans not important. the end".[/quote]
Because we know for certain the universe is filled with billions of civilizations/life right? Are you insinuating we should not care for the fate of the human race/the earth just because of the universe's relative volume?
The earth might as well be the only inhabitable planet. You could do without the condescending tone and make an effort in posting something decent.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 20:11
by Verbal
I have no idea what absu meant by that post.
And I can't even think of a good point he could possibly be making.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 21:33
by baron von blondle
[quote name="Lavabug"]
Because we know for certain the universe is filled with billions of civilizations/life right? Are you insinuating we should not care for the fate of the human race/the earth just because of the universe's relative volume?
The earth might as well be the only inhabitable planet. You could do without the condescending tone and make an effort in posting something decent.[/quote]
to answer all your questions - no.
Mankinds arrogance and self important attitude in believing it is the top of the tree and the cause of all things natural and unnatural is it's ultimate downfall. are we cleverer than ants? unknown, but in our ignorance we assume we are smarter as we have i-phones and vaccinations. also to consider this dimension of existence the be all and end all also shows stunning ignorance and inability to progress past circuits and concrete.
again put simply for fear of being read wrong - humility can teach us a lot of things and putting more effort into serious issues like population control, preservation of natural habitats may well reinstate mankind into a more successful existence on the earth as part of the cycle of nature.
HOWEVER
to reiterate once more. Mankind could well be the intended natural downfall of the earth and that's not such a terrible thing to consider as it also slots us nicely back into natures plan..therefore destiny is progressing as it should.
smile, it aint all that bad.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 19 Nov 2009, 22:45
by TamPron
I AM 11
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 08:07
by Abzu
[quote name="ManOfSteel"]
[quote name="abzu"]When you look at it in the context of bees building beehives and people building stripmalls, where it becomes unnatural is where it deviates from the purpose as lain out by other building species.[/quote]
As you have yourself stated, the purpose is decided by the species. Just as we (a species) decide the purpose of our constructs.
Or are we the exception to this rule?
Is the degree of 'naturalness' of our creations to be ascertained by relating it to the creations of other species? This is an arbitrary comparison you are making.
The only conclusion one can derive from your post is that humans are unnatural while everything else is natural, and that is why when a human creates something to suit his purposes it is unnatural, but when an animal does it, it is natural.[/quote]
That's not what I said. I said we deviate from the general building purpose of other building species. They all merely build different versions of the same idea - custom habitation. We build beyond that.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 08:08
by Abzu
[quote name="Johnny"]I have no idea what absu meant by that post.
And I can't even think of a good point he could possibly be making.[/quote]
It is an answer to the initial question of what is natural or unnatural. I am sorry you cannot understand it.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 12:00
by cat hallucination
i read through the rest of the thread and i'm not going to address any of it. the natural vs. unnatural debate is clearly ambiguous. its only good for personal values. until of course it reaches laws and policies, which then include governed personal values, and freedom of choice, and constriction of carelessness, and all that other bullshit that wouldn't be necessary if people would just drop religion and act responsibly, and fairly, and honestly, which probably won't ever fully happen.

Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 17:56
by Abzu
[quote name="cat hallucination"]i read through the rest of the thread and i'm not going to address any of it. the natural vs. unnatural debate is clearly ambiguous. its only good for personal values. until of course it reaches laws and policies, which then include governed personal values, and freedom of choice, and constriction of carelessness, and all that other bullshit that wouldn't be necessary if people would just drop religion and act responsibly, and fairly, and honestly, which probably won't ever fully happen.

[/quote]
'It's only good for personal values until it has to do with things other than personal'. Retard.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 19:50
by Hugo.
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]
Because we know for certain the universe is filled with billions of civilizations/life right? Are you insinuating we should not care for the fate of the human race/the earth just because of the universe's relative volume?
The earth might as well be the only inhabitable planet. You could do without the condescending tone and make an effort in posting something decent.[/quote]
to answer all your questions - no.
Mankinds arrogance and self important attitude in believing it is the top of the tree and the cause of all things natural and unnatural is it's ultimate downfall. are we cleverer than ants? unknown, but in our ignorance we assume we are smarter as we have i-phones and vaccinations. also to consider this dimension of existence the be all and end all also shows stunning ignorance and inability to progress past circuits and concrete.
again put simply for fear of being read wrong - humility can teach us a lot of things and putting more effort into serious issues like population control, preservation of natural habitats may well reinstate mankind into a more successful existence on the earth as part of the cycle of nature.
HOWEVER
to reiterate once more. Mankind could well be the intended natural downfall of the earth and that's not such a terrible thing to consider as it also slots us nicely back into natures plan..therefore destiny is progressing as it should.
smile, it aint all that bad.[/quote]
We're just as arrogant and self important as any other species.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 23:15
by baron von blondle
[quote name="MorbidAngle"]
[quote name="baron von blondle"]
[quote name="Lavabug"]
Because we know for certain the universe is filled with billions of civilizations/life right? Are you insinuating we should not care for the fate of the human race/the earth just because of the universe's relative volume?
The earth might as well be the only inhabitable planet. You could do without the condescending tone and make an effort in posting something decent.[/quote]
to answer all your questions - no.
Mankinds arrogance and self important attitude in believing it is the top of the tree and the cause of all things natural and unnatural is it's ultimate downfall. are we cleverer than ants? unknown, but in our ignorance we assume we are smarter as we have i-phones and vaccinations. also to consider this dimension of existence the be all and end all also shows stunning ignorance and inability to progress past circuits and concrete.
again put simply for fear of being read wrong - humility can teach us a lot of things and putting more effort into serious issues like population control, preservation of natural habitats may well reinstate mankind into a more successful existence on the earth as part of the cycle of nature.
HOWEVER
to reiterate once more. Mankind could well be the intended natural downfall of the earth and that's not such a terrible thing to consider as it also slots us nicely back into natures plan..therefore destiny is progressing as it should.
smile, it aint all that bad.[/quote]
We're just as arrogant and self important as any other species.[/quote]

Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 20 Nov 2009, 23:29
by cat hallucination
that wasn't put together well. oh well, i'm not going to explain it.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 21 Nov 2009, 01:16
by Verbal
Absu, I think you are talking shite.
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 21 Nov 2009, 08:04
by Abzu
[quote name="Johnny"]Absu, I think you are talking shite.[/quote]

Care to calculate the probability of me talking shit based on who I am talking to?
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 21 Nov 2009, 20:37
by ANGEL OF DESEASE
Natural is having 24 and not needing Viagra, Unnatural is having 24 and needing Viagra. All the rest is ash and dust.
jesus jesus jesus
Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 21 Nov 2009, 20:47
by bills bro
24? is this your age?

Re: What is natural? What is unnatural?
Posted: 21 Nov 2009, 20:58
by ANGEL OF DESEASE
I am 24 yes, why?