American conservatives and liberals
Posted: 15 Nov 2009, 00:15
Red vs. Dittohead
By J. Slavyanski
....
I can still remember those days, when I would religiously listen to conservative talk radio, soaking up every pithy argument like a sponge, believing in a conspiratorial ‘liberal media’, and honing my arguments against hypothetical ‘liberal’ opponents in my head. It also really helps when there are no “liberals” around to challenge you. Oh yes dear audience, the owner of this blog was a red-white-and-blue ‘dittohead’ for several years. Then puberty kicked in and I grew out of it. Yes that’s right, I was a conservative back when I was about 11 to 14, and in reality that is a pretty logical time to be a conservative. Conservatism, I have come to realize many years later, is an ideology for children, rooted in certain qualities that children typically have, namely ignorance. It entails black and white, good and evil thinking over critical analysis, and ‘common sense’ to actual expertise and critical thought.
Conservatism, as it is followed by the masses, is in fact an ideology of ignorance and cowardice. Liberals often characterize conservatism as overly “macho” or masculine, but this is only because liberals are openly cowardly and submissive. In short, liberals are worthless, because anything accurate or worthwhile that they say is always contradicted by their lack of solutions, which in turn stems from their unrealistic idealism. If you need any more proof of how weak liberals are, notice how liberals in America are afraid to even call themselves liberals; for the last four or five years they have been referring to themselves as “progressives”, because they have let conservatives beat them over the head senseless with that word “liberal”. But conservatives are themselves cowards. For all their tough talk, conservatives are generally fearful people, deathly afraid that countries like North Korea, Iraq, or Iran are going to murder them or at least upset their kids’ soccer games. They want some tough-talking president to send out the US military into random nations and hunt down these bogeymen, sometimes literally believing the mind-boggling slogan, ‘fight them in Baghdad or fight them in Boston!’ They have little to no experience of the world outside their borders, and fear what they can’t understand.
Another testament to conservative cowardice and their desire for protection is their obsession with the military. This goes beyond the “support our troops” rhetoric. I’m talking about the kind of mindset that inspires some conservative shut-in to write chain e-mails about Jane Fonda telling a class of god-fearing school children that Islam is the only true religion, when suddenly a US Marine, who just returned from active duty in Iraq, comes in and punches her teeth out as the students stand up and recite the Pledge of Allegiance with the words ‘under God’ in it. Granted, part of these people’s obsession with the military may very well be due to latent homosexuality (2), and the military certainly provides them endless material for their personal fantasies. But homoeroticism aside, I believe that their obsession with the soldier is the need for a protector. For all their talk about liberals wanting government to be a “mommy” or “daddy”, these people want someone in a uniform with a gun to go overseas and kill all those scary foreigners; Muslims, Serbs, or any other group of people the government says is trying to “take America’s freedom”. This and a lot of the most vocal conservatives never served in the military, and thus have no idea how mundane and ridiculously boring the military is. The fact is that “defending America’s freedom” generally means standing around doing nothing, drinking heavily, playing Playstation, and coming up with hilarious nicknames for people in your unit. (3) When the military is overseas, they are doing anything but defending America’s freedom; usually it’s taking away some other countries ‘freedom’.
So thus we have the basic conservative outlook; fearful, cowardly, terrified of foreign nations be they Muslim, Latin American, or European. But we must add to this a conspiratorial element. Conservative claims don’t really hold up well to facts, which means they need someone to blame when they are told that in fact, Iraq is not a democratic paradise. Their answer is “the liberal media.” Yes, that same media that cheered on the war in Iraq all the way, until they noticed it wasn’t too popular any more, is “liberal”. One might ask; isn’t it in the eye of the beholder whether there is a ‘liberal slant’ to the media? Not in the case of conservatives. They are constantly fed a conservative viewpoint from the army of pundits and cable news, and are simultaneously told that anything that contradicts or fails to support their claims is the result of liberal bias. This is nothing but a widespread conspiracy theory. In reality, the mainstream media is as “liberal” or “conservative” as it needs to be on any given issue in order to serve the interests of its owners and their class. They supported the Iraq war because it meant big ratings and profits, and they ‘apologized’ when they realized that it was getting unpopular. Already it seems they’re getting ready for another major “fuck up” with Iran, and I’ll bet they’re already preparing their apology for when that war turns sour.
What this all boils down to, is that conservatives are fed a certain worldview, and when little inconvenient things like facts come in and spoil the party, these facts are alleged to be some part of a global “liberal” conspiracy. Conservatives generally lack the necessary basic knowledge to debate any of these facts; but rather they allege that the facts of their opponents come from “liberals” or that they are “politically correct” facts, in other words they should be ignored. There are a number of other conservative sources that specifically attempt to reveal the “truth” about something that is supposedly being suppressed by “political correctness”, whatever the fuck that really means.
For example there is the Politically Correct Guide to Islam. I remember skimming this thing a few years ago, and according to the bullet points on the back, I learned to my surprise that the scientific advances in the Islamic world during the Middle Ages were actually inherited mainly from Ancient Greece and Rome. No shit, I thought to myself, not so much due to specific knowledge of Middle Eastern history, but a simple understanding that virtually all science and technology is inherited from somewhere. This is like pissing on all of America’s achievements simply because it grew out of the British empire. It is true that some times certain Muslims try to claim all credit for the scientific achievements of that age, but this is beside the point. The point is that Muslims embraced the science and technology of the Classical era while Europeans, under the direction of the Church, were suppressing and literally destroying it in some cases. Still this is no particular credit to Islam. The book also claimed that Islam conflicts with science, and only Christianity and Judaism are compatible with science. That must really reassure Earl Pickens in Bubbafuck, Georgia that his efforts to get ‘Intelligent Design’ into the public schools is righteous, but it’s simply not true. Islam, Christianity, Judaism, and a whole host of other religions are not compatible with science, and that includes Scientology. Without digressing too far, this illustrates a certain aspect of the conservative mindset. Their pundits are constantly revealing new ‘facts’ to them, and anything outside this realm of ‘facts’ is ‘politically correct’. The implication is that these things are untrue, yet the average conservative lacks the ability to actually substantiate their claims. They rely on pundits to hand them talking points, which they bark out and repeat incessantly. This is why when I see a book like Ann Coulter’s How to Talk to a Liberal, I long to see someone take the book’s advice to heart and attempt to speak with an actual liberal or left-winger, just for the entertainment value.
The extent to which this kind of follower mentality reaches is also illustrated by the various “party line” shifts one can observe with these people. When I was still in the US, I used to listen to talk radio to see what they were up to, and these shifts were very noticeable. The first was during the run up to the war, when conservatives were sure that Americans could simply not wait for the inspectors to finish their searches for weapons (after being invited back in by Hussein), because this hard-on bearer was going to gas America or worse. Every possible doomsday scenario was echoed from the White House, including references to a “mushroom cloud” over America. Now naturally if a country is really amassing such an arsenal, you should find a trace of something fairly soon after conquering it and taking its capital city. More realistically, we should expect such a country to use its unconventional weapons from the moment such an invasion, since that is the whole point of having them in the first place. But of course such weapons didn’t exist, and the pundits clearly anticipated this. They began ‘shifting the base of fire’, claiming that the invasion was never about Weapons of Mass Destruction, but about the Iraqi people’s ‘freedom’. Now a person with normally function reasoning skills would ask, ‘what the hell was all this crap about mushroom clouds, aluminum tubes, and yellow cake, for then?’ One might also ask why the ‘freedom’ of Iraqi people in particular is so important to the US, and why at that time. Conservatives don’t notice this, however, as their capacity for memory and critical thought has been broken down. They take what Limbaugh or Hannity hands them one day, and never remember what he was saying a few months prior. Later, folks like Hannity would claim that weapons were actually found, that they were moved to another country (which makes literally no sense), or sometimes both interchangeably. Internal contradictions are generally missed by the conservative audience.
To rational people who pay attention, the selling point of this war was that Iraq was an imminent threat. Bush, Cheney, Rice, Wolfowitz et al, were videotaped numerous times making these claims about a number of issues related to Iraq. Virtually every claim they made about Iraq was flat out wrong. Let me repeat that: Virtually every claim these people made about Iraq is not only indisputably wrong, but they could be proven wrong with information that was available at the time. Of course conservatives don’t want to admit this; they want to claim that the war was about Iraqi “freedom”, and occasionally they want to claim that they found the weapons as well. The reason behind this is that they simply fail to question the people from whence their information comes. Is it just a coincidence that folks like Sean Hannity or Rush Limbaugh happen to be experts on virtually any issue that comes down the pipe? One day they are economists, the next day they are military strategists, and on another they are experts in Middle Eastern history. Conservative audiences don’t notice this. ATTENTION CONSERVATIVE READERS: Next time you are listening to your favorite talk-radio show host, ask yourself whether it is strange that a hard-on bearer with a degree in broadcasting seems to have a concise answer on virtually any topic, no matter how far outside is area of expertise, and why he is so confident about attacking people with actual credentials in the relevant fields. Doesn’t that seem a little odd?
The key to understanding complicated issues like Middle Eastern politics or history isn’t by listening to some hard-on bearer on the radio who got his start by spinning records and taking song requests. When you want to find out about something, you go out and you start usually at a library or bookstores and read. And you don’t just read anything; you check the author’s background, his affiliations, you try to read at least more than one work from that author, and check his bibliography. If you seriously want to gain sound knowledge on some subject, you read several authoritative books on the same subject. Conservatives failure to do this explains one reason why I have failed to find any conservative willing to carry on a debate about certain issues for quite some time; you bring up some fact about the issue they are discussing, and they are blindsided. Hannity never told them about this, Limbaugh never explained it to them, so they end up spitting out random lines of text with no substantiation. And that brings us to the inspiration for this article.
I haven’t had much desire to communicate online or even update this blog lately, and the once-popular no-holds-barred Phora died, giving way to The Lyceum. On the latter someone posted a link to this conservative blog entitled The Astute Bloggers. The story was a very strange comparison between Hitler’s Amerika Bomber and radical Islamist hatred of New York. If the term Islamofascist tells you anything, it is that conservatives have been falling over their own collective ass trying to equate radical Islam with Fascism and the Nazis. The irony of this of course, is that conservatives in the 30s and 40s were isolationists who didn’t want America to get involved in the war. I left a comment pointing out that while there were genuine connections between Islam and the Third Reich, this had more to do with political considerations. The Nazis found themselves in a war with the British Empire, and a great number of its subjects in key regions were Muslim. It is because of this fact that the Nazis did not limit their support to Muslims; they were also supporting the Hindu nationalists in India as well. If anyone wants to point a finger at a religion associated with the Nazis, we would have to look at Christianity, since both Catholic and Protestant Christian leaders were crucial to the rise of National Socialism and Fascism in Europe. Well I didn’t get a response to this, but as I checked back in again and again, I began to see some other bizarre stories. I learned for example, that Vladimir Putin is a ‘socialist’, or that the US has ‘won’ in Iraq, but the liberal media and the Democrats don’t realize it. So I began dropping a few more comments, and yes they were deliberately provocative. It’s just that when I see someone disseminating such unbelievable nonsense, I want to see them defend it in their own words. That’s when I finally received a reply…
By J. Slavyanski
....
I can still remember those days, when I would religiously listen to conservative talk radio, soaking up every pithy argument like a sponge, believing in a conspiratorial ‘liberal media’, and honing my arguments against hypothetical ‘liberal’ opponents in my head. It also really helps when there are no “liberals” around to challenge you. Oh yes dear audience, the owner of this blog was a red-white-and-blue ‘dittohead’ for several years. Then puberty kicked in and I grew out of it. Yes that’s right, I was a conservative back when I was about 11 to 14, and in reality that is a pretty logical time to be a conservative. Conservatism, I have come to realize many years later, is an ideology for children, rooted in certain qualities that children typically have, namely ignorance. It entails black and white, good and evil thinking over critical analysis, and ‘common sense’ to actual expertise and critical thought.
Conservatism, as it is followed by the masses, is in fact an ideology of ignorance and cowardice. Liberals often characterize conservatism as overly “macho” or masculine, but this is only because liberals are openly cowardly and submissive. In short, liberals are worthless, because anything accurate or worthwhile that they say is always contradicted by their lack of solutions, which in turn stems from their unrealistic idealism. If you need any more proof of how weak liberals are, notice how liberals in America are afraid to even call themselves liberals; for the last four or five years they have been referring to themselves as “progressives”, because they have let conservatives beat them over the head senseless with that word “liberal”. But conservatives are themselves cowards. For all their tough talk, conservatives are generally fearful people, deathly afraid that countries like North Korea, Iraq, or Iran are going to murder them or at least upset their kids’ soccer games. They want some tough-talking president to send out the US military into random nations and hunt down these bogeymen, sometimes literally believing the mind-boggling slogan, ‘fight them in Baghdad or fight them in Boston!’ They have little to no experience of the world outside their borders, and fear what they can’t understand.
Another testament to conservative cowardice and their desire for protection is their obsession with the military. This goes beyond the “support our troops” rhetoric. I’m talking about the kind of mindset that inspires some conservative shut-in to write chain e-mails about Jane Fonda telling a class of god-fearing school children that Islam is the only true religion, when suddenly a US Marine, who just returned from active duty in Iraq, comes in and punches her teeth out as the students stand up and recite the Pledge of Allegiance with the words ‘under God’ in it. Granted, part of these people’s obsession with the military may very well be due to latent homosexuality (2), and the military certainly provides them endless material for their personal fantasies. But homoeroticism aside, I believe that their obsession with the soldier is the need for a protector. For all their talk about liberals wanting government to be a “mommy” or “daddy”, these people want someone in a uniform with a gun to go overseas and kill all those scary foreigners; Muslims, Serbs, or any other group of people the government says is trying to “take America’s freedom”. This and a lot of the most vocal conservatives never served in the military, and thus have no idea how mundane and ridiculously boring the military is. The fact is that “defending America’s freedom” generally means standing around doing nothing, drinking heavily, playing Playstation, and coming up with hilarious nicknames for people in your unit. (3) When the military is overseas, they are doing anything but defending America’s freedom; usually it’s taking away some other countries ‘freedom’.
So thus we have the basic conservative outlook; fearful, cowardly, terrified of foreign nations be they Muslim, Latin American, or European. But we must add to this a conspiratorial element. Conservative claims don’t really hold up well to facts, which means they need someone to blame when they are told that in fact, Iraq is not a democratic paradise. Their answer is “the liberal media.” Yes, that same media that cheered on the war in Iraq all the way, until they noticed it wasn’t too popular any more, is “liberal”. One might ask; isn’t it in the eye of the beholder whether there is a ‘liberal slant’ to the media? Not in the case of conservatives. They are constantly fed a conservative viewpoint from the army of pundits and cable news, and are simultaneously told that anything that contradicts or fails to support their claims is the result of liberal bias. This is nothing but a widespread conspiracy theory. In reality, the mainstream media is as “liberal” or “conservative” as it needs to be on any given issue in order to serve the interests of its owners and their class. They supported the Iraq war because it meant big ratings and profits, and they ‘apologized’ when they realized that it was getting unpopular. Already it seems they’re getting ready for another major “fuck up” with Iran, and I’ll bet they’re already preparing their apology for when that war turns sour.
What this all boils down to, is that conservatives are fed a certain worldview, and when little inconvenient things like facts come in and spoil the party, these facts are alleged to be some part of a global “liberal” conspiracy. Conservatives generally lack the necessary basic knowledge to debate any of these facts; but rather they allege that the facts of their opponents come from “liberals” or that they are “politically correct” facts, in other words they should be ignored. There are a number of other conservative sources that specifically attempt to reveal the “truth” about something that is supposedly being suppressed by “political correctness”, whatever the fuck that really means.
For example there is the Politically Correct Guide to Islam. I remember skimming this thing a few years ago, and according to the bullet points on the back, I learned to my surprise that the scientific advances in the Islamic world during the Middle Ages were actually inherited mainly from Ancient Greece and Rome. No shit, I thought to myself, not so much due to specific knowledge of Middle Eastern history, but a simple understanding that virtually all science and technology is inherited from somewhere. This is like pissing on all of America’s achievements simply because it grew out of the British empire. It is true that some times certain Muslims try to claim all credit for the scientific achievements of that age, but this is beside the point. The point is that Muslims embraced the science and technology of the Classical era while Europeans, under the direction of the Church, were suppressing and literally destroying it in some cases. Still this is no particular credit to Islam. The book also claimed that Islam conflicts with science, and only Christianity and Judaism are compatible with science. That must really reassure Earl Pickens in Bubbafuck, Georgia that his efforts to get ‘Intelligent Design’ into the public schools is righteous, but it’s simply not true. Islam, Christianity, Judaism, and a whole host of other religions are not compatible with science, and that includes Scientology. Without digressing too far, this illustrates a certain aspect of the conservative mindset. Their pundits are constantly revealing new ‘facts’ to them, and anything outside this realm of ‘facts’ is ‘politically correct’. The implication is that these things are untrue, yet the average conservative lacks the ability to actually substantiate their claims. They rely on pundits to hand them talking points, which they bark out and repeat incessantly. This is why when I see a book like Ann Coulter’s How to Talk to a Liberal, I long to see someone take the book’s advice to heart and attempt to speak with an actual liberal or left-winger, just for the entertainment value.
The extent to which this kind of follower mentality reaches is also illustrated by the various “party line” shifts one can observe with these people. When I was still in the US, I used to listen to talk radio to see what they were up to, and these shifts were very noticeable. The first was during the run up to the war, when conservatives were sure that Americans could simply not wait for the inspectors to finish their searches for weapons (after being invited back in by Hussein), because this hard-on bearer was going to gas America or worse. Every possible doomsday scenario was echoed from the White House, including references to a “mushroom cloud” over America. Now naturally if a country is really amassing such an arsenal, you should find a trace of something fairly soon after conquering it and taking its capital city. More realistically, we should expect such a country to use its unconventional weapons from the moment such an invasion, since that is the whole point of having them in the first place. But of course such weapons didn’t exist, and the pundits clearly anticipated this. They began ‘shifting the base of fire’, claiming that the invasion was never about Weapons of Mass Destruction, but about the Iraqi people’s ‘freedom’. Now a person with normally function reasoning skills would ask, ‘what the hell was all this crap about mushroom clouds, aluminum tubes, and yellow cake, for then?’ One might also ask why the ‘freedom’ of Iraqi people in particular is so important to the US, and why at that time. Conservatives don’t notice this, however, as their capacity for memory and critical thought has been broken down. They take what Limbaugh or Hannity hands them one day, and never remember what he was saying a few months prior. Later, folks like Hannity would claim that weapons were actually found, that they were moved to another country (which makes literally no sense), or sometimes both interchangeably. Internal contradictions are generally missed by the conservative audience.
To rational people who pay attention, the selling point of this war was that Iraq was an imminent threat. Bush, Cheney, Rice, Wolfowitz et al, were videotaped numerous times making these claims about a number of issues related to Iraq. Virtually every claim they made about Iraq was flat out wrong. Let me repeat that: Virtually every claim these people made about Iraq is not only indisputably wrong, but they could be proven wrong with information that was available at the time. Of course conservatives don’t want to admit this; they want to claim that the war was about Iraqi “freedom”, and occasionally they want to claim that they found the weapons as well. The reason behind this is that they simply fail to question the people from whence their information comes. Is it just a coincidence that folks like Sean Hannity or Rush Limbaugh happen to be experts on virtually any issue that comes down the pipe? One day they are economists, the next day they are military strategists, and on another they are experts in Middle Eastern history. Conservative audiences don’t notice this. ATTENTION CONSERVATIVE READERS: Next time you are listening to your favorite talk-radio show host, ask yourself whether it is strange that a hard-on bearer with a degree in broadcasting seems to have a concise answer on virtually any topic, no matter how far outside is area of expertise, and why he is so confident about attacking people with actual credentials in the relevant fields. Doesn’t that seem a little odd?
The key to understanding complicated issues like Middle Eastern politics or history isn’t by listening to some hard-on bearer on the radio who got his start by spinning records and taking song requests. When you want to find out about something, you go out and you start usually at a library or bookstores and read. And you don’t just read anything; you check the author’s background, his affiliations, you try to read at least more than one work from that author, and check his bibliography. If you seriously want to gain sound knowledge on some subject, you read several authoritative books on the same subject. Conservatives failure to do this explains one reason why I have failed to find any conservative willing to carry on a debate about certain issues for quite some time; you bring up some fact about the issue they are discussing, and they are blindsided. Hannity never told them about this, Limbaugh never explained it to them, so they end up spitting out random lines of text with no substantiation. And that brings us to the inspiration for this article.
I haven’t had much desire to communicate online or even update this blog lately, and the once-popular no-holds-barred Phora died, giving way to The Lyceum. On the latter someone posted a link to this conservative blog entitled The Astute Bloggers. The story was a very strange comparison between Hitler’s Amerika Bomber and radical Islamist hatred of New York. If the term Islamofascist tells you anything, it is that conservatives have been falling over their own collective ass trying to equate radical Islam with Fascism and the Nazis. The irony of this of course, is that conservatives in the 30s and 40s were isolationists who didn’t want America to get involved in the war. I left a comment pointing out that while there were genuine connections between Islam and the Third Reich, this had more to do with political considerations. The Nazis found themselves in a war with the British Empire, and a great number of its subjects in key regions were Muslim. It is because of this fact that the Nazis did not limit their support to Muslims; they were also supporting the Hindu nationalists in India as well. If anyone wants to point a finger at a religion associated with the Nazis, we would have to look at Christianity, since both Catholic and Protestant Christian leaders were crucial to the rise of National Socialism and Fascism in Europe. Well I didn’t get a response to this, but as I checked back in again and again, I began to see some other bizarre stories. I learned for example, that Vladimir Putin is a ‘socialist’, or that the US has ‘won’ in Iraq, but the liberal media and the Democrats don’t realize it. So I began dropping a few more comments, and yes they were deliberately provocative. It’s just that when I see someone disseminating such unbelievable nonsense, I want to see them defend it in their own words. That’s when I finally received a reply…
